Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Posts

Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#1

Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>Hi Everyone,

The other day I was in the city and feeling very "low" as I had been told that I had a tumor in the esophagus. CAT scan failed to confirm this and gastroscopy indicated pre cancerous cells. After I got out of hospital, I went straight to Lee Valley and bought a detail gouge to cheer myself up. I made a cherry handle for it today but now that I look at the grind on the gouge, I am not sure what to do with it. I have included pics that show how it came and would appreciate any hints on how to grind or regrind it. The gouge actually has 2 grinds, one at 25degrees and the small grind at approx. 50 degrees

Next time I buy a tool it will be from Doug Thompson!

Thanks for the help in advance,

Wayne


img

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#2

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

ted okolichany

>I bought the same gouge from P&N directly at the Southern States gathering in Gainsville, GA last April. I was told to only sharpen the upper part and nothing else. It a very fine grind..Works for me!

Ted

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Steve Kubien

>Evening Wayne,

Thankfully, I have no experience with such things but what does "pre-cancerous cells" mean? Is surgery in the near future or is there another way to deal with this? Best of wishes no matter what and hoping this isn't as serious as it sounds.

I can't help you with the gouge. I've got a Thompson detail gouge and I simply lay it on its side with the groove facing away from the belt (I use a belt sander, not a grinder for sharpening) and roll it, maintaining bevel-to-belt contact. When one half of the bevel is done, I turn the gouge around so the handle is on the other side and repeat. A very light touch to get rid of any unevenness (is that a word?) in the centre of the bevel and I'm off to the races.

Hope this helps.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#4

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Bill Neddow

>Michael Hosiluk, who first introduced these gouges to North America, grinds the square chisel off and turns it into a fingernail shape. That simply involves grinding back the sides to turn it into a fingernail.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#5

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Carole Valentine

>That little secondary bevel should come in handy on detail work. I have put one on my gouges on occasion when doing really tight stuff.

Sorry to hear about your health problem. I guess the good news is "Pre"? Does that mean they can get it without too much trouble?

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#6

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Peter Teubel

>Personally, I would match the long bevel and grind away (using an appropriate jig, of course). The small tip goes almost anywhere a skew could go and the long side edge works great for shearing cuts in thin spindle work. I also grind away about half the heel for better clearance.

Yes, mine is a Thompson.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#7

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>Hi Steve,

The health problem is a minor setback? Pre cancerous cells are cells that have changed from normal to displastic-the next step is cancer and the operation sounds grim. They chop out much of the esophagus and then pull the stomach up neat the throat and re-attach. I hope I go from natural causes before that? The good news is that it is slow progressing but have to get scoped regularly and biopsied.

Thaks for the info and help.

Wayne

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#8

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>Hi Carol,

I think I will try it the way its ground after I sharpen it better before I commit to altering the profile. I bought it on a whim and I will now have to learn to use it!

Hopefully the medical problem will resapond to medicine as the operation sounds aweful (they chop out most of the esophagus and bring the stomach up and re-attach near the throat. Fortunately (according to the surgeon) the condition is slow to develop and I am keeping my fingers and toes crossed. Thanks for the insight on the gouge.

Wayne

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#9

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

RonZ

>Hi Wayne,

Lets hope its slower than molasses in the winter and you out live it.

99.9% of the tools out there are not ground for use or are ground in such a way its difficult to re-grind it the way it was bought, i.e. Osolnik, Avisera, Ray Key tools, etc.. I recommend you grind it to what works best for you. Almot all my spindle gouges are 30deg and long grind if that helps.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Mike Stafford

>I do just exactly as Bill describes with my detail gouge. I have the same gouge and use it for boxes. I have pictured the grind on another detail gouge I have for your consideration.


img

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#11

Mike Stafford

It is the one at the bottom....

Mike Stafford

>I got ahead of myself and failed to identify the detail gouge in the picture. The one at the bottom of the picture is a Packard Woodworks 1/2" detail gouge I use for box exteriors.

The other two gouges pictured are detail gouges as well with different grinds I use for hollowing boxes.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#12

You made an interesting ...

Ed Moore

>comment. "Next time I buy a tool it will be from Doug Thompson!"

Why not treat yourself to a Doug Thompson detail gouge, maybe a 3/8", which is his most popular tool! Then, duplicate the grind on the Thompson gouge on your P&N detail gouge. Then you would have two detail gouges and you can see which one you like best.

I find 30 degree grinds on spindle/detail gouges to be a little catchy. If you check the sharpening page on Doug's website you will see that he recommends a 40 degree grind, which I think is less aggressive.

And I wish you the best with your medical problems.

Ed

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#13

Re: It is the one at the bottom....

john lucas

>I ground a P@N gouge for a friend the other night. We put a grind almost exactly like the thompson gouge. It looks very much like the bottom photo that Mike sent.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#14

Thanks to everyone who replied

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>to my grind question and also to my extended family for their well wishes-this is just a temporary setback! Sure glad I have woodturning and friends like you all!

I will order a 3/8 detail gouge from Doug when I get down south at the end of Oct. (if my medical problem allows it)!

I have an old spindle gouge that I will experiment with different grinds to see if it helps me with this.

Thats what is fun about turning-always interesting and never dull.

Best regards,

Wayne

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#15

Re: Thanks to everyone who replied

Wilford Bickel

>I watched the Bruce Bell demos before I bought that same gouge at SSS this past April. All he does is lay it on the grinding wheel and bring the long bevel into a sharp point across the width of the tool - real similar to a skew. It really allowed him to get into tight areas like where you have a square pommel going into the round and need to clean up the change. Also he was using it to clean up the edges of beads where they came back into the body of the work. It is for very detailed work as it's name says. I have another detail gouge ground like the bottom one in the picture and there are times this one with the long bevel will get into areas that one cannot.

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#16

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Jorge Castaneda

>Wayne,

Hope you feel better, the detail gouge kas quite a learning curve, but once over the hump is a very versatile tool, think of it as a skew in a different atire.

I will make pictures of mine, they came with a different grind than yours and I kept it.

Have fun!

jorge

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

#17

Re: Help needed on grinding P&N detail gougee

Mike Nelson

>Thank you Bill & Mike! I rarely used the gouge because of the corners catching and the slight curve tending to run up the piece! After reading your post I ground mine back and now have a heavy fingernail gouge that works great! Mike