Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

Posts

A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#1

Steven Antonucci

A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

steve antonucci

>Alright, maybe not a poll, but I know AAW board members know about WoodCentral's turning forum and probably would be interested in some constructive help at bettering the AAW for it's membership.

Now without yelling and screaming, what do you expect from AAW?

I'll go first:

1.) I expect that AAW will address a broad range of turning topics- from techniques to tools to form and design. I suspect that I will look at beginner, intermediate, and advanced topics throughout the materials, and I will read them all with a varied level of interest.

2.) I expect AAW to promote the art/craft of woodturning through various symposium, which I may or may not choose to attend. If I choose to attend, I expect the topics/mix from point #1 to be present, and it will be my responsibility to seek out the interesting ones.

3.) I do NOT expect it to be a democracy (majority rules). Assuming that most of the turners are beginners, I do not want an organization that is run by inexperienced turners, nor caters to them exclusively.

4.) I expect the AAW to expect of its' membership. As we all know, in any group, there are thinkers, do-ers and followers. I would love to see the AAW step of the pressure on becoming ACTIVE members within the organization and put together a plan to reward people for participation. Nothing comes from nothing.

It's a start. Now that I'm a member of the AAW (ok, technically 1/1/2008), I have an opinion.

Steven

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#2

Steven Antonucci

P.S. Rules for posting

steve antonucci

>Let's try to make a civil list here.

As a rule- no replies to any post, no matter how "inane" you might feel it is. Just let everyone have there say...

Steven

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#3

Excellent rule! ... Oops, shouldn't have posted

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#4

Re:Steve- proof read item #4- I think ...

Jamie Donaldson

>you left out a word and typoed another.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#5

Re:What a useless and boring endeavor ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... that would be! Remember that there is a "co" at the beginning of communication, not an "uno!"

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Step up not step of...

steve antonucci

>

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Since no one is listening to the rules...

steve antonucci

>I disagree about the utility of creating an open discussion where everyone is allowed to voice an opinion with worry of judgement, or even worse, attack.

I work in high-tech, and some of the more forward thinking companies use development methodologies that start with this process. Everyone gets in a room and ideas fly. You aren't allow to go into detail, or bash the ideas, no matter how wacky they might seem. Everything starts on a whiteboard and gets weighted equally.

When the ideas stop coming, people then begin the process of weeding out the stuff that doesn't make sense, is impractical, or doesn't fit with the overall goal. It fosters innovation.

What typically happens in these types of environments is that new ideas create new opportunities. I worked for the company that built Priceline.com 1.0. You'd have laughed if you saw some of the things that were pitched. At the time, no one thought it was a great idea, but a lot of folks got paid...

There is no place for naysaying in the room, Jamie. Your basic premise that nothing good can come from an open exchange of ideas would have you "uninvited" to a lot of meetings in my world.

If you reread my post (with the correction)and want to contribute, feel free.

Steven

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#8

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

RonZ

>I treat forums kind of like office relations with an addition. I don't talk religion or politics. Some people have made turning into either one or both. The addition is don't say anything you wouldn't say in pperson or feel sorry for the next day.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#9

Re: Steve- you err in both your choice ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...of the word "exchange" and interpretation of my post. I am all in favor of an "open exchange," but you have proposed only the posting of individual opinions or wishes rather than an exchange. You can't have it both ways at the same time!

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Jamie, simply put: what do you expect from AAW?

steve antonucci

>

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#11

Re: The mission statement of AAW...

Jamie Donaldson

>... is a good working standard for me. If I was a better computer user I would link it here, but I'm not and I can't. Help someone!!

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#12

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

Russ Fairfield

>I expect the AAW to challenge me to become a better woodturner, inspire me to do new things that are beyond my normal vision, and show me the way to do both. It has never failed to do this over the 20 years that I have been a member. If this is the AAW's mission, then it has served me well.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#13

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Actually, I am pretty happy with what I am getting from the AAW for $45/ year (for those who smoke and/or drink put it in perspective).

If I become unhappy, I will let them know through a letter to the editor, contacting the Directors I have voted for OR getting actively involved.

I dare say most of us do not have any idea of how much work is involved with the running of the AAW and the Symposium. I certainly don't. Before I criticise any part of the AAW I would take the time to find out the complete story so that I don't appear to be making snap judgements without proper input.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#14

$1,000,000 and a helicopter

Bruce Forrest

>

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#15

Re: Barbara- if you volunteer to .......

Jamie Donaldson

>...help next year in Richmond VA you will have a full understanding of the process!

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#16

Re: The mission statement of AAW... *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>By-Laws (with Mission) and P&P are at the link.

Click on the left margin links to d-l the word docs.

mm


AAW

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#17

Steven Antonucci

If they give you $1M, buy your own helicopter!

steve antonucci

>

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#18

Re: Barbara- if you volunteer to .......

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You are right. With 5 part time jobs it might be a little difficult for me to do much before hand.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#19

Question

Roger Smith

>Russ, what would you have thought if you experienced today's AAW twenty years ago or a better example is after you had only been turning for 5 years?

How much has the AAW changed in the past 20 years? I would expect very much.

