Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Aromatic cedar finishing question

Posts

Aromatic cedar finishing question

#1

Aromatic cedar finishing question

Wolf Kiessling

>I have several aromatic cedar bowls to finish and I need some help. What I really want to finish them with is Tru-Oil but I know from past experience that the volatiles in the cedar can eat any oil based product. Also, I don't want to use shellac.

I have been finishing my cedar projects with wax, which is impervious to the cedar volatiles, but in this case I don't want to do this. I just re-read Russ Fairfield's article on finishing with Deft and noticed that after the sanding is completed there is a heavy coat of liquid finishing wax applied prior to the application of the Deft. In the case of cedar, would the wax act as a barrier to protect the Deft from the volatiles? Anyone have any experiece/knowledge about this?

Additionally, is there some way to "pop" the grain the way an application of oil would?

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#2

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Carole Valentine

>I am working on the same type of problem right now. I had a cedar HF that had been finished with Waterlox about a year ago and it stayed tacky. I finally put it back on the lathe the other day, turned it down to bare wood (that was a little dicey) and applied 50% thinned Deft - immediately wiping it dry. I have put two of these coats on and may try a third. So far so good, but it does not pop the grain like an oil would. I have another piece that received the liquid wax but I am not going to finish that one for a while since it is exuding a white crystalline substance which Russ tells me is sugar that is bound to the cellulose in the wood and separates as the wood dries.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#3

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Wolf Kiessling

>Mmmmmmmmmmmm, maybe someone can come up with something regarding the grain popping. I have a feeling, however, that may be an insurmountable problem and the bowls will just have to look like they are now. Probably okay 'cause the wood is awfully pretty in its natural state. still...........

One more thought, I don't have any liquid wax (I know, I know, go to the store and buy some) but wouldn't my regular Minwax finishing wax work just as good? I'm referring to the application prior to the Deft...........

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#4

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Fog Tanner

>I use Shellawax or sometimes just plain Shellac on my Aromatic Cedar pieces. When using the Shellawax I use the EEE- Ultrashine along with it. It does a good job of popping the grain and letting the wood stand out. Butit is also seals the smell of the cedar. I am allergic to Cedar and a little bit goes a long way towards sinus headaches, the shellac/Shellawax seems to stop that.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#5

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Allen Neighbors

>Wolf, I finished several pieces of Aromatic Cedar over the years, and I make the grain pop with a wet wash-coat of 35% Lacquer/65% Thinner. Then I sprayed with pre-cat Lacquer. I still have one of the pieces. It's not degraded any, and it's been over 2 years.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#6

Re: PS: I use Master's Magic...

Allen Neighbors

>WoolWax, if I want to wet-sand with wax, prior to the lacquer finish. Lacquer can be sprayed directly over the WoolWax.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#7

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Mike Nelson

>I use Deft satin spray can, knocked down with 0000 steel wool between at least six coats and haven't had any problems.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#8

I'm surprised to hear you say that, Allen,

Wolf Kiessling

>I have used 50/50 Deft/thinner and it didn't do anything to make the grain pop. Of course, it wasn't on aromatic cedar. You reckon that makes a difference?

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#9

For Fog and Allen

Wolf Kiessling

>What is Shellwax and EEE-Ultrashine?

Is Master's Magic Woolwax some special type of wax? (referring to the "wool" part)

Where do you get this stuff? Is it available at Lowe's/Home Depot?

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#10

P.S. notice Carole Valentine's post

Wolf Kiessling

>she didn't see any grain popping with the Deft either......

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#11

Re: For Fog and Allen

Fog Tanner

>Shellawax cream is a friction polish put out by U-Beaut in Australia. It is basicly shellac that has some wax in it so you can put it on with a cloth or paper towel (Viva) and then turn the lathe on and use the heat to melt and cure the finish. Its quick and easy to use. I buy it from U-Beaut but you can get it from C.S. or Packards. I also use shellac that I brush on and then friction dry sometimes. The Shellawax is just easier to use on bowls and boxes where I am looking for a gloss finish.

EEE-Ultrashine is a wax with an abrasive in it, very much a polishing compound for wood. I have made my own using Rottenstone and wax. You sand down to 400 grit and then wipe the surface with the EEE-Ultrashine. With the lathe on you can rub the surface much like you would when sanding. After a minute or two, the surface will be the same as having sanded to 1200 grit. It works under shellac or Shellawax but doubt it could be used under any finish that doesn't tolerate wax.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#12

Re: P.S. notice Carole Valentine's post

Allen Neighbors

>I've never used Deft, so I can't comment on it, but the grain always comes through for me with the Lacquer Wash... I don't know if it's because I drench it, or if it's due to a mixture of the wash and the chemistry of the Cedar.

