Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Box #2

Posts

Box #2

#1

Box #2

Carol in Illinois

>Alright. Here goes. These are my second and third attempts at turning lidded boxes. All comments welcome. I am not a photographer. Photos were taken outside in natural light.

The first is of cocobolo, about 1 1/2 inches tall by 2 inches diameter. It's a "ring box" requested by Dear Daughter #2 after DD#1 requested and received my first attempt.


Here's the underside of the box and lid. Per forum consensus, the bottom is slightly concave. So is the lid, in case she plunks a ring on top instead of inside the box. The finish is oil and wax.


Re: Box #2

#2

Box #3

Carol in Illinois

>Wow! That worked! Cool!

Here's box #3, for my sister's birthday. It's cherry, about 1 2/3 inches tall and about 3 inches in diameter, finished with oil and wax. The pic was taken outside in natural light, and it's sitting on top of my car. The first pic is a bit fuzzy, but it's the only one I have of the closed box.


The second pic shows the box open:


And the last shows the bottom of the box and inside of the lid:


Next message is "what I learned"...

Re: Box #2

#3

What I learned

Carol in Illinois

>1. Jam chucks are not as easy as y'all make them look and sound.

2. Bringing the tail stock up keeps the box from flying around the room.

3. A snug-fitting lid will still escape when the lathe is on if not secured by the tail stock.

4. Turning that little lip might take a trial or two. The box gets shorter, the grain match is a little off, but I'll be danged if I'm gonna give up!

5. It's a lot easier and faster to turn the darned thing smooth to begin with than to sand off rough end grain.

6. Dull gouges cut slower. It's important to not only take the grinder out of the box and ponder assembling the grinding jigs, but also to take _those_ out of the box and actually put the thing together.

7. Re-centering a box that has taken a trip around the kitchen (where I turn)is not likely to be successful.

8. Boxes that are "re-centered" off-center end up with strange eccentricities... and/or smaller than intended.

9. That spur center leaves one danged deep hole. The box either ends up with a belly button (or two), or shorter than you think it was gonna be.

10. Sanding takes longer than you think it will, and circular sanding marks are harder to remove from that lovely detailed lid and bottom than on the nice smooth sides. Consider this when planning detail.

11. A catch in the lovely beaded rim of your box requires turning the box smaller or re-design of your lovely accent.

12. A catch is also loud and danged scarey!

13. Catches can neither be disguised nor sanded into oblivion.

14. There are probably better ways to do this. I need a different way to chuck these things.

15. Did you know that a regular spur center in the tail stock does not turn when you turn on the lathe? Huh. (Duh.)

16. Boxes make a LOT more shavings than spindles/wands/pens.

17. Boxes are just as magical as wands.

Fun!

Re: Box #2

#4

Re: Box #3

Cyril Griesbach

>Carol, you did a nice job and it's clear that you learned a lot. You should also know that things get easier as you continue to gain experience. If you're not already a member of a turning club consider seeking one out in your local area. It can make your learning experience more fun as you'll find lots of help.

Re: Box #2

#5

Well, you've got it, Carol.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>You are now a bonafide turner. I seem to spend some times on 7 and 8.

Your lathe is in the kitchen? Um, there's no way you can get ALL of the sawdust out so I guess you've found a new food spicing, right?

Those are nice boxes, by the way, and I still don't know, even after watching in person, how some guys knock those things out in a hurry.

Re: Box #2

#6

Re: What I learned

HarryB in Kulpsville

>Carol, We must be kindred spirits. My lathe is in the kitchen too. And a small drill press and two ginders! Wood is good!

Harry

Re: Box #2

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: What I learned

Mike Stafford

>Carol, for those to be boxes 2 and 3 you have done exceptionally well. I wish my 2nd and 3rd boxes looked as good. I love the little beads and dimples you turned as surprises on the underside of the lid and on the bottom of your boxes. Very nice!

Below are responses to your findings from the perspective of another box turner....

1. I hate jam chucks, that is one reason I started rechucking my boxe on various sized chuck jaws. I only use jam chucks as a last resort.

2.Yes, it does and you can do most of the work on the lid and on the bottom of the box with the tailstock supporting the work.

3.Snug fitting lids can loosen up from the heat generated by cutting, sanding or polishing. That is why it is important to let the body flange and lid get back to normal temperature before final fitting. If you adjust your fit while the lid is hot and expanded it will be loose when everything cools down to normal. DAMHIKT!

4.Yes, they do so proceed slowly when cutting that flange. Cut a tapered flange and trial fit your lid to see when it just starts to go on. Then you can come back and adjust the fit later.

5.Yes it is. When I finally learned how to sharpen my tools it made all the difference in the world. It also helps to resharpen your tools right before you make a light last pass.