I think an example would be like a worker building a skyscraper. If he started on the first floor, then the twenty-first floor would not seem as high as another worker starting on the 21st floor.

Could it be that AAW challenges and motivates those that grew with it, but at the same time overwhelms those that came along later?

Roger,

getting back to a job that pays my bills in North Ala.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#20

Steven Antonucci

The result of my little experiment...

steve antonucci

>So I think at this point, there is enough data to summarize my experiment.

Without going through a detailed scientific and mathematical analysis, here's some broad observations:

171 views upon this writing

6 unique comments

2 said everything was perfect as-is

3 said nothing at all

Russ acutally answered the question thoughtfully in his own words. Thank you, Russ.

I think this illustrates the basic social structure of the AAW and any group. A lot of people belong. Some contribute, but don't try to change. Few lead by example.

Steven

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#21

I expect nothing for me but I hope....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>the AAW continues to promote woodturning. The symposium is a great place to learn and to meet new people that enjoy the same thing I do.

45 bucks is a small price to pay for all this. The magazine is a bonus to let us know what's going on in this small world of ours.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#22

Re: Question

Carole Valentine

>Hi Roger,

Obviously I am not Russ, but maybe I can offer my perspective. I got my first lathe in December 2004. I had never seen a lathe in real life or seen anyone turn and didn't even know AAW existed. I joined AAW in 2005. I turn classic forms and do very little "artsy" stuff (yet), but I have learned a lot from both the AAW mag and as well as its forums in my short turning career (especially the "how Tos, Tips and Techniques" forum. It is like any other resource to me - I use what I can at the present time and file the rest away for future reference as I grow in this wonderful hobby. Lately I have found myself inspired by some of the artsy stuff I have seen and am having fun experimenting in my shop. BTW, you don't have to be a member of AAW to participate from the forums. Happy turning!

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#23

Too short a time period

john lucas

>Steve you only gave us half a day or so to do this. I've noticed a lot of time it takes about 24 hours for many people to respond.

For me the AAW has had a huge impact. Of course it helps if you dive in and help them. Ever since my first symposium which was a local symposium, not the AAW, I joined the �AW and have volunteered to help when I could.

What do I expect from them. Well I think Jamie covered it with their mission statement. I want to learn all I can. I feel that if I learn all the skills I can then I can build whatever is in my mind.

I like the way the magazine has changed in the last 5 years. There are some really good articles covering a wide range of subjects.

I like that they are teaching children. Most woodturners are my age or older. What happens when we die off. No new turners. I think we need to train the younger generation.

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#24

Re: Too short a time period

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>Nicely said, John. I do not have the time to check this venue 3,4,5 times as many seem to do. I have a business (mine!) to run and am a caregiver to my very sick and immobile parents.

Yet I refuse to feel like I am a sheep being led by "contributors" or "leaders" that have a great deal of free time to post here seemingly at will. And I don't see a day of luxury in my near future when I will be able to ponder the weighty issues of what to expect from my hobby club. If only there was that kind of time... and even time to respond within 24 hours to a query about my hobby!

And as always, whether it is woodturning, woodworking, model ship building, and yes, even alt.coffee, there is always a group that thinks that the newbies might just belong somewhere else. Or that they should keep their mouths shut and learn by observation.

With over thirty years of professional woodworking behind me, I still get a real charge out of teaching someone something they are interested in that I know about. Actually, most guys that do woodworking for a living are just happy to find someone that cares about the craft at all anymore and are happy someone cares enough to learn. I know I am; if one of the guys that works for me wants to learn how to cut a scribed outside corner of non nested crown molding, I take the time to show them - on my nickel.

On the other hand, I know that some of the guys feel like their time is wasted with those that have less time, experience and inferior tools. I have always encouraged those folks to start their own group, make it private, and possibly have online judging of different pieces and styles to see if you could make the grade before being allowed to join. Entry levels could be the correct lathe, tools, and how many seminars you have attended with the approved demonstrators. This would enable the higher minded folks to combine into their own brain trust to develop their "art" as the see fit, without wasting their time on others.

But then I remember Groucho Marx:

"I wouldn't belong to a club that would have me as a member".

Robert

Re: A poll: What do you expect from AAW?

#25

Double Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My "expectations" may be different from my "wants" although they may overlap in spots.

I expect that the organization will be run by honest and competent people who, in the spirit of true voluntarism, put their self interest far behind the needs of the organization.

I expect the organization to conduct outreach and PR campaigns that are reasonably calculated to benefit all members rather than a lesser group of "active" members.

I expect sanctioned events to be run with competent planning and oversight and to be responsive to the interests of the broadest number of members. A symposium should, by definition, please all of the people in some way.

I expect the organization to be run such that the maximum benefit and value is returned equally to each member for their dues dollars.

I expect the organization to conduct outreach and educational activities to popularize woodturning as an artform while at the same time promoting it as a craft and an inclusive hobby in which people of all skill levels and outlooks can participate with an equal sence of acceptance and self-importance.

I want . .

My magazines delivered promptly; and

FREE STUFF worth at least 5 times what my dues are.

mm