I suggest that you take a small scrap of the wood, sand it to the smoothness of the piece, and test it, if you have any different lacquer available. You can only try it... and if it doesn't work the way you want it to, you haven't lost anything but your time.

You might try putting the lacquer wash on a finished chunk of scrap, and let it dry for a half hour or so, then resand with the last two or three grits, then oil it. The lacquer might seal the Cedar oil from the polymerizing oil finish. Just a suggestion.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#13

Re: P.S. notice Carole Valentine's post

Carole Valentine

>The lacquer wash does pop the grain - just not as much as oil. I think Russ recommended submerging the cedar in the oil for a period of time. I am not sure how that would prevent the reaction that occurs with oil finishes on cedar, though. Maybe it displaces the resins or something. Maybe he will chime in here.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#14

Re: For Fog and Allen

Allen Neighbors

>Wolf, Masters Magic is "Wol-Wax". I was mistaken in my previous post. That is the brand I have remaining in two small Jars that I bought years ago... (a little goes a long way)... I tried to find it around this part of the country because I was getting low, and couldn't locate it anymore. But I finally found the exact same wax at Munger's Finishes in Oklahoma City, and bought two quart cans of it:

It's made by Mohawk Coatings. It's labeled "Paste Wool-Lube". The "wool" stands for steel wool. The stock number on the can is M720-1356, and the label description: Non-combustible; non-toxic; non-silicone; economical; fast & easy cleanup; water-soluble.

{Directions: Place a small amount of Wool-lube on a pad of 3-0 or 4-0 steel wool. Dip into water to wet pad; rub surface in the direction of the grain using smooth, even strokes to obtain a uniform finish. For fine, satin sheens wet rub with 400-600 grit paper and wool-lube. No polish is necessary after rubbing, simply wipe with a clean dry cloth.

Wood rubbed with Wool-Lube can be recoated with lacquer with good adhesion.}

If I am planning to shoot it after using the wax, I don't worry about going with the grain, using a circular motion sort of like a random orbit. Wish I could find some 6-0 steel wool...

HTH.

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#15

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Lan Brady

>Wolf,

Thanks for this post. I have learned a lot from the responses. Plenty of things to try in the future.

Lan

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#16

Re: For Fog and Allen

Wolf Kiessling

>I think I'd like to try some of that Wool-Wax, Allen. Is the Munger's Finishes in OKC you refer to the Munger Paint and Wall Covering on N. MacArthur Blvd?

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#17

Wolf, pic of the difference

Carole Valentine

>This is the piece that I re-turned this weekend to get rid of the oil that became tacky. The top is the Waterlox finish. The bottom picture is after the returning and two wipe-dry coats of lacquer (it has not yet been buffed.) I wish I had taken a picture of it bare before I applied the lacquer, but as you can see, it did not darken the wood a lot, but at least it is silky smooth and not tacky now.


img

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#18

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Wolf:

Done lots of Eastern red Cedar, I don't think an oil will pop the grain because Cedar has a Pine like resin that that would be pretty impervious to absorbing anything. I usually use Linsed oil to finish sand and pop grain on most pieces, but no success on Cedar. I finish with several coats of Deft in the can. Never had any problems. Cedar will naturally darken with age & exposure to UV. Yes you will get the white powdwer like substance as it cures, 0000 steel wool will remove it. It sems to me that putting any kind of wax on first would cause the deft not to stick or absorb into the wood well. Like another post suggested i would get some cedar scraps and experiment

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#19

Re: Wolf, pic of the difference

Wolf Kiessling

>Yeah, I see, huge difference. It's too bad cedar can't take oil. It would be almost as pretty as mesquite. However, particularly due to the excellence of your photography, I can see the Deft does pop the grain some and it looks pretty good. I'm sure glad I didn't have to return that piece. BTW, a very beautiful piece of work it is.......

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#20

Probably a stupid question

Wolf Kiessling

>but does the white powder appear before or after applying the Deft? If I had to guess I would say before but I thought I'd better ask....

Re: Aromatic cedar finishing question

#21

Re: Probably a stupid question

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Wolf:

The white powder appears gradually over several months. It is not related to the finish being applied. It appears with or without finish, I think it is similiar to Pine sap oozing out of Pine over time.