Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Exhausting a DC Outside

Posts

Exhausting a DC Outside

#1

Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

I have an Oneida Gorilla cyclone. I am working on rebuilding my dust collection system, and I have the opportunity to exhaust the thing to the outside of the shop. This means less room taken up in the shop, no more having to empty a filter, etc. I am not concerned about any heat loss, since my shop is:

a) heated with radiant heat

b) the DC is used for short periods of time

c) I have plenty of natural insulation

Has anyone here done this? If so, did you buy or build any special fittings? I am concerned mainly about animals trying to make a nest in the ductwork or the cyclone. Noise is not an issue.

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#2

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>I know a guy who had a mouse chew a large hole in his dust bag(he put his entire system in a lean-to).

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#3

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Randy Privett

>Bill,

I've always exhausted it outside, you and I live where it doesn't matter if it goes into the air.

Randy

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#4

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Gary, there are no bags on my cyclone, and the filter is going bye bye if I exhaust it outside. Besides, I already have mice in the shop.

Randy, I sort of figured it would not be an issue. Noise and dust are just going to be swallowed up by the space around me. The guy who farms the field across the road puts more dust into the air in a day than I could in a year!

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Dick Hines

>Bill the first time you turn on the DC it will be good by nest.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

keith tompkins

>Bill, that's how the furniture factories do it. At my day job, we have two HUGE cyclone systems, fully computerized with heat sensors and water sprinklers. They empty directly into bins, which are then trucked away when full. How huge? Each cyclone is about 30 feet tall, the system cost in excess of 1.5 million. Mice? not a problem.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#7

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Peter Teubel

>I have my cyclone in a shed next to my shop. For the winter, I pipe it back into the shop into a custom made filter cabinet. For the summer, I routed the exhaust straight down thru the floor of the shed. The 6" PVC pipe is too slick for any animal to climb up 7ft.

Since you are redoing your whole DC system, I cannot emphasize enough to use BIG pipes for the main runs...AT LEAST 6". Mine is all 6" PVC to every machine and then it splits into two 4" hoses for the machine. The difference is really amazing.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#8

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Crommett

>When I upgraded my Grizzly to a 6 inch pvc system I made a new adapter plate for the impeller housing so it would consume the full vacuum available. It worked great, except with the increased air flow I couldn't keep the upper bag in place. So, in desperation , I vented the whole thing to the outside with the exhaust about 5 ft. off the ground. No more problems, but the paint locker is still a mess of dust and cobwebs.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#9

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Bill,

Having just spent a goodly part of my weekend 1) building a filter box so that I can direct the filtered/heated/cooled air back into the shop, and 2) converting to 6" piping, I feel your pain. In your situation, I would vent outside. For the cost of filters, you can buy a decent forced air heater for the winter cold issues.

In great part, I try to control the temp in my shop more for my lacquer finishing, Helps me moderate the humidity.

Mark

Mark

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#10

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Barry Irby

>Bill, I also posted on the flat side, but I thought I would add a PS. I have said many times I don't want a Duct Collector, I want a Dust Disposer. I want the dust to go away, so why collect it? I live on a half acre in a subdivision. If I lived out of town, I would just use a blower to suck up the dust and blow it outside in a pile or out into the woods if any were handy. To heck with bagging it or putting it in a bin and emptying the bin later. Blow it out of sight.

And you don't need a Cyclone for that, just the blower. I think Bob Dodge posted something about Dust Destroyer. Check them out.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#11

PS, heres a link  *LINK*

Barry Irby

>


Blower

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#12

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Steve Worcester

>Lets say you have a 20x20x10 shop,4000 cubic feet (if I get my math correct)

With a 1000CFM dust collector, you are sucking the shop air out in 4 minutes. Obviously you will still be able to breath because it has to pull the air from somewhere.

I talked to Onieda about putting the DC in my attic and they said the problem I will have is that air that gets taken out has to be replaced.

(Or in a perfect world, the room implodes) so it will replace the winter air outside with what's in the shop, or the summer air outside with what's in the shop. If you want to put the DC outside, you will have to exhaust back inside or find a way to replace the displace volume of air somehow.

Steve Worcester

www.turningwood.com

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#13

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Leppikallio

>The thing I would be worried about is the wind it will generate inside the shop when you are pushing that warm air outside and sucking that cold air to inside. Only little better situation is if you make some proper way for replacement air to come inside so that you can control the wind. Unfortunately this is quite common problem at least around here and probably where ever is cold winter... My back doesn't like that sort of "wind" that much anymore.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#14

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks everyone!

The filter is going, and the exhaust is going outside. One of the reasons for this is ease of maintenance, but the other is gaining just a little more room in the shop. I am not worried about makeup air, getting cold (or hot) or anything to do with the air. I have a radiant heater than can more than make up for any heat loss in the winter, and if it gets too hot in the summer, I retire to the pool! Besides, I was just given a brand new 18,000 BTU air conditioner that is going to replace the 12,500 BTU one that is in the shop now. I figure I should be able to get frost on the walls with that one!

Barry, I like that idea. If it were not for the shop being right up on the road, I would be able to sell the cyclone and put a huge squirrel cage in to blow shavings and all out into the field. Maybe for the next shop...

