Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Coring system choice ?

Posts

Coring system choice ?

#1

Coring system choice ?

K.S.SONG

>Hi

We are now specifing to buy a couple of Oneway 2436 lathe with coring system.

We have no experience of this coring work and can see three brands on Woodturnerscatalog.com like photos.

Which brand will be best one?

Your comment of experience & special note to choose should be highly appreciated for us.

Thanks in advance.

K.S.SONG / Yang's Woodturning Academy, SEOUL KOREA


img

Re: Coring system choice ?

#2

Re: Coring system choice ?

robo hippy

>There has been a lot of discussion about this in this forum. A lot of it is from me. I have all three systems.

The Oneway is the most expensive, easy to use as it is on a fixed pivot point, and difficult to sharpen, although they have jigs for sharpening the tips. I prefer it for bigger bowls, over 14 inches in diameter. You do have to turn off the lathe to asvance the support finger that goes under the cutting blade which slows the coring down a bit.

The McNaughton is the one I use 95% of the time. It is the most versatile, as you can core plates, vessels, and standard bowls. It isn't on a fixed pivot point, so the turner has to control where it goes. This takes some learning. They do have a laser pointer system available now which helps you know where the cutter is so that you don't core through the bottom of your bowl. It is easy to sharpen, and is the fastest one for me to use.

The Woodcut system is a nice little unit, The big blade is a 5 inch radius, so you can't core anything big. It is easy to sharpen, changing blades isn't too hard, and it is easy to sharpen.

robo hippy

Re: Coring system choice ?

#3

How do you sharpen the McNaughton?

John Scheideman

>I have the McNaughton but have never been too sure how to sharpen it. Could someone give me some advice? Thanks.

John

Re: Coring system choice ?

#4

Re: Coring system choice ?

RonZ

>I'm having trouble because the wood here in Israel is much harder than maple, ash, etc. I just bought but I have yet to try the Oneway system. I did not like the McNaghton system. The Woodcut is very similar to Oneway and much easier to set up on any lathe. Oneway requires seperate jigs for a 24", 20', etc lathes. Everything was fine with woodcut and the first bowl worked. After that it kept breaking my large tennons. I also reground the knife as suggested and it didn't work. I turned to Woodcut for help and got none. My friend uses the Oneway and he's happy.

Re: Coring system choice ?

#5

Re: Coring system choice ?

Jerry from Lapel In.

>I have the One Way and find it to be very easy to use. I have the jig for sharping my tips, I find it very easy and fast with not much metal being removed cost is more but it's very simple to use with little to no learing .

Re: Coring system choice ?

#6

Re: Coring system choice ?

Jerry from Lapel In.

>Yes, I know how to spell LEARNING but my eyes were open and my fingers were still sleeping

Re: Coring system choice ?

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Coring system choice ?

Dick Hines

>I have the McNaughton and like it. I have seen but not used the others. The McNaughton seems to give more choices as to the size and shape of bowls you core out. The learning curve is a little steep though.

The knifes have to be on dead center or you will get a lot of catches. I cored a big dry piece of BLM burl that was very dry last nignt. The dry wood seems to core easyer than wet wood. The chips come out of the slot better.

I sharpen my knifes with a dimond credit card. That will give you a nice burr.

If you can try all of the coreing systems then make your choice.

Re: Coring system choice ?

#8

Re: Coring system choice ?

Bill Neddow

>I have both the McNaughton and the Oneway systems and have not used the McNaughton one since I broke down and bought the Oneway a few years ago. The Oneway is far easier to use and the learning curve is dramatically lower than on the McNaughton. It also looks and feels a lot safer, which will be important if you are teaching. I core over 200 big blocks of wood a year, so I was well over the learning curve on the McNaughton. It now sits in the BirdsEye maple box I made for it, unloved.

There is a myth out there that the McNaughton is more versatile. I cannot see this. Both sets of knives are portions of a circle. They cut the same way. You can set the Oneway to cut wide in shallow, or narrow and deep -- same as the McNaughton. The only thing you can't do with the Oneway is compound curves like an ogee. I have done that with a McNaughton, but it is done by making multiple paths and the core looked like it had been chewed out of the block of wood by a dog. You lose far less wood by making a clean cut on a simple curve, then shaping the bowl when you can see what you are doing.

Re: Coring system choice ?

#9

Re: Coring system choice ?

Mike Brazeau

>Great assessment Bill. I have the Oneway and am very happy with it, but see those beautiful nested burl bowls that Mike Mahoney does and wonder if I should try it too. Does the McNaughton have a narrower kerf?

Just saved me from spending some future dollars! I have been going to do a large drawing of the potential shapes with the Oneway by varying offset from center and depth of cut, but never get around to it.

Re: Coring system choice ?

#10

Re: Coring system choice ?

robo hippy

>Okay...

First to sharpen the McNaughton, you can use a grinder if it needs it, or most of the time, I use a diamond hone. Use the coarse grit as it does a better job of raising a burr. All coring systems are fancy parting tools that cut like scrapers, and a burr works best. The exception here is the Oneway which comes sharpened on a surface grinder. To sharpen it, you sharpen the top surface and the chip breaker point. It still cuts well. All 3 systems remove a 3/8 inch wide kerf. The exception is the mini McNaughton system which removes a 1/4 inch kerf.

As far as versatility, the McNaughton wins hands down. I can take a 3 inch high by 14 inch blank and remove a core that will yield a 1 1/2 inch by 12 inch platter. I can take a 6 inch wide by 10 inch deep open vase form and get 4 cores out of it. You can not do this with the Oneway. The small curve (flatter) blades from McNaughton are on a bigger radius than any of the Oneway blades so you can take a flatter core, or a deeper more vertical core. There is some room on the Oneway to move the tool rest to either side of the center. This allows some variation on coring flatter or deeper, but if you go all the way to either side, you can run into some binding because of the support finger. When you add the total height and curve of the blade and finger, you a very specific radius on the core for the blade set up to fit into, to be able to complete the cut with no binding. This is why there is a limited amount of movement allowed on the tool rest.

I don't count the number of bowls or cores I take each year, but it would be in the 700 range. I can core a 4 bowl set, 14 by 6 inch deep, and turn to final thickness in about 50 minutes with the McNaughton. I have a PM3520A. I never timed myself on the Oneway, but because you have to turn the lathe off and advance the support finger up to 4 or 5 times on a bigger bowl, it takes longer than the McNaughton. I can resharpen the tip on a McNaughton in seconds, as compared to minutes on the Oneway (I will sharpen them all at once to be more efficient). I have to remove all the tips (allen wrench) screw them onto a jig, sharpen them, then remount them back onto the blade.This doesn't matter if you are turning more for fun than for production purposes. There is also less work in set up on the McNaughton.

The Oneway and the Woodcut both are easier to use than the McNaughton. If you are only coring utility bowls, they work fine. If you are coring other shapes as well, then the McNaughton works better, but it does have a learning curve.

robo hippy

Re: Coring system choice ?

#11

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: Coring system choice ?

eduardo sarmiento

>Hi guys :GET THE TAPE PERIOD! there you will see ,what you do wrong

ill send the tape free to any turner if he send me a hotmail adress

happy turning

peruturner@hotmail.com

Re: Coring system choice ?

#12

Re: Thanks , everybody

K.S.SONG

>Really thanks for many comments.

We have to compare them upon your useful advices.

Thanks again.

Safe turning

K.S.SONG / SEOUL KOREA