Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Hunter vs. Eliminator

Posts

Hunter vs. Eliminator

#1

Hunter vs. Eliminator

russ Fairfield

>The following is my answer to the question about the difference between the rwo hollowing tools. Others may have different opinions.

I have 2 sizes of Mike Hunter's tools and one of Jack McDaniel's "Eliminator" tools. Either one is superior to a ring tool, a termite, or one of the hooded tools for cutting dry or wet end grain wood. The cutting action is similar but there is no clogging and no sharpening. I made goblets for Christmas last year and gave the Hunter tool a good workout. I have used it a lot more as a hand-held tool than the Eliminator, so my opinion may be biased. These are small open forms that are no more than 3" to 4" deep. I lost track of their number after 40, and I am still cutting with the same spot on the tool. So it does last a long time.

I acquired an Eliminator earlier this year, and have had a chance to use it on similar dry wood. There is little difference in how the tool cuts. The real difference is in the handle. It is a 3/4" diameter shaft that has a long taper down to the cutter, and there are 2 flats along the shaft to make holding the tool at 45-degrees a no-brainer. The smaller diameter and the larger diameter shaft should make for easier and deeper cutting, but I didn't find that to be the case. The long taper negates any effect of the larger diameter shaft, and in the end I cannot cut any deeper with the Eliminator than I can with the Hunter.

The longer shank on the Eliminator means I can use it without a handle if I were so inclined, but the shorter Hunter tool requires a habdle. My handle of prederence is either the long or short handles that Oneway sells. I have used both, and prefer the shorter one.

For serious deep hollowing, either hand-held or with a captured system, the better option is a short Hunter tool with a 3/8" shaft stuck into the end of a Stewart Omni or other straight bar that has a hole drilled in the end and a set-screw to hold the tool bit. This gets the larger diameter shaft out near the cutting tool where it can do some good. I have been up to 12" over the tool rest with this tool in dry Maple burl and it cuts fine.

Hunter also makes a version of his cutter that can be attached to the Srewart Hooker tool, most of the Don Pencil tools, and probably any other tool that you can come up with that has a replaceable tip.

Bottom Line:

As a hand-held tool, which you prefer is a personal choice because there is little difference between the Eliminator and the Hunter. There may be specific applications where one may be preferred over the other, such as the goblets where I prefer the Hunter.

The Hunter is the only one (that I know of) that has the option of being used with another hollowing system.

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#2

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

Cyril Griesbach

>Thanks, Russ. You have answered many questions for me.

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#3

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>Thanks for this comparison Russ. I am contemplating the purchase of a hunter to use in my Don Pencil Scorpion. After reading this, I am closer to making the decision.

keith

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#4

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

john lucas

>I did like Russ and put my #3 Hunter tool in a 3/4" bar so I can use it in my arm brace or in my captured bar system. I can easily hollow to 12" deep with that.

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#5

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>Thanks for the feedback Russ. Very good breakdown on the differences and how they apply.

I put the link to the other carbide tipped turning tool company that I'm aware of. This is the one that I have. I think a smaller cutter than the 1" would make it easier to use.

-Craig


New Edge Cutting Tools

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#6

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

john lucas

>Craig Hunter doesn't make a 1" cutter. They have 1/4" 3/8" and 1/2". The cutters you linked to are a metal cutting carbide and they don't cut as well as the Hunter. they function more like scraping tools. I had 2 of them that I built and gave away because they didn't work any better than my scrapers. The edge lasts longer but doesn't cut as clean as a scraper with a fresh burr.

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#7

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

Gordon Seto

>Craig,

The disks from your link are different things. The Hunter and Eliminator cutters are cup shape disks.

Gordon

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#8

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

Craig Daymon

>John,

I'm not interested in a 1" cutter from Hunter, I'm not that happy with the one I have. Maybe it is because it is meant for metal cutting like you said.

I trying to curb my tool buying a little, but a Hunter is probably on the list for the future.

-Craig

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#9

I need a Hunter to replace my termite Yes!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#10

Re: I need a Hunter to replace my termite Yes!

john lucas

>Doug I put my #4 Hunter tool in the box. I'll bring it to Indyfest and you can try it out. The only thing I like better on the termite is that I sharpened my termite tool differently on the backside. sometimes this allows me to rub the bevel in a narrow vessel that's hard to do other wise. I can simply flip the tool over. That's pretty rare however.

Re: Hunter vs. Eliminator

#11

Re: I need a Hunter to replace my termite Yes!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Sounds good John, I'll see you tomorrow.