Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

Posts

Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#1

Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

Threepeatpete

>What do you Ladies and Gents think - at half the cost how do the Oneway grinding wheels compare to the Norton SG wheels? I have a slowspeed Woodcraft grinder and it's time for me to upgrade the stock wheels that came with it....

Thanks in advance!

Pete

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#2

Orange wheels from ...

Ed Moore

>Highland Hardware are not expensive and I like them best. I THINK the brand is "Kinik".

I took a Norton SG off one grinder and replaced it with a Oneway wheel. Good move.

I got a new grinder and put the Kinik on it. Better than either of the two mentioned.

Ed

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#3

Now isn't that strange!

Carole Valentine

>I had an orange wheel from them and didn't like it (don't remember why). Took it off and put on Oneway wheels. LOL Have not tried the Nortons.

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#4

Re: Now isn't that strange!

C.W.Stivison

>Thats what makes the world go around Carol. Everyone is different.

CW

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#5

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton S

ET

>I have used the Oneway slow speed gringing wheel on my Delta 8 in. slow speed grinder for almost a year. I forget the grit size. It seems harder than what ever I used in the past. It holds its shape with use, no problem with dishing. I do like to use a star wheel dresser to clean the surface and roughen it up from time to time. I have just put a Norton SG on my 6 in. hi-speed grinder and have not used it enough to get any opinion formed.

What about those Norton X3 wheels that Craft Supplies sells? Any one have any experience with those?

ET

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#6

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton S

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I tried the Norton SG "I" grade wheels, at $100 each they are expensive plus they are to soft and will form a groove faster than any other wheel. The strong point of the SG wheel is the fact it's a cool running wheel.

I use a 3X to sharpen all the tools to be sold and found sharpeningsupplies.com has the best price for the 8 inch wheels.

One day I would like to try a 3X "I" grade for my own personal tools and retire that green wheel.

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#7

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton S

robo hippy

>After wearing out some white wheels, and some pink ones, I investigated, and found CBN (cubic boric nitride) wheels. Luckily I can get them made here in town. They are 3/16 of CBN bonded onto an aluminum wheel. They are already spin balanced. They can be made any grit that you want. You can't dress them, you have to use an aluminum oxide stick to clean them off. If you have to have them dressed, you have to send them out, or in my case, take them back to the manufacturer. CBN is made for grinding steel, not carbide. I have had my 80 grit wheel for 3 years, and it shows almost no wear. I have had a 320 grit wheel which lasted over a year, but am switching to a 150 grit wheel for the gouges. The down side is that they cost about $300 for an 8 by 1 inch wheel. 3M is getting into them, and any place that grinds a lot of steel should be able to get you in contact with someone who makes them. I will never go back to conventional wheels.

robo hippy

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#8

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton S

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Pete,

I just recently bought the Oneway wheels for my slow speed grinder. I have the Woodcraft slow speed too. I bought mine to replace the white wheels that came on the grinder. Not so much that I didn't like them... although they did load up pretty fast.. but to get the one inch hole in the wheels for the balancing system Oneway sells.

So far I am really impressed. I teach a class at Woodcraft and part of the deal is they get a gouge included in the price. The gouges are in pretty sad shape when I get them, so I take them to my shop to re-profile and re-shape them before the class. The Oneway wheels do not were a grove in them easily. I have re-ground about eight of them in the last couple of weeks with no apparent grooving of the wheel. And believe me, I am removing a lot of material to make these gouges acceptable. So for me, they are a good investment. But I have no experience with the SC wheels. But if they are twice as good as the Oneway wheels, that would be something!!

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#9

3X grade that you use

Michael Stadulis, in Gloucester County, NJ

>Doug,

what hardness grade of the 3X would you suggest I order?

Mike

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#10

Re: 3X grade that you use

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I use a K grade (hard) to sharpen the tools for sale, a 46 grit on the bowl gouges and a 80 grit on the spindle tools. IMO - The "K" is not the ideal wheel to use at home and they are only sold in the course grits.

I never tried the 3X "I" grade for my personal tools. One day I'll buy a 100 & 120 grit and see what is the best for my turning tools. Right now I use a 100-120 green wheel (for carbide) on a 6 inch grinder that is NOT recommended for any turning tools.

So the answer is... I don't know what I would recommend but I'll never spend a 100 bucks on a wheel again.

This would be a good test to set up say 6 tools ground with different wheels and see what works the best.

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#11

Re: 3X grade that you use

Bill Howatt

>Right now I have the white wheels from LV which I find groove very easily. When they are done the original gray wheels are going back on the grinder for a try. Some report that they work just fine for HSS so I'm going to see what my experience is.

Bill

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton SG

#12

Re: Grinding Wheel Comparison - Oneway vs Norton S

steve worcester

>I have used the Oneways for quite some time. Used the camel pink wheels, which work well for the money, then after going through a few Oneways, tried the Norton SG and then went back to the Oneways. The SGs I had seemed way too soft and needed frequest dressing as well as made a heck of a mess if i needed to do some reprofiling.

So, Oneways for me.