Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

If you don't like the AAW Journal....

Posts

If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#1

If you don't like the AAW Journal....

russ Fairfield

>All of the messages in a recent thread talk as though the American Woodturner is the only game in town. It is not. There are several alternatives whose content is projects for the beginning and intermediate skill levels. One of these is Woodturning Design. It is published 4 times a year, its cost is a couple dollars less than $11 per issue, and it covers everything from furniture parts to pens to lidded boxes and salad bowls in almost every issue. The other is More Woodturning, and it is published 11 times a year for about the same price. Add to that the turning articles that regularly appear in Wood Magazine, American Woodworker, Fine Woodworking, and the other general woodworking publications on the newsstand.

It seems to me that by looking through all of the available magazines we will find the needs of that majority of woodturners we concerned about have already been taken care of.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#2

You are right, Russ. This is a time ...

Ed Moore

>of growth for the the woodturning community. Changes in the AAW look to me as if there is some forward-thinking going on. I believe that the AAW is healthy and serving us well.

As I said below, no good structure is built by undermining. And, regretfully, I feel that the constant carping and whining demeans an individual who has long enjoyed a good reputation among turners. It isn't as drastic as Michael Vick, but the same self-destructive behavior seems to be occurring.

There are some good people running for the AAW Board. If folks keep throwing rocks rather than building new turning opportunities, why should these good folks make themselves available? Nothing seems to please the naysayers.

Ed

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#3

Steven Antonucci

12 Angry Men

steve antonucci

>and a few angry women.

TD-

A word of advice: A few months/years ago (I don't recall), I had a disagreement with the moderator of another forum. I didn't like the way he ran it, so I left.

Yesterday, I got 5 renewal notices from it, and I deleted the first 4. The fifth one, I replied asking to be taking off of the list.

I support your right to disagree with the agenda of the AAW, but let it go. There's nothing good coming from yelling at the castle walls. If you want to be heard, join and change from the inside.

Steven

A fellow non-AAW member with nothing to complain about except that I couldn't join online this year and hate printing things out and mailing them...

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#4

Dead Racoons

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I am with you Ed,

I have been involved in starting several clubs in my day, one a furniture society. It was a lot of hard work, setting up the membership a place to meet and keeping the topics fresh and interesting. All the founding members bust our behinds to get it going and keep it going. What amazes me after 6 years is that when new people come in and think about joining the club some have no interest in investing in the hard work to keep it going or build it up. They pay no respect to what has been created, what it took to get it there and what it will take to move it forward.

It's easy to toss stones at something that is there if it does not suit your needs, most people have the common curtisy to move on, others want to tear things down, to me those who do so show no character or class and I am glad to see them leave. The best you can do is respect what has been done before and how you can support in change, complaining and doing nothing about it is a waste of everyone's time, as My Dad used to say "Stop Tossing Me a Dead Racoon, Change It Your Self".

Our furniture club continues, we turn over about 30-50% of the club annually, but I find it very supportive, we all learn from each other and that is why I feel giving my energies back and making a difference is all worth while, I still get something out of it.

Take care,

Jim

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#5

Please re-read before posting......

Ruth Niles

>Since the 3 (so far) responses have absolutely nothing to do with Russ's original post, I think it should be posted again. Here is what Russ said,

"All of the messages in a recent thread talk as though the American Woodturner is the only game in town. It is not. There are several alternatives whose content is projects for the beginning and intermediate skill levels. One of these is Woodturning Design. It is published 4 times a year, its cost is a couple dollars less than $11 per issue, and it covers everything from furniture parts to pens to lidded boxes and salad bowls in almost every issue. The other is More Woodturning, and it is published 11 times a year for about the same price. Add to that the turning articles that regularly appear in Wood Magazine, American Woodworker, Fine Woodworking, and the other general woodworking publications on the newsstand.

It seems to me that by looking through all of the available magazines we will find the needs of that majority of woodturners we concerned about have already been taken care of."

See, no mention of AAW, membership or commitments........ just a list of all the other magazines available if you are not satisfied with the You-Know-What Journal. You guys have me paranoid to even say the name for fear of having to go to confession!

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#6

Re: My 2-cents worth (long)

DickAnderson

>With more than a passing interest I have read numerous posts on the Wood Central site of woodturners thoughts and opinions on juried art shows and now the AAW not meeting the majorities needs. First there are many media of art and within each media a multitude of styles, forms, designs and personal expressions. I enjoy many types and styles of art and obviously have some personal preferences, as most people do. My wife and I have attended many art shows and frequently visit art galleries and museums. As a result of our interests we have purchased a variety of art objects, including paintings and works in clay, wood, fabric, reeds and metal. As a woodturner I have not participated in a juried art show and only have had my work in a limited number of galleries. With that preamble here are my thoughts on the current controversies of woodturning as art and on woodturning critiques.

