Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Posts

1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#1

1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Ruth Niles

>I have the rechargable batteries for my camera (and anything else that uses AA). When I charge them, should or could I;

a) leave them in the charger, plugged in, until I need them or until I need to charge others.

b) leave them in the charger, not plugged in?

c) take them out of the charger and keep them where? in a plastic bag? fridge? doesn't matter?

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#2

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Leaving them in the charger, plugged in, will keep them fully charged. It's always nice to have fully charged batteries on hand.

The standard rechargable batteries slowly self-discharge. Leaving them in an unplugged charger is the same as taking them out to store them. It doesn't really matter how you store them, just as long as they don't short out. Keeping them in the fridge will slow down the process, but you have to wait for them to warm up again to get full power from them. (Batteries are weaker at lower temperatures, discharge faster at higher temperatures.)

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#3

Exactly what I wanted to know, Brian, Thanks

Ruth Niles

>

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#4

well said brian

john lucas

>

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#5

Re:Ruth- many camera batteries...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. are NiMH rather than than the older NiCD, and they will also self-discharge sigfnificantly in as little as 30 days. If the camera has been sitting unused(or even slightly used!) it's a good practice to charge before a known session of shooting. Murphy's Law!

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Steve Kubien

>Brian said, "Keeping them in the fridge will slow down the process, but you have to wait for them to warm up again to get full power from them. (Batteries are weaker at lower temperatures, discharge faster at higher temperatures.)"

Really? I always thought the opposite because my cellphone (when I can find it or choose to try) loses its charge in a day or two if left in the car during a Canadian winter. I lost my phone about a month ago and it was just returned to me, still with a partial charge.

I'm not trying to be difficult just wondering where you are getting this from. Other than what I've experienced, I have zero reason to doubt what you say. Boy, technology confuses me sometimes!

Steve Kubien

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#7

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Fog Tanner

>Ruth,

A lot depends on the batteries and the chargers. I have been around rechargeble batteries for over 30 years in R/C model aircraft. I have built my own battery packs over the years and have all of the various chargers made over that time period.

I normal charger that charges at a fixed rate, which is what most of the cheap chargers are, will charge the battery in about 16 hours. This is assuming a C10 (1/10 capacity) rate, a 500mh battery would be charged at 50ma. Once it is charged you can put it on a "trickel" charge of between a C50 to C100 and leave it indefinately. C50 is 1/50 of capacity, for a 500ma battery that would be a 10ma chrage rate.

The best chargers are the ones that will charge the battery to it fully charged state and then switch to a "trickel" charge. I have several of those for my models and one for my Airstream. They are really the only way to go. They do not over charge the battery as the cheap chargers do. If you use the battery for 30 minutes, it will have more of a change than if you used it for 8 hours. The smart chargers will only put back what you need. The dumb charger will charge until you unplug it.

Over charging will over time deterioate the capacity of the battery and shorten its life. That may not be important in a camera, but when you are controlling an airplane going 200mph it becomes very important.

As far as storing batteries, leave them in your house at room temp. Same with charging, heat will cause internal loss of charge much quicker quicker. The older batteries would loose 10% a day, then it went down to 10% a month - just setting there. Charging in hot weather can cause a thermal runaway, as can over charging. I have a fast charger that has a temp sensor and adjusts the charge rate. Used to be fun when the batteries would explode, then they added

vents and the capacity would just go down. But, when you store the batteries, fully charge them and set them aside. Once a month charge them for a little to maintain the charge. I made some trickle chragers (C100 rate) so I could leave mine on charge all the time.

And the myth of batteries developing a memory is exactly that. A rep from Gates batteries addressed that back in the late 70's. It didn't exist then and doesn't in the newer batteries.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#8

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Cold reduces the available power from batteries. It is a fundamental fact of chemistry. Your cell phone doesn't reduce its power requirements, so the batteries discharge more quickly. It is the same reason that car batteries are rated by their cold cranking amps and a marginal battery will fail when it gets really cold. Alkaline batteries have very poor cold power characteristics because their chemistry is more complicated than the lead-acid battery or Ni-Cd / Ni-MH batteries and it is even more susceptible to the cold.

A separate issue is the self-discharging of batteries. All batteries loose power over time. That's why non-rechargeable batteries have "best by" dates. Among the rechargeables, Ni-Cd batteries are notorious for self-discharging and will completely discharge within 90 days just sitting on the shelf. It is an inherent problem with Ni-Cd batteries. On the other hand, lead-acid batteries will keep their charge for years.

Did that help, or did I confuse you even more?

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#9

Whoa, Fog, you boggled my brain!!!!!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#10

Re: Whoa, Fog, you boggled my brain!!!!!

Don in Central Illinois

>Ruth, I use the rechargable batteries for shooting weddings and when we unpack from the wedding, we put them in the chargers and forget them until we need to use a camera.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#11

Good point, but...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>All of the consumer-grade chargers that I've seen for NiCd/NiMH cells (usually they handle sizes AAA - D) automatically switch to trickle mode when the cells are charged. I strongly doubt that anyone makes a NiMH charger for AA cells that doesn't trickle charge.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#12

Re: Good point, but...

Carole Valentine

>How do you know if a charger is a "trickle" charger or not? I have been wondering if I should leave one of my Trend Airshield batteries on the charger all the time or try and remember to take it off when I "think" it is fully charged. I have no way of knowing if it is charged since they did not see fit to put any sort of indicator light on the stupid charger. :(

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#13

Re: Good point, but...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Carole, I was talking about the generic battery chargers that take standard single cell batteries. If you have a charger that will handle a variety of cell sizes, it most likely automatically switches over to trickle charging once the cell is charged. All of the chargers that I've seen and have for power tool battery packs also automatically switch over (DeWalt, Makita, Panasonic, Bosch, et.). I'm not familiar with your charger and if the manufacturer's instructions don't say... One good indicator is if the battery pack gets warm while it is charging, then cools down. The higher current during charging heats up the batteries, the low trickle current lets they cool down again.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#14

Steve Kubien

It helps

Steve Kubien

>Thanks for that Brian. Batteries are something I know nothing about, just my own experiences. And as for chemistry, well, that's a pretty dirty word in my book!

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#15

p.s.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>If the battery takes forever to charge or it never gets warm while charging, then the charger is a trickle charger and you can leave the battery on until you need it again.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#16

Re: p.s.

Carole Valentine

>I just went and felt the battery. It's been on charge for 4 hours. Doesn't feel warm at all but I have no clue if it is charged yet or not.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#17

Re: p.s.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Not warm is good. It means either the battery is fully charged and on trickle or the charger is only a trickle charger. Either way, I would leave the battery on the charger until I needed it.

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

#18

Re: 1/2 OT: chat last night - batteries?

JKJ in East TN

>>...Cold reduces the available power from batteries.

This concept can be driven home when trying to start an automobile in extremely cold weather. One rare time when the temperature got close to -20F here I was only able to start my car after removing the battery and warming it in the bathtub.

JKJ