Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig(long)
eliot d
>I have three rigs, the Don Derry, the Spin Doctor and the Elbotool. The first one I purchased was the Kelton. I sent it back for a refund (which they were good about). If you look at it , the heart of it is a cylindrical bar that rids on another cylindrical bar. That means that the two bars come together at a single point. That creates tremendous pressure at that point because a point has practically no dimension. Consequently the bar does not slide smoothly; it hangs up a lot. Before I sent it back, I spoke to their technical rep who knew all about the problem and suggested that I put cabinet sliding tape on one or both bar surfaces. I tried it, and it did work better; but I thought, " why should I have to", and sent it back. I then got Dr. Keith Clark's Spin Doctor rig, which is really massive and beautifully built. But I found that the bearing that the bar rides on would also hang up. Dr. Clark will do just about ANYTHING to help you out and after many months of "beta testing", he eventually came up with a superior bearing, which does work better. And he sells the best and most massive steady rest I have ever seen for really large turnings. The Don Derry is the easiest to set up and use, but I find that I can't get into small openings with it. The one I turn to always now is the Elbotool. But I modified it considerably. I didn't like the way his tool attaches to the tail stock quill. So I use a method invented by my friend, Jorge Salinas, at CAW ,to mount the rig in a second banjo. Also, the Elbotool's laser attachment was poor, so I got the Oneway, which is infinitely better. But the basic idea of the Elbotool -- namely (duh) elbow joints --is excellent: there is no metal -on -metal rubbing for anything to hang up on. And by making various adapters, I can use small(e.g. 3/8" dia.) shaft tools to get into small openings while still inserting them(using the adapter) into the 3/4" dia tenon of the Elbotool. I recently spent three days at David Ellsworth's studio, where I learned from him that you can do fine hollowing with no rigs. He gets 1/16 " even thickness in fairly large vessels using no rigs and a piece of hangar wire to measure thickness. So go figure! I do use his methods around the opening (where I find none of the rigs very useful) , but I see nothing wrong with using rigs to do most of the rest of the hollowing and to judge wall thickness. Watch out though, that the laser doesn't move while you are hollowing. If it moves to the right, you will go through the wall!