Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

skew chisel grind

Posts

skew chisel grind

#1

skew chisel grind

eliot d

>Does anyone have an opinion about grinding a skew WITHOUT a hollow grind? I believe most turners use a wheel, so there will be a hollow. But clearly some sharpening methods will produce a flat -- and even a convex -- grind. I vaguely remember reading that there are some who actually have a preference for a convex grind. What, if anything , would be the advantage of a flat or a convex grind?

Re: skew chisel grind

#2

Re: skew chisel grind

Mike Brazeau

>Before I had a decent grinder, I flat ground my skews on my belt sander and found that they made lots of catches just like when I concave grind them on the grinder now. I didn't see any radical difference in performance. I have ground an old 1/2 Carbon steel skew with the convex grind, as promoted by Eli Avisera, and found it remarkabley catch free. I used it for a bunch of pens in the spring and found it quite enjoyable to use. To grind the convex grind, you freehold and let it ride up and down the wheel while rocking it somewhat. A little difficult to explain, but easy to do.

Re: skew chisel grind

#3

Re: skew chisel grind

john lucas

>Elliot. I currently have skews ground all 3 ways. I also have an oval skew and rectangular skew. I prefer the hollow ground. The flat ground works well but simply takes longer to grind. A hollow ground blade is very quick to hollow and much faster to sharpen with diamond hones because you are only sharpening a small amount of metal.

The flat grind works well but when it gets dull it takes a long time to sharpen if you want to polish the whole bevel. It is quicker to sharpen if you come straight from the belt grinder but it isn't really sharp. If you but micro bevels on it with diamond hones then you have shortened the bevel and don't have the control of the long lever arm that you have with a concave ground skew.

I find the convex ground blade to be tricky when turning beads. It's harder to feel the bevel rubbing. The same is true for turning really flat cylinders. It takes more concentration to maintain the same angle. If you only grind on the belt sander it's much faster but if you want a really keen edge you can't feel the flat areas so your grind gets steeper and steeper as you try to raised the burr with each grit of the diamond hone. This means the edge may be sharp but the angle has changed.

These are all small things and each skew will work, I just think the hollow ground is easier for the beginner to control and sharpen.

As far as oval vs rectangular I can't see a difference. Some have said the rectangular is sturdier and vibrates less but I haven't been able to feel it and I've turned some large things with my oval skew. The one big difference is sharpening on the grinder. It's harder to hold the oval skew flat. I made an adaptor for my oneway platform that has curved grooves that fit the oval. this makes it very easy to hold the skew at a repeatable angle. If you use the Oneway skew jig then they both sharpen the same way. This isn't really a problem for me since I sharpen probably 20 times or more with diamond hones before I go back to the grinder. Now that I think of it it's probably way more than 20 times.

curved edge vs flat edge. I still prefer the flat edge. I think it's easier to sharpen and don't see any advantages to the curved edge. When cutting with the heel on a curved edge you can't see the heel on some cuts. I've heard it said that your less likely to catch to toe when cutting heel down because the toe is further from the wood. This is really not very far and the catch usually occurs because you got the cut above the center of the blade which eventually pulls the toe into the wood with either skew. When you are actually cutting at the proper point on the skew you are cutting with less than 1/4" of tool so the contact area is virtually the same with straight or curved.

Any way those are my perceptions. Others may have different opinions.

Re: skew chisel grind

#4

Re: skew chisel grind

eliot d

>So it's Eli Avisera who promotes the convex grind! I use a JoolTool to sharpen my skews and find that I often (unintentionally) get a slight convexity to the grind. Then, to my surprise, I found that they worked beautifully! Apparently, the slight convexity forces you to lift the tool a bit to rub the bevel, and this motion helps in avoiding catches( usually scroll backs around a bead.)

Re: skew chisel grind

#5

Re: skew chisel grind

russ Fairfield

>There are a lot of of options - rectangular, oval, or round; straight or curved cutting edge; or a bevel that can be concave, flat, or convex. I have always thought that which one we use is a matter of what we are turning, personal preference, turning style, how we sharpen the tool, or what we have learned to use.

The only time I can tell a defference between the different bevels is when making a planing cut on a long flat surface, such as a rolling pin or pen. The flat to slightly convex bevel is easier to control because the cutting edge is supported by the bevel immediately behind it; while the concave bevel is sliding along on a 2-point contact of the cutting edge and the heel of the bevel that can quite far away.

For curved surfaces such as beads, it doesn't make much difference. There could be some benefit from the concave bevel better following the curvature if the wood.