Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Posts

Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#1

Andy DiPietro

Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Andy DiPietro

>Hi Everyone,

This hollow form has heavy bark inclusions on one side. Should I have tried to limit the number of inclusions or does it look more appealing they way it is. This piece is 9� diameter x 15� high. Critiques are welcome.

Thanks

Andy DiPietro


img

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#2

Andy DiPietro

Pic2 Back View 

Andy DiPietro

>


img

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#3

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Carole Valentine

>That's a big one! Personally, I like the earthy look of bark inclusions. Nice piece, Andy. What is the wall thickness?

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#4

Re: Pic2 Back View

Carole Valentine

>Like the front better! To me, the front looks more like cherry burl than maple but the back looks like plain spalted maple. Strange.

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#5

Andy DiPietro

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Andy DiPietro

>Thanks Carole,

The wall thickness is 1/8" all the way down except for the bottom, which is about 1/4" thick. The maple tree had two stumps squeezed together, which created the heavy bark inclusions. It does resemble cherry from the front.

Andy D.

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#6

Re: Pic2 Back View

john pickett

>The front is definitely more interesting.

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#7

Andy DiPietro

One Bark Inclusion � same log

Andy DiPietro

>This HF is from the same log but I made it smaller to remove most of the bark inclusions. It finished up at 6" diameter x 10" high x 1/8" wall. I like this better since it only has one bark inclusion and the spalting is pretty uniform all the way around. Which one looks better?

Thanks

Andy D.


img

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#8

Andy DiPietro

Back View 

Andy DiPietro

>


img

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#9

I like them both---------

Jake Niedling

>The wood and the shape are very nice. Good job.

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#10

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Gerry Meekins

>Hey Andy,

Looks like you got a 2fer! Get tired of looking at it on the shelf just do a 180.. Then you have a whole new piece. I like both sides equally.. Musta been fun turning it.

Gerry

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#11

Steven Antonucci

I like the first one better

steve antonucci

>For me, one hole looks like an accident, but lots of holes are a design feature!

Seriously, I think it balances the piece better to have a bunch of holes/inclusions. I'd also consider picking out the bark to unify the color balance from front to back.

You should bring this piece to Albany for the Instant Gallery.

Steve

P.S. I think I found some ambrosia maple in my buddies wood pile. I'll have to trade him seasoned firewood for it, but that's the breaks, huh? I'll save you some.

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#12

Steve Kubien

Contrary opinion

Steve Kubien

>Looks like I'm in the minority but I like the smaller one better and I like the 2nd views without the inclusions better. Why? I think the bark makes it look too busy and, to my eye, takes away from the wood itself. Just my opinion and worth exactly what you paid for it.

Steve Kubien

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#13

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Andy,

I like it as it is! Personalyl I like to see the bark inclusions. They give the piece a very organic feel and/or make it look more "natural".

Se eya around,

Dominic

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#14

Re: Bark Inclusions cost extra!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#15

Ric Taylor

On This One I Like the Back Side

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

#16

Re: Bark Inclusions � Spalted Maple HF

George Van

>That is a nicely spalted form Andy. In fact great form! I would go for the first with the inclusions and the chatoyance. The second one does seem to show the inclusion as a problem rather that a feature IMHO.