Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Kelton Hollowing Rig

Posts

Kelton Hollowing Rig

#1

Kelton Hollowing Rig

kenny in indep MO

>Hello, First let me say thanks for the great help I have recieved from this site by just reading the posts. Do any of you use the Kelton Hollowing Rig, what are pros and cons of the system? Thanks again for your help,

Kenny in Indep Mo, Harry's town

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#2

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have the Kelton rig and have been real happy with it. Since I have not used any other captured systems I am unable to address the others. There are a lot of good ones out there. If you can find some turners near who have different systems it would be in your best interest to try them

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#3

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

Ralph Watts

>Kenny,

I have a Kelton system and have tried others. The reason that I picked the Kelton is that it is more massive than some of the others and the laser light if far more stable during operation.

Best regards, Ralph

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#4

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig(long)

eliot d

>I have three rigs, the Don Derry, the Spin Doctor and the Elbotool. The first one I purchased was the Kelton. I sent it back for a refund (which they were good about). If you look at it , the heart of it is a cylindrical bar that rids on another cylindrical bar. That means that the two bars come together at a single point. That creates tremendous pressure at that point because a point has practically no dimension. Consequently the bar does not slide smoothly; it hangs up a lot. Before I sent it back, I spoke to their technical rep who knew all about the problem and suggested that I put cabinet sliding tape on one or both bar surfaces. I tried it, and it did work better; but I thought, " why should I have to", and sent it back. I then got Dr. Keith Clark's Spin Doctor rig, which is really massive and beautifully built. But I found that the bearing that the bar rides on would also hang up. Dr. Clark will do just about ANYTHING to help you out and after many months of "beta testing", he eventually came up with a superior bearing, which does work better. And he sells the best and most massive steady rest I have ever seen for really large turnings. The Don Derry is the easiest to set up and use, but I find that I can't get into small openings with it. The one I turn to always now is the Elbotool. But I modified it considerably. I didn't like the way his tool attaches to the tail stock quill. So I use a method invented by my friend, Jorge Salinas, at CAW ,to mount the rig in a second banjo. Also, the Elbotool's laser attachment was poor, so I got the Oneway, which is infinitely better. But the basic idea of the Elbotool -- namely (duh) elbow joints --is excellent: there is no metal -on -metal rubbing for anything to hang up on. And by making various adapters, I can use small(e.g. 3/8" dia.) shaft tools to get into small openings while still inserting them(using the adapter) into the 3/4" dia tenon of the Elbotool. I recently spent three days at David Ellsworth's studio, where I learned from him that you can do fine hollowing with no rigs. He gets 1/16 " even thickness in fairly large vessels using no rigs and a piece of hangar wire to measure thickness. So go figure! I do use his methods around the opening (where I find none of the rigs very useful) , but I see nothing wrong with using rigs to do most of the rest of the hollowing and to judge wall thickness. Watch out though, that the laser doesn't move while you are hollowing. If it moves to the right, you will go through the wall!

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#5

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>Kenny,

I haven't used it, but was considering it after seeing it on the Craft Supplies site. (Especially now that it and the laser are on closeout, with a 20% discount using the promotional code, "THANK YOU".) It always looked more solid than the Jamieson rig. I also like the idea of being able to extend only as much of the boring bar as I need out of the rig. I just saw Jamieson demo, but I don't recall that being possible with his.

I trust Barb's opinion and Lyn Mangiameli, from More Woodturning, gave it very high marks in a review of several rigs, including the Derry, the Spin Doctor and the Jamieson as well as several others. I'll put the link to the More Woodturning article (in PDF format) below.

-Craig

P.S. I ordered the rig from Craft Supplies when I saw the closeout price combined with the promotional code.


Lyn Mangiameli Review of Hollowing Systems (PDF)

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#6

P.S. May get a Hunter cutter for it in the future

Craig Daymon

>Watching the shavings come off while Lyle Jamieson was hollowing a goblet with his system last night added the Hunter 3/16" cutter to the wish list.

Most hollowing tools with replaceable cutters take a 3/16" cutter, including the Jamieson boring bar and that Kelton rig will take a 1/2", 5/8" and 3/4" boring bar, so it will work with pretty much all of the available boring bars/hollowing tools.

-Craig

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#7

Re: P.S. May get a Hunter cutter for it in the fut

kenny in indep MO

>Hello, thanks for the responce, what is the code for the extra savings,

Thanks for your time, Kenny in Indep

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#8

Re: P.S. May get a Hunter cutter for it in the fut

Craig Daymon

>It was right there in the first message I posted,

"THANK YOU".

Just put that string in for the promotional code. I think it was 15% off on purchase up to $175 and 20% on purchases over $175. With the laser set-up along with the hollowing rig, it gets you the 20%.

-Craig

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

Dick Hines

>I ahve to hollowing rigs. I have the Kelton and last spring I bought a Lyle Jamieson rig. I still use the Kelton for big hard wood pieces but like the Jamieson for every day hollowing. It is much smoother than the Kelton.

I thought about selling the Kelton rig but after diveing it some thought I decided to keep it. You can't have to many hollowing rigs. LOL.

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#10

Re: Craig, does the Hunter...

Allen Neighbors

>replaceable cutter come with some kind of mount so it can be used in another tool shaft, or do you just get the little round cutter with a hole in it?

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#11

Re: P.S. May get a Hunter cutter for it in the fut

kenny in indep MO

>Who's on first?

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#12

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

kenny in indep MO

>Thanks to all for the information and thanks to Graig for the heads up on the Craft Supplies 20% off deal. I did order the hollowing rig and lazer at the sale price along with the 20% off and two gift cert's ending up spending 219.00 for the system. I have the hunter #3 tool and love it. Works great for small boxes and bowls. Once again thanks to all for the help. (What's on second)

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#13

Another Thought

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>There are several other ends that will fit the Kelton. Proforme and Hunter come to mind. This is probably true of other hollowing systems too. It is always nice to be able to use other tools in a rig. I used to have trouble sliding the Kelton. I use SlipIt on the bars now and have no trouble.

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#14

Re: Craig, does the Hunter...

Craig Daymon

>You get the cutter on a short piece of 3/16" steel with the mounting point angled to appropriately align the cutter. It's about $70 and replacement cutters (which last a VERY LONG time according to Jamieson - he's still on his first) are about $20.

It was neat to see it spitting long shavings, though it might fill a hollow quicker than the finer particles produced by scraping. Should be a much cleaner cut.

I think there are a few here who have 1st hand experience with it.

-Craig

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#15

Re: Another Thought

Craig Daymon

>Thanks for the tip Barb. I was going to try it first, maybe with parafin on the bar, before possibly adding some UHMW tape. I figured the price offset the inconvenience of adding the tape.

Jamieson said he uses parafin (candle wax), rather than beeswax, because he said beeswax makes it stick and parafin lubricates. SlipIt is one step up from that.

-Craig

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#16

Re: Craig, does the Hunter...

john lucas

>Allen you can also get the Hunter cutter in a 1/4" round bar so you can make them fit many of the other systems.

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#17

Re: Craig, does the Hunter...

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks Craig and John.

How do I purchase them in the 1/4" round mount?? Do I just email someone, or can I order it online someway? If I knew the proper nomenclature, I might be able to order it, but I haven't seen them online described that way.

Re: Kelton Hollowing Rig

#18

Re: Craig, does the Hunter... *LINK*

George Van

>Allen, I did not see them listed at Hunter Tool, you may check with Craft Supply, they have the 3/16" but I do not find them on the website not. Maybe a call to customer service?


http://www.hunterwoodturningtool.com/retrofit.html