Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

Posts

Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#1

Andy DiPietro

Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

Andy DiPietro

>Has anyone used both finishes and can tell me the differences? I know that Waterlox is Tung oil based and Bush oil is Linseed and Urethane based. I attached a link for Curious Woods Blog where you can purchase it for 10% off. I talked with some one there today and they could only give me the info off the can. Some questions:

1. Will Bush oil gloss up like the original Waterlox(red & gold can) after 3 or 4 coats?

2. Will Bush Oil last longer, Waterlox seems to skin over easily?

3. Are there different sanding requirements?

4. I see that you can apply top coats such as: nitrocellulose lacquers, urethanes, and rubbing varnishes if desired over Bush oil. I am not sure if you can do this with Waterlox.

Thanks

Andy DiPietro


http://curiouswoods.blogspot.com/2006/11/bush-oil-

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#2

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Gary Ratajczak

>1. Level of gloss depends on number of coats. If the last coat is left on heavier, and not wiped down, it will dry to a higher gloss.

2. Oxygen causes curing of the surface. If you are going to store, place in a smaller container to minimize airspace. This product has a very low VOC (solvent) content, and has a good shelf life when stored properly.

3. Like all proper processes, you should not skip any steps. Depends on what you are sanding. Flat work is 80 to 400 typically, but turnings can start at 120 and utilize some of the flexible pads that Bill offers in his kit. Idea is to make scratch pattern invisible to the eye, and propery shear off grain to allow oil to wick into wood.

4. Bush oil cures 100%, and does not bleed. I don't believe the Waterlox allows topcoats.

Hope that helps

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#3

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Andy, I can compare the two, but only from experience long past with Waterlox.

Gloss is a subjective thing that is going to vary from piece to piece. On about half of the pieces on which I use Bush Oil, and all but one I had with me Tuesday night were finished with two coats. The white oak burl only had one. All were buffed on a Beall wheel (again, excepting the white oak), even though they were burls. I haven't gone beyond two coats yet, although part of that is because I like a soft shine, as do most of my customers.

Bush Oil has a much longer shelf life that Waterlox. That is one of the reasons it has been so long since I have used Waterlox. I really hate throwing partial cans of stuff away because they gelled up on me or start failing to dry properly. It's not just lost money, it is the hassle of throwing it away without some governmental agency crawling up my nether region because it was not done according to some obscure regulation.

I have also found that Bush Oil suffers very little from bleed out. I will almost always find it around knots and other inclusions, regardless of what oil finish I use, but Waterlox and Watco always seem to bleed out and create little shiny dots all over a piece as soon as I do my last wipe down and leave it for the night. All that needs to be removed, either with fine grain sandpaper, or even better, steel wool. Bush Oil seems to dry faster as well. With other finishes I am often forced to wait for several days to a week before I can buff them, where with Bush I can buff the next day most of the time.

Film finishes can go over any oil finish as long as it is dried completely. I have French polished over boiled linseed oil with good success. I will say that I have not tried over Waterlox, but I suspect it is not much different that others I have used. It would be a good idea to do a test piece first though.

Good luck with it!

Bill

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#4

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Stokes

>How durable is Linseed versus Tung Oil?

Stokes

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#5

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Don Orr

>Andy,

You have recieved very good info so far, so I will only add what little I know from experience. I have used Bush oil for several years with very pleasing results. Bush oil is not really meant to be a final top coat although it can be with several coats. It builds very slowly. It does have more varnish solids than Watco. A final coat left thick will take quite a while to "dry". You already know it can be overcoated with most other topcoat-type film finishes. As Bill G. said, buffing works quite well to bring up a nice soft sheen. I have also found that it dries faster than other oils. It really "pops" grain great but does add an amber color. Good sanding is important as with any oil finish since scratches get highlighted just like the grain. I have not had any problem with it hardening in the can, but it will get thicker over time (like a couple years).

Bill Bush is a regular with his products at our Totally Turning Symposium in Albany, NY and at our Showcase of Fine Woodworking in Saratoga Springs, NY in the Spring. Very nice guy and really knows his stuff. And by the way, Curious Woods is located at Curtis Lumber in Balston Spa, NY where our turning club meets.

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#6

Andy DiPietro

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Andy DiPietro

>Thanks Don,

I would think Bush oil should be a little more durable then Waterlox since it has urethane in it and Waterlox does not. I really like the gloss finish I can get with Waterlox on Walnut. I usually put 4 to 5 coats and then Beall buff it to a nice gloss finish. I am hoping that I can get the same results with Bush oil. I am going to order it today and try it. I hope it works since I would hate to add another can to my finishing can collection.

I will be going to Totally Turning in October so I will get a chance to meet Bill Bush. But I should have my answers before then.

Thanks

Andy D.

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#7

I would think

Ron in Drums PA

>Bush oil is more like heavy duty Watco

Tung oil is more durable and lighter in color than BLO.

IMO - User Preference

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#8

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

peter kolb

>Besides Curious Woods who else sells Bush Oil?

Thanks for your help Peter in south central nj

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#9

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Donna Banfield

>Peter, I have purchased Bush Oil at Woodcraft.

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox... *LINK*

#10

Re: Bush Oil vs Waterlox...

Don Orr

>Andy, I will look forward to meeting you in October in Albany.

Ron is basically right in the post below, Bush oil is essentially a "Danish" oil.