Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Masculine or feminine...

Posts

Masculine or feminine...

#1

Mike Stafford

Masculine or feminine...

Mike Stafford

>As a follow up to the thread about who is your best customer I have to ask whether you think of your work as masculine or feminine?

My wife has a friend who was a design major and over the years she has helped me with my design sense regarding my woodworking and woodturning. She would always look at something I made and say, "That one is very feminine" or "That one is definitely masculine." Usually when I asked her why it was as a result of a number of factors including the shape, the finish and the woods used in the project.

As long as I don't use all dark woods she has categorized most of my boxes as feminine and indeed the vast majority of my box sales are to women. However, the more angular boxes, straight sided, squat and stout boxes in dark woods are always pronounced by her as "definitely masculine."

It does seem that the women buy the curvy, rounded forms and the men buy the heavier dark straight sided stuff.

It is also interesting to watch the difference between the ways a woman examines a piece and the way a man examines it. Women, invariably always touch every surface on the box, inside and out. Men generally make sure the lid is functional and never make statements about how smooth the object is. Women almost always comment on the smoothness and if they find a rough spot they usually tell you...

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#2

Steven Antonucci

Congrats on the Sept 2007 Woodcraft Mag mention

steve antonucci

>I just saw one of your boxes in the current issue.

I personally don't think of my work as either masculine of feminine, generally speaking. I think of it as wood, and the purpose (box or bowl...) may imply some notion of gender. You are right about the color perception influencing our perception of gender. Dark is decidedly male...

Interesting concept...

Steven

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>Mike, almost all art or craft can be viewed as either masculine of feminine. For example,a table with straight, heavy lines is viewed as masculine, while a delicate table with tapered legs hints of femininity. The concept in not new, Thomas Chippendale described his work as decidedly feminine; in stark contrast with the heavy gothic furniture of his day. Many turners, including myself, are aware of this and apply the concept in their work.

This image is of a toy top in motion. It is from my "Dancing Box" series. It suggests a lady dancer, spinning with a flared skirt. The point suggests a ballerina standing on her tippy-toes. The skirt is segmented, suggesting fabric rather than wood. The base, not shown, is star-shaped, following the theme of a "star dancer".

Some of my pieces are a bit more subtle.


img

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>Here is another recent piece, holly, blackwood and silver. Do you think it could be described in terms of gender? By looking at a piece in terms of masculine or feminine, a whole new perspective can be gained, going beyond the usual "size of the foot" or "mathematic formula" mentality. I think it is a topic worthy of discussion.


img

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#5

Re: Masculine or feminine...

Arch

>Mike, another gender tip off might be if the box speaks or sings to you, whether it's a bass or a soprano. Maybe not! Arch

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#6

Re: Masculine or feminine...

Paul Zerjay

>Two excellent turnings. Impressive. I can only dream of having talent such as yours.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Masculine or feminine...

Mike Stafford

>Keith, this beautiful little top was created to be feminine and it does that wonderfully. I suppose you can assign gender to anything but until this friend started doing it I had not ever thought about my work in that way.

So, if one, intentionally takes what they think to be true about the shapes that one sex or another might like, it goes automatically that only the correct sex will like it? I think not. I think it may have certain characteristics that make it more appealing to one gender or another but that does not preclude the other from finding it appealing. Do you agree?

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#8

Steven Antonucci

Hey Keith, your fly is open! (Masculine!)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: Masculine or feminine...

Mike Stafford

>Yes, I can assign gender to this piece. It is female and I think it reminds me of the decollete on an attractive woman. You left out the attractive woman so each viewer can fill in the blouse as he or she sees fit.

A wonderful piece of work, by the way.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey Keith, your fly is open! (Masculine!)

keith tompkins

>Oh My!!!...hey, you fooled me!!

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>Thanks Mike, Your friend is quite astute. You may not have previously made the connection, but many people looking at our work certainly do. The human form is very pleasing, and has been the subject of artists from the very beginning!

I don't think too much about which gender likes a particular piece..I think we're all a bit unique in our likes and dislikes. Sometimes a person will be attracted to a piece without conciously being aware of the reason why. However, I have found that men have purchased my tops for their wives or daughters.

Does thinking in terms of gender bring us closer to the realm of...ART?

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>Thanks again Mike....you nailed my intent! One person's observation may be totally different from another's. See Steve's post below...Hey Steve, I'm still trying to see it from your perspective, but it's not workin' for me. He He.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#13

Is this a Rorschach test? I see the ...

Ed Moore

>zipper as definitely masculine. The white holly vase is feminine.

Ed

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Congrats on the Sept 2007 Woodcraft Mag mentio

Mike Stafford

>Thank you sir for noticing.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#15

Re: Masculine or feminine...

john lucas

>Mike Sorry I haven't chimed in here. I don't really look at my pieces a femine or masculine. I guess they are I just haven't looked at them with that in mind. Although it's easy to say something with straight lines is masculine and curved lines are feminine but what do you do when almost everything has curved lines, like most turned hollow vessels.

How would you classify a wine stopper. I have some that are definitely masculine because they have a male form. The same with the female silhouette wine stopper I do. The others are just forms, some probably more graceful than others.

My hand mirrors sell mostly to women but I don't know if they are masculine or feminine as a general rule.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Is this a Rorschach test? I see the ...

keith tompkins

>Hi ED, could be a zipper....could be a pendant. :)

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>Thank you, Paul. You will be surprised how quickly your work progresses. Set your sights high, and learn from the best turners you can find.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#18

Keith, is a zebrawood platter ...

Ed Moore

>masculine or feminine?

Ed

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#19

Re: Masculine or feminine...

RonZ

>Beautiful work Keith.

Sheesh, some peoples' minds are in the gutter. All I saw was an open neck to a shirt and a black tie. I thought the top was having to do with bag pipes and kilts.

In general terms, vessels are feminine where as between centers is masculine and this piece nicely emphisizes this.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#20

Re: Keith, is a zebrawood platter ...

russ Fairfield

>Depends on the Zebra

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#21

is a zebra black on white, or white on black

john lucas

>

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#22

Steven Antonucci

That's a horse of a different color!

steve antonucci

>

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith, is a zebrawood platter ...

keith tompkins

>Ed, some pieces may be neither. I liked your zebrawood platter, but I don't believe the human form had anything to do with its shape. While the wood selected was outstanding, I don't see how it relates to this topic.

I do believe a platter could be used as a "canvas" to explore the concept, however.

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine or feminine...

keith tompkins

>John, I seem to recall a piece in Orlando you did that was decidedly masculine! Seriously, this is a topic that art students study in depth, and is worthy of serious consideration by any turner. You can look at any piece and ask the question...feminine? masculine? neither?

Re: Masculine or feminine...

#25

Keith, my point was that the simple ...

Ed Moore

>platter did not fall into either category. While some forms certainly do have gender issues, there are some pleasing forms that do not. And for that reason, the platter and other non-gender items did have a place in the discussion.

Ed