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#15

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

robo hippy

>Bill,

I did see a thread in Fine Woodworking a while back about some one who put the collector outside, and the filter inside the shop. The pleated paper filters from Oneida do not leak any dust. If you vent it outside, you will be surprised how fast your shop will cool down, or heat up. When the weather is nice, it won't matter.

robo hippy

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#16

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

eaglesc

>Along with your utillity bills rising there is one more thing to consider.

When you direct vent with no restriction the impeller is allowed to "free-wheel".Contrary to popular misconception this makes the motor work harder.

Best cast scenerio you will trip the thermal overload on the motor or trip the breaker.

Worst case scenerio premature motor burn out.

After you vent it outside check the amp draw to see if it is within the specs on the plate on the motor.

If it is higher, restrict the duct on the exhaust side to get the amp draw within limits.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#17

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Or, I could check with the people at Oneida about it. Which I did today.

And I really am not worried about my heating bill, at least not as much as everyone else seems to be. I'll just jack up the prices on my bowls if it gets to be a problem.

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#18

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Walter Ahlgrim

>Let�s think about safety, If we remove air from your shop it will be replace if all the doors and windows are closed the replacement air may flow backwards throw the furnace flue, filling the shop with carbon dioxide and flames could be drown out of the combustion chamber making a catastrophic fire a possibly. The blower could pull the water from pluming traps and pull sewer gases into the shop not only do they smell bad they can be flammable.

The cost of heating the replacement air works out like this. If the flow is 1400CFM and it is 0� F outside and 70� F inside you will need 641,454.55 BTU of heat per hour. If your furnace is 80% efficient you need to burn 801,818.19 BTU of gas, there are 100,000 BTU per therm or 8.01 therms per hour at 1.21 per therm = $9.69 per hour. Cheaper that I thought it would be did I miss something?

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#19

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Walter

You missed a couple of things. First, I have stated several times that I do not care about heat loss. I work in a drafty old building that is partially insulated. Despite that, it is warm without the furnace working hard at all. That furnace is a very high tech Reverberray radiant heater, forced air throughout, a straight tube on the end of a firebox.

You missed the part about the heater being radiant too. I am not heating air. I have enough experience with this shop in the winter to know that opening the door and leaving it open for long enough to completely exchange the air a couple of times over is not going to adversely affect the temperature to any significant degree. Sure the heater is going to come on, but not for long.

You also missed the part where I wrote in my original post that the DC is used for short periods of time. If it runs for an entire five minutes at a shot without being shut down for at least another five, that is a long time. If I throw caution and parsimony to the wind, I might run it 10 minutes at a time if I leave it on while I change sanding grits. The most it ever ran was when I used to do a production job sanding spindles. It ran at intervals timed to keep the motor starts under the specs laid out by the manufacturer, and ran for about 30 seconds per session. Oh yeah, if I am cleaning up the shop, it might run for 10-15 minutes, but that is the end of a session, the temperature is being turned down anyway, so who cares? Not me.

The closest sewer drain is over 150 feet away in a different building.

Zero degrees around here is a bit of an event, and rarely happens. Even more rare is 70� in the shop. Not even students from FL in Feb get it that warm. When I am in the shop, the temperature is 60�. When I am not in the shop, the temperature is 45�. Even during the bitterest cold of winter, which is unusual, but happens, I burn less than 100 gallons of propane in a month. During the course of a regular winter, that same 100 gallons will last me on average 45-60 days.

And, there is a part everyone missed because I did not mention it. I have gotten closer, although I am not there yet, with installing radiant heat supplied by my outdoor wood furnace, which is about 75 feet downwind from the shop. Once that is in, the propane becomes nothing more than a backup system, and I will be heating my house and shop by deforesting the planet.

To reiterate: Heat loss is not a concern for me. I am not going to address any heat loss comments or questions any further. I will continue to respond to this thread if other respondents read what I have written and address that specifically. Walter, I do not mean to pick on you, but you did ask if you missed anything.

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#20

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

eaglesc

>"Or, I could check with the people at Oneida about it. Which I did today."

Maybe you should have done that rather than ask for advice in starting this thread.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#21

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Yeah, maybe I should have. But then, I value the opinions and experiences of people I have gotten to know here, and I don't have the time to write each one individually. I don't know you. Who are you? Why should I believe anything you have to say? You don't have a real name associated with your posts, so where are your bona fides? I have no idea if you are a DC expert in reality or just in your own mind. For all I know you are simply parroting things you have read elsewhere. As a matter of fact, the motivation to call Oneida came from a good friend here who is also an engineer experienced in this sort of thing. But he is someone I know, in whose house I have been a guest, etc etc etc blah blah blah.

I realize this is contributing to the general acrimony that exists here right now, but no one forced you to even read my post, much less reply to it. I'll be blunt, since any other way is awful hard for me. I may be polite in my responses to people who do not have a real name, but I rarely if ever put any stock in any advice they offer. So next time you have an urge to give me advice, do us both a favor and resist it.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#22

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

eaglesc

>"I realize this is contributing to the general acrimony that exists here right now, but no one forced you to even read my post, much less reply to it. I'll be blunt, since any other way is awful hard for me. I may be polite in my responses to people who do not have a real name, but I rarely if ever put any stock in any advice they offer. So next time you have an urge to give me advice, do us both a favor and resist it. "

Everything I wrote is based in fact.The name behind it or the lack makes no difference.

Have any kind of day you wish.