Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Bubinga box....

Posts

Bubinga box....

#1

Mike Stafford

Bubinga box....

Mike Stafford

>Here is a box in bubinga 2 1/4" in diameter and 2 3/4" tall. This one didn't quite make the mark for me. I think a result such as this is what happens when you are unsure of what your plan is...

Bubinga is still one of my favorite turning woods...


img

Re: Bubinga box....

#2

Re: It's a beauty Mike! Nothing could.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...have been any better, so get over it!!!

Re: Bubinga box....

#3

Re: Bubinga box....

john lucas

>I agree with Jamie. I don't know that I would have done anything differently. The curves are nice, the size relationships between the lid and bottom are visually nice for me. I make a raised form on my wine stoppers very similar to your little detail and couldn't tell yours from mine so obviously I'm not going to say anything about that. The ony thing I question myself on when making these is how sharp to make the point and the sides. Some I dull up some I leave super crisp. I just can't decide. I do like the proportions of that detail. Since the lid has a lot of figure to show making it larger would have taken away from that.

Let us know what you would have changed. It might be a good learning exchange for all of us.

Re: Bubinga box....

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Bubinga box....

Mike Stafford

>John, I do not like the rounded edge on the lid. I would have preferred it to be a little crisper. I also think the diameter and curve of the lid right above the bead at the join do not align correctly. And the lid has a little dip in it about 2/3 of the way from the transition from the side and the finial...

Other than that it is fine...8(. I am not sure exactly why I don't care for it. There is just something about it that is not right.

Re: Bubinga box....

#5

Re: Bubinga box....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Awe....that is gorgeous, Mike! I love the round bottom in contrast with the straight lines on the top.

Another winner for sure!

Jen

Re: Bubinga box....

#6

Re: Bubinga box....

john lucas

>Mike I look at the corner of the lid as simply an alternative. You could have continued the line from the bottom or even flared it out and made a sharper angle. That might compliment or it might compete with the top detail. I'm not sure. I think either would be good and not necessarily better, only different. It's fun hear what you think about the boxes.

Re: Bubinga box....

#7

Re: Bubinga box....

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Mike, this box is a sweet little rascal. If not having a clear plan is what it takes to create boxes this nice, I reckon I need to muddy my waters some.

Gil

Re: Bubinga box....

#8

Re: Bubinga box....

RevDoug

>Mike, I see what you're talking about, but it really doesn't bother me. In fact, I didn't see it until you said something about it and I took a different look. At the same time I'll say this, if you just can't abide it in your collection or on your sales shelf, I'll take it for you and dispose of it properly. I'd hate for you to have to suffer with it hanging around.

Maybe if the top of the lid had more of the concave curve as the knob you'd like it better. But I love it the way it is.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Bubinga box....

#9

Re: Bubinga box....

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Mike, you know that I admire your work enough to inquire about buying a recent piece. I agree with you on this one, but for me the lid is the problem. The top/finial looks to me like it was an afterthought, like someone got to the top and decided then what to do with it, rather than have a plan, and simply created a point and parted it off. Your turning skill is of course not at fault here, that is always above the mark, but I think rather it is one of design. A lid that was completely without decoration might have made you happier with the piece. I think you were right on when you said it looked like it was the result of not having a plan. I like the overall lines and the join as well.