One of the past Wood Central posts stated;

�Wooden art is lumped in with pottery, sculpture and other three dimensional work which it should be but is hardly given the same weight as those other media.�

I agree and my fairly extensive library of sculptural and art books and art magazines (Sculptural Pursuit, Wildlife Art, Southwest Art, Art Works - A Voice for the Arts and others) supports this observation. The various art magazines cover a wide variety of paintings, works of glass, stone, pottery, and metal sculptures, but very seldom do any of these art magazines feature anything on woodworking or woodturning. However, Sculptural Pursuit (several issues back) did feature Jacques Vesery and his work, but this was a rare occurrence. The upshot of this to me then is; where is wood �art� in the broader public�s eye and what can woodworkers (woodturners) do to promote to a wider public audience (market) wood as a form of art?

Is it possible that wood works are too young to have achieved broad public acceptance as a legitimate art form and is generally considered a craft; or, that woodworkers have not adequately promoted their work as art; or, that there is not a sufficient amount of quality work (in other words too much low quality craft work and cheap imports) to stimulate a higher level of public respect and interest; or is there another reason why wood works are not being featured in general art publications, but are more or less limited to woodworking specific publications.

Although wood �art� is not widely recognized by the public, efforts are being made to promote wood art as indicated in one Wood Central post:

��we must continue to build a reputation for wood as a viable ART medium. Within the last 10~15 yrs. woodturning has begun to be recognized, and in part that recognition is due to entities like Collectors of Wood Art, AAW, the Woodturning Center, and the individual collectors who have championed the cause thru their high profile efforts.�

So, what additional efforts can be done by woodturners to promote wood as a true art form?

There are many issues and questions to be explored in group discussions as was done during the 2007 AAW symposium. Those discussions were very worthwhile, but only scratched the surface and reached a small audience. Example of issues and questions include:

� Is the current effort to promote wood art being hindered by a division between craft and art within the woodturning ranks?

� Do we really understand what traditional and contemporary woodturning has been and is becoming? The historical perspective seems to be lacking in the rapidly growing field of woodworking and woodturning.

� Is a lack of understanding of the history of woodworking adversely influencing our critiques and juried selections?

� Craftsmanship once was a highly respected and revered term. Now the term craft seems to denote a lesser quality of workmanship causing some organizations to remove the term from their title. Should this be a concern to the artist who strives for high quality in his/her work?

Craft vs. Art. Another notable Wood Central posting stated:

��many in the wood turning field criticize the art turners who, in their opinion, are ruining the craft. The simple fact is the art turners are the ones who are elevating our craft to the higher levels, and are the driving force behind the wood art movement. The art turners are an important part of the turning community.�

Here we go again --- the differences between the proponents of craft and proponents of art. Or is it the difference between those who want to produce inexpensive craft sale work vs. those that want to achieve the upper end gallery/museum market sale. Some artisans want to make their livelihood through their woodworking by producing high quality art forms, which requires many hours of dedicated work. However, I don�t know of anyone making a living solely through craft work.

It would appear that �craft work� is being produced by non-craftsmen thus redefining craft as a lower level of quality from that originally associated with craftsmanship.

I enjoy AAW, its publication and appreciate the boards and staffs work. I also enjoy the several woodturning publications I subscribe to and get something out of each of them. If you can't find something good in AAW then maybe you need to try harder and use more imagination.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#7

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

RonZ

>For now, I only woodturn so that's the magzines I stick to. While it is expensive, the Woodturning UK magazine, IMHO, is the very best. The only magazine I haven't tried is More Woodturning, which I hope to soon. I help distribute Woodturning Design in Israel and its a good magazine.

Being located in a 'central' area, I can examine woodturning from most locations. The USA has made advances and New Zealand has probably the most woodturners per capita. While I try and learn from everyone, the UK, to me, is the turning capital of the world. You've got towns and families that are generations of woodturners that go back further than the establishment of the USA. They emphesize learning skills and then branch out as well as spindle work. BTW, they complain that they don't explore like the Americans.

Now if you want to complain about AAW, one need only to see the IAW here in Israel. Pitiful at best, leaving at least me, with no real source for development. You need to apreciate what you have.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#8

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

Gordon Seto

>I think the best magazines are the Woodturning from UK and the quarterly from AAW.

I let my More Woodturning subscription lapsed after Lyn J. Mangiameli stopped writing those reviews. It was mostly the diary of the author hanging out with the big name turners. It is not my cup of tea. I wish Lyn well.

Gordon

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#9

The Grass is Always Greener.......

Ruth Niles

>sort of thing, right, Ron?

I think the "Woodturning" magazine from the UK is the best, too. Maybe because, like you said, it is where woodturning is a family and community profession or craft and it's not much different than cooking. Here it's mostly art or a hobby. Because of that difference, that magazine has more recipes for tasty turnings! : ) I think Allan Batty is the best (hands down) demonstrator because the tools are like his hands and he can, literally, do anything with them.