6.Not only slower but tend to create more problems like tear out of end grain. See #5 above.

7.I don't have this problem. I don't turn in the kitchen. My flying boxes always end up under the table saw, work bench or in some black hole somewhere where the creepy crawlies hide out...

8.Yes they do and lids tend not to fit the way you wanted them to...

9. If you can remove the point from your drive center and live center and use a hollow cup center in the tail stock if you have one to eliminate that problem.

10.Absolutely true. Plain shapes are much easier to sand on end grain. Also, the more sanding you do on end grain the more likely you are to have heat checks which result from the heat buildup when sanding end grain.

11.This is called a design opportunity....

12.And disheartening....

13.So true and difficult to incorporate into your design.

14.I use multiple chucks so that I can chuck and rechuck and woodchuck my boxes as I turn them. I was just kidding about the woodchuck part...

15.LOL LOL. It happens to us all....

16.But when you are done you have a place to store the shavings....

17.Boxes are great fun and contain their magic inside. I have never seen a potential buyer who did not open every single box to see what was inside....They just have to look. That is the magic of boxes.

Fun, you bet, great fun!!!!

Re: Box #2

#8

You Learned a LOT!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carol, these both look great! After our attempt in January I'm very impressed! We were both like the blind leading the blind. I loved your write up and learning what you learned. It was priceless and put a smile on my face.

...now about this turning in your kitchen.......?

Jen :)

Re: Box #2

#9

Re: What I learned

john lucas

>Carole They look great but it sounds like you had the kind of day I have been having. I don't know what's wrong with me today but I just can't concentrate. I've screwed this box up so many times if I save it it will be a miracle. I decided to stop and eat dinner.

here's what I learned.

Screw threads aren't as easy in wood as on the metal lathe.

Two female threads won't go together-meaning the lid gets shorter.

Some days you just can't use a dial caliper to make 2 accurate Measurements.

An ornamental surface burns your fingers while you try to stabilize the piece and turn the inside.

Sanding the inside of vessels takes longer when you don't cut cleanly- next time I'll do the ornamental work last.

Cursing doesn't make the cuts cleaner- it only irritates the dog.

To save this piece I'm going to have to burn, paint, bleach, carve, sandblast, burn again, sand again, paint and dye. Hey isn't there a contest starting for this.

Re: Box #2

#10

Re: Box #3

Barry Elder

>Carol,

You are obviously a veritable storehouse of experience and are way ahead of most of us when it comes to turning Hot Cross and Baked Boxes!! (Tongue in Cheek) They are very nice!

Re: Box #2

#11

Re: What I learned

RonZ

>The boxes came out nice and you learned something, I'd call that a successful day.

Re: Box #2

#12

Re: What you learned, did it.

Allen Neighbors

>... made me roll on the floor. :))) I now have a sore stomach. LOL

Sounds like you pick things up pretty easy... (even those on the floor).

Well done on your first boxes, Carol. I'd say your daughters are fortunate to have you for their Mother. You're alright!

Re: Box #2

#13

Cyril, Eddie, and Harry...

Carol in Illinois

>Thanks for your kind comments. I finally joined a local turning club this weekend, just because I ran into a demo of theirs while wandering around Woodcraft looking for a Talon chuck. (Chuck opinions solicited - I've got one of those nifty Rikon minilathes.)

The lathe is in the kitchen due to lack of a garage and the fact that the drill press, table saw, grinder, belt/disc sander and workbench are in the laundry room and there's a limit to how much grit the girls will tolerate in their undies. I vacuum like crazy - frequently and long, vertical as well as horizontal surfaces... and there's still sawdustmotes on the tv in the living room. I make the bird wear a dust mask.

Re: Box #2

#14

Re: What I learned

Carol in Illinois

>Mike, I went alookin' for chuck jaws this weekend, and am thinking about the Talon chuck for my Rikon mini... any opinions on that?

I watched a video of (making this up, cuz the video is downstairs...) I think Richard Raffin (?) turning boxes this weekend, and learned from his demo of the tapered flange. I'll try that - as well as some other things he demonstrated - with the next box.

The Rikon comes with a hollow cup (you take out the pointy thingy...) so I'll give that a shot with my next box as well.

Thanks for your help!

Carol

Re: Box #2

#15

John, Jennifer, Ron, Allen

Carol in Illinois

>Thanks for your comments. I turn in the kitchen d/t lack of a garage. I'm glad I gave you a chuckle. If I seem to pick things up quickly, it's only because I have the example of my betters to learn from. I read a lot before I give a thing a try. OTOH, it does seem to go along fairly well at first, which is very rewarding. I say "at first" because I lack the true artist's eye and touch, so I always hit a wall...

Re: Box #2

#16

Thanks, Barry.

Carol in Illinois

>