Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Andy, I can compare the two, but only from experience long past with Waterlox.
Gloss is a subjective thing that is going to vary from piece to piece. On about half of the pieces on which I use Bush Oil, and all but one I had with me Tuesday night were finished with two coats. The white oak burl only had one. All were buffed on a Beall wheel (again, excepting the white oak), even though they were burls. I haven't gone beyond two coats yet, although part of that is because I like a soft shine, as do most of my customers.
Bush Oil has a much longer shelf life that Waterlox. That is one of the reasons it has been so long since I have used Waterlox. I really hate throwing partial cans of stuff away because they gelled up on me or start failing to dry properly. It's not just lost money, it is the hassle of throwing it away without some governmental agency crawling up my nether region because it was not done according to some obscure regulation.
I have also found that Bush Oil suffers very little from bleed out. I will almost always find it around knots and other inclusions, regardless of what oil finish I use, but Waterlox and Watco always seem to bleed out and create little shiny dots all over a piece as soon as I do my last wipe down and leave it for the night. All that needs to be removed, either with fine grain sandpaper, or even better, steel wool. Bush Oil seems to dry faster as well. With other finishes I am often forced to wait for several days to a week before I can buff them, where with Bush I can buff the next day most of the time.
Film finishes can go over any oil finish as long as it is dried completely. I have French polished over boiled linseed oil with good success. I will say that I have not tried over Waterlox, but I suspect it is not much different that others I have used. It would be a good idea to do a test piece first though.
Good luck with it!
Bill