Question: are there as many signature tools over there as we have here? For some reason, I imagine the rest of the world having 1 maybe 2 sets of very fine turning tools. Seems we're tool junkies. Dan Geiger has a wonderful saying that I'm having printed on

t-shirts: "We're all one tool away from greatness."

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#10

But its just as hard to mow...>>>

RonZ

>..>> Nah, here is bad, hands down. I'd invite you to see but why bother.

Yep, Allen Batty is arguably the best but I think Raffan is up there, too. I gained so much from taking his class. IMHO at least one dark horse to watch out for is Jimmy Clewes.

Americans are tools junkies, hands down. Heck, I'm guilty myself. That's whay I got into selling turning supplies, to support my habit. ;o) Most European and Down-unders pride themselves on using the least ammount of tools for the job. Many turners will only use one gouge to do a whole bowl.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#11

Re: But its just as hard to mow...>>>

Ruth Niles

>I am not a tool junkie and will do as much as I possibly can with whatever tool I have in my hand. I call myself a "lazy" turner because I'll use a tool not meant for a particular cut just because it's in my hand. You'd be surprised what a given tool can do! : )

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#12

Steven Antonucci

It's about aligning your choices and interests...

steve antonucci

>I'd hope that people didn't think that the thread was about magazines... Who joins AAW just for the magazine? I'd hope it had more to offer than just that.

My point was simple. We all have the ability to decide for ourselves where we associate ourselves. If we want change to happen, we need to contribute constructively. If we're not willing to donate time and energy, complaining doesn't help. I don't spend time fixing things that can't be fixed (assuming that I see them as broken, YMMV).

Thanks for trying to explain it to me, though ;-)

Steve

(who has met Joanne twice at Fiuve Barns, but can think for himself...)

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#13

Steven Antonucci

Sorry Joanne, I meant Ruth

steve antonucci

>I had just read one of your posts, and had your name in my head...

Steve

(Who has also met Ruth, albeit only once, at Five Barns...)

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#14

Re: Jim-dead racoons??? That's one....

Jamie Donaldson

>... an expression I've never heard before and don't understand the relevance?? Is it a family joke or legend??

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#15

Re: But its just as hard to mow...>>>

Phil Powell

>I'm with you Ruth. I just a bunch of wine bottle stoppers from you and I've been working

hard to finish all the wood parts. I picked up a Sweazey 3/8's bowl gouge to do the first

one and haven't changed gouges yet and I'm on #18. OK a parting tool and a skew but

that's it. Maybe I should develop a Swiss Army Knife type of gouge......then I would never

have to leave the lathe.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#16

Could Have Fooled Me

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I went back and re-read the post Russ made. If it wasn't about different magazines available to woodturners who weren't happy with the AAW magazines I need to practice reading comprehension.

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#17

dont forget WOODTURNING, english mag.

robert davis

>

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#18

A Swiss Army Gouge, what a good idea!!!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#19

Jamie, My Dad Used to Say It When ...

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi JAmie,

My dad would say that when I'd bring him my problems with no solutions...It was his way of getting me to see past a problem and start to look for my own solutions...

He would call "It tossing Him a Dead Racoon" when ever I did that....he got me to think for myself shortly after that....the Dead Raccoon got tossed a few times by brothers too, they soon learned no one likes a dead Raccoon...it was my Dad's way and expression.

Take care,

Jim

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#20

Steven Antonucci

Non Sequitur

steve antonucci

>My understanding is that AAW publishes the AW magazine four times a year, yet everyone is equating that membership equals a subscription. It does not. My American Woodturners were $7.50, not $11 an issue, so there must be more to offer to an AAW member than just a magazine I can get at the local B&N. I only buy the ones that I'm interested in reading. Some issues have nothing for me, so I leave them.

So if you want to buy the magazine, then buy it. If you don't, don't. There is no rule that says you can't buy more than one, and positively no "best" magazine for everyone- only your individual choice.

My read of the post by Russ was that we all have options about what we read, but based upon the other commentary prior, I understood its' intent. I merely attempted to offer good advice which had been given to me in a similar situation: either fight the establishment or walk away. Seems TD and I have made the same choices. I made no attempt to debate his position, since it is not up to me to "take sides" on an argument that I have no vested interest in.

Somedays, I try to wave a peace flag. Most days, probably not. There is no right and wrong here- only a bunch of people getting fired up over nothing and taking sides in a stupid argument.

Even so, I'd rather see exchange with dissent than 100 attaboy posts...

Steven

Anyone else want to discuss which magazine is "the best"?

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#21

Rob Wallace

Re: The Grass is Always Greener.......

Rob Wallace

>..... Ruth, Isn't that DON Geiger, from Florida?

Rob Wallace

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#22

Oops, sorry, it is Don Geiger.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#23

Attaboy!

Joe Pack

>Sorry, Steven, couldn't resist. :-)))))

Re: If you don't like the AAW Journal....

#24

Steven Antonucci

Good one ;-)

steve antonucci

>