Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Posts

Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#1

Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Philip Morris

>Is there such a thing as a safe, controlable catch in woodturning?

I may have an opportunity to do a turning demonstration and was considering including the demonstration of a catch. I was wanting to do something that would maybe cause a minor gouge in the wood, but nothing catastrophic.

I was thinking of attaching a solid blank on a faceplate and turning the outside profile of a small bowl or vase. Before turning/hollowing the inside, I could use a spindle gouge with a fingernail profile on the outside of the turning to cause a minor catch. I am thinking that the profile of the tool is small enough that there won't be a big catch and with the turning still solid, not a big chance of it coming apart. The few times I have done this before have always resulted in a nasty gouge in the wood, but nothing really dangerous.

What are your thoughts/suggestions?

Thanks.

Philip

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#2

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Carole Valentine

>You could use a safety center. Just tighten up enough that you can produce the desired effect.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#3

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Phil in NJ

>I would think if you have the tail stock in use, it would be pretty hard to have anything break off.

You could also use a safe drive as was suggested, or loosen the drive belt enough so a catch would just slip the belt!

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#4

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Philip, in my years of demonstrating, I have not found it all that hard to incorporate catches into my demos. Incorporating them at particular points is a little harder though! And one group did ask me to demo a few catches so I could show them how to fix them, and what to avoid in the way of holding the tool to avoid the catch itself.

But to answer your question, I don't think most catches are of the blank removing, metal breaking, pants messing variety. Most are just the presentation of the tool in the wrong way, and we all do it. I say in my demos, there are only two kinds of people who do not get catches - those who don't turn, and liars. I would say if you need to do it, practice some catches, perhaps at low speeds and light pressures, so you can demonstrate what you want. I think it is commendable that you are doing that. A lot of people like to maintain the mystique that it never happens to them. They eventually have to put out the fire in their pants! ;-)

Bill

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Richard Allen

>I find that a catch with a larger tool is safer than a catch with a smaller tool.

Take a small tool and jam it into a spinning hunk of wood. Now take a large tool and jam it into a hunk of wood. The small tool will catch deeper than the large tool.

For me a catch is usually because the cutting edge of the tool goes out of control and the cutting edge is pulled into the wood. A larger tool can't be pulled into the wood as deeply as a smaller tool.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#6

Yes

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Philip,

One way is to show the catch with the lathe off and rotating the wood by hand. I do this in the classes I teach. It is more controlled and the studends can actually see what is happening and at a speed that is easy to see the cause. It may not be as dramatic, but is sure is less stressful that the real deal... not that it has ever happened to me. :)

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#7

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

robo hippy

>Hopefully you will have a lathe that has variable speed, and set the speed at lowest possible. On my PM3520A that is around 20 rpm. You can easily show a catch, and the slower speed makes it easier for the audience see what is happening, and it is much safer for you.

robo hippy

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#8

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>The softer the wood you use the less serious the catch would be.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#9

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Jim Shewan

>Turn between centers and have the drive spur only just engaged under low compression. A light piece of timber doesn't need to be turning really slow but is still very easy to stop in the event of a catch.

A friction drive useing a cup shaped drive and turning a ball between centers give's very gentle catchs and I have done a lot of practice with a skew turning balls. Catchs are non events useing this method.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#10

This is the best response

Ruth Niles

>Trying to demo a catch at any speed is difficult because you know it's coming and won't do it the exact way it happens by accident.

Dave's suggestion of turning the lathe off and showing how NOT to present the tool is perhaps the way to go.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#11

Re: I'm definitely with Dave and ........

Jamie Donaldson

>.....Ruth for the suggestion to show how a catch can occur while rotating the wood by hand. There is no need for dramatics which could potentially create a flying tool or piece of wood. Don't forget Mr. Murphy and his Law!!!

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#12

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Barry Irby

>Went to a Richard Raffin Demo and he said that if you did not understand a catch, you could not avoid them. He did catches over and over to demonstrate that they are understandable and reproducible. If you do the wrong thing the same way you get eh same results over and over.

As I recall, he showed one where you casually stuck the tool against the wood without having it on the rest. I occasionally get one of these when I am not paying attention and just waving the tool around. Its a wake up call to concentrate. The other one he showed was rolling a bead and letting the cutting edge catch in the bead.

It was a good demo.

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#13

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Philip Morris

>Thanks everyone for the excellent suggestions. Looks like I have some homework to do before my demo.

Thanks again,

Philip

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

#14

Re: Is There Such a Thing as a Safe Catch?

Philip Morris

>Bill,

Thanks for the response. When I first started turning, I really feared getting a catch. I had heard of them, but not seen one demonstrated on a video or in person. When I had one, it was kind of like, oh... so that's a catch. Up to that point, the fear of a catch was always in the forefront of my mind. Once it happened, I could enjoy turning and focus on trying to make something instead of trying to avoid something.

Philip

P.S. Yeah, I have had my share of catches since then, some dramatic. But because of what I have learned here, I have usually taken some precautions, which minimized the severity of what happened.