Re: My 2-cents worth (long)
DickAnderson
>With more than a passing interest I have read numerous posts on the Wood Central site of woodturners thoughts and opinions on juried art shows and now the AAW not meeting the majorities needs. First there are many media of art and within each media a multitude of styles, forms, designs and personal expressions. I enjoy many types and styles of art and obviously have some personal preferences, as most people do. My wife and I have attended many art shows and frequently visit art galleries and museums. As a result of our interests we have purchased a variety of art objects, including paintings and works in clay, wood, fabric, reeds and metal. As a woodturner I have not participated in a juried art show and only have had my work in a limited number of galleries. With that preamble here are my thoughts on the current controversies of woodturning as art and on woodturning critiques.
One of the past Wood Central posts stated;
�Wooden art is lumped in with pottery, sculpture and other three dimensional work which it should be but is hardly given the same weight as those other media.�
I agree and my fairly extensive library of sculptural and art books and art magazines (Sculptural Pursuit, Wildlife Art, Southwest Art, Art Works - A Voice for the Arts and others) supports this observation. The various art magazines cover a wide variety of paintings, works of glass, stone, pottery, and metal sculptures, but very seldom do any of these art magazines feature anything on woodworking or woodturning. However, Sculptural Pursuit (several issues back) did feature Jacques Vesery and his work, but this was a rare occurrence. The upshot of this to me then is; where is wood �art� in the broader public�s eye and what can woodworkers (woodturners) do to promote to a wider public audience (market) wood as a form of art?
Is it possible that wood works are too young to have achieved broad public acceptance as a legitimate art form and is generally considered a craft; or, that woodworkers have not adequately promoted their work as art; or, that there is not a sufficient amount of quality work (in other words too much low quality craft work and cheap imports) to stimulate a higher level of public respect and interest; or is there another reason why wood works are not being featured in general art publications, but are more or less limited to woodworking specific publications.
Although wood �art� is not widely recognized by the public, efforts are being made to promote wood art as indicated in one Wood Central post:
��we must continue to build a reputation for wood as a viable ART medium. Within the last 10~15 yrs. woodturning has begun to be recognized, and in part that recognition is due to entities like Collectors of Wood Art, AAW, the Woodturning Center, and the individual collectors who have championed the cause thru their high profile efforts.�
So, what additional efforts can be done by woodturners to promote wood as a true art form?
There are many issues and questions to be explored in group discussions as was done during the 2007 AAW symposium. Those discussions were very worthwhile, but only scratched the surface and reached a small audience. Example of issues and questions include:
� Is the current effort to promote wood art being hindered by a division between craft and art within the woodturning ranks?
� Do we really understand what traditional and contemporary woodturning has been and is becoming? The historical perspective seems to be lacking in the rapidly growing field of woodworking and woodturning.
� Is a lack of understanding of the history of woodworking adversely influencing our critiques and juried selections?
� Craftsmanship once was a highly respected and revered term. Now the term craft seems to denote a lesser quality of workmanship causing some organizations to remove the term from their title. Should this be a concern to the artist who strives for high quality in his/her work?
Craft vs. Art. Another notable Wood Central posting stated:
��many in the wood turning field criticize the art turners who, in their opinion, are ruining the craft. The simple fact is the art turners are the ones who are elevating our craft to the higher levels, and are the driving force behind the wood art movement. The art turners are an important part of the turning community.�
Here we go again --- the differences between the proponents of craft and proponents of art. Or is it the difference between those who want to produce inexpensive craft sale work vs. those that want to achieve the upper end gallery/museum market sale. Some artisans want to make their livelihood through their woodworking by producing high quality art forms, which requires many hours of dedicated work. However, I don�t know of anyone making a living solely through craft work.
It would appear that �craft work� is being produced by non-craftsmen thus redefining craft as a lower level of quality from that originally associated with craftsmanship.
I enjoy AAW, its publication and appreciate the boards and staffs work. I also enjoy the several woodturning publications I subscribe to and get something out of each of them. If you can't find something good in AAW then maybe you need to try harder and use more imagination.