Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

newbie question...

Posts

newbie question...

#1

newbie question...

Edward in Vancouver

>Have been fooling around, on and off with a cheap lathe for quite some time, and now want to do some "real" projects with it. One that I'm working on now is a piano-type stool with revolving seat. Basically a central column of fir resting on an " X" of 2" solid oak legs.

The column, made of a salvaged old-growth 4" x4" is giving me troubles. I've got down to rough shape but the finish looks like it was spit out of a beaver's mouth. No matter what tool I use,--skew, round nose scraper, or square end scraper or what speed, the finish still looked like he**.

Finally gave up on tools and started sanding with a 60 grit disk chucked into a drill and with the piece on low speed on the lathe. Progressed to 80, then 120 with sheet sandpaper, then 240 which gave me a decent enough surface to use tung oil.

Now that I've done it the wrong way, what's the proper way, and the proper tool and speed to do it?

Re: newbie question...

#2

Re: newbie question...

Carole Valentine

>Since you have no replies yet, I will take a whack at it. I am assuming you were cutting with the grain? Were your tools very sharp? On large spindles like your stool column, I just use my 3/8" bowl gouge which has very long wings and then sometimes use a skew or small spindle gouge for details. If the finish looks fuzzy or the fibers are pulling up, I sharpen my tool and use a shear cut (not scrape) as the finish cut. Maybe some of the spindle turners will chime in here with some tips, although I don't see how turning a column is that different from turning the outside of a tall end-grain hollow form or vase.

As Russ would say, this advice is worth what you paid for it. :))

Re: newbie question...

#3

Re: newbie question...

Allen Neighbors

>Don't know for sure, but I'd probably turn it round, then speed it up to about 1400 or faster, resharpen my tools, and take lighter cuts to finalize the form and finish it out.

Fir is really soft, and will tear out easily from dull tools, slow speeds, and heavy cutting.

Re: newbie question...

#4

JL

Re: newbie question...

JL

>My personal druthers (as someone who mostly turns spindles) is to rough it out with my large roughing gouge followed by my smaller roughing gouge. I then use my skew for a planing or finishing cut. I have seen people use only a large skew, but I don't trust myself to rough with a skew. If I am adding coves or beads, I use my spindle gouge.

Re: newbie question...

#5

Re: newbie question...

Rick Allen

>My first suspect would be the wood. Fir is prone to the "beaver's mouth" effect. A harder wood like maple or cherry tends to yield a much better finish off the tool.

Second would be technique. Unfortunately technique is difficult to describe and easy to show. I would find someone local who knows what they are doing to check the technique.

Third is lathe speed and tool condition (sharpness, grind angles...) This can be conveyed on this forum. Take a look at some of the pictures in the grinds library. Take some pictures of your grinds and share those pictures with us.

My approach is a sharp roughing gouge for most of the work. A sharp 1/2" or 3/8" spindle gouge for coves and a very sharp 1" skew for beads. All cuts are made downhill. I usually sand uphill.

Good luck

Re: newbie question...

#6

Re: newbie question...

john lucas

>Ed You didn't say if you were using the skew as a cutting tool or scraping tool. The others are correct in that this wood can be a problem but scraping even with the side of the skew will always cause that problem.

A good sharp spindle gouge is what I would use to turn the various beads and coves on something like this. I use a skew for much of it but then I've been using a skew for 20 years. A skew is good for turning large curves, flats and tapers for a beginner but takes a fair amount of practice to turn beads.

Re: newbie question...

#7

Re: newbie question...

russ Fairfield

>All of the answers you have received are good advice, but I will offer one more.

Dry old growth Douglas Fir is the worst possible wood you could have chosen as a beginner. Gather some green wood limbs or saplings of any hardwood or fruit tree, even Alder will be better than Fir, and learn how to use the tools before tackling a project. One of the worst traps a beginner can fall into is trying to make something when what they need is tool skills and practice using them. Get that green wood and make several piles of shavings.

Re: newbie question...

#8

Re: newbie question...

Edward in Vancouver

>Thanks for all of your replies!

Lest see now, speed, I guess that was my first mistake. Column was a 4x4, grain running paralell to the the lathe bed, and the speed I used was the second series of pulleys on a 4 speed pulley set up, somewhere around 900 rpm. (yes folks it is a genuwhine craptsman tubular lathe...)

Tools. A shallower roughing gauge with a fingernail grind got the rough work done. I had sharpened it on a norton 120 grit white wheel with a sharpening jig. Can't say it was scary sharp, but it had a single bevel and no burr. Sharpening is something I need to work on though.

After roughing it to shape I decided to keep it simple, just a clean taper. I sharpened my skew on a 800 waterstone by hand and could shave hair from my forearm with it. I understand the skew is the hardest to master but also one of the oldest tools, and therefore must be valuable and leave a clean finish in all those centuries before sandpaper (and sanding disks chucked in a drill...) were around. Technique is something I will need to work on, but I'd like to master this tool.

The scrapers may have been dull. I did roll a new burr on them with that funky little LV burr rolling device though. And after I gave up with getting a decent surface on the fir. I chucked in a hunk of red oak, and got a decent surface from the same tool.

So I guess the thing to do now is to stay away from turning fir nfor a while. Have to admit though that once it was sanded and oiled it looked pretty O.K.--almost worth all that time sanding......

Re: newbie question...

#9

Re: Edward- put those scrapers....

Jamie Donaldson

>.... back in the tool box- they will only make more sanding necessary. I do most of my spindle type turning with a 1/2" side ground bowl gouge for roughing(I have about every tool EXCEPT a roughing gouge!), then the shallow flute spindle gouge for details like beads and coves. What you really need is some instruction- is there a turning club in your area?