Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Endgrain micrographs?

Posts

Endgrain micrographs?

#1

Endgrain micrographs?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

Just wondering if anyone has a link to a more extensive collection of endgrain photos than the one in "Understanding Wood". I'm looking specifically for Chinaberry.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#2

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

Mark Wollschlager

>Not micrographs as much as close ups, but might be helpful.

http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/chinaberry.htm

http://www.hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/lilac.htm

Mark.

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#3

Identifying Wood by Bruce Hoadly

Ron in Drums PA

>Great book with microscopic pictures, but chinaberry is not in it

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#4

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

Jason Clark

>Gary, Have you tried the following link?

http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/specialcollections/forestry/hough/common.html

Jason

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#5

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, Mark,

I appreciate the links. After looking at your pics and the ones that

Jason recommended, I'm pretty sure that Chinaberry is not what I have.

What makes this I.D. difficult is that these trees were damaged in the fire that took down the sheds next to the store, so any bark tht is still there has been well-scorched.

The wood is red with a bit of a brown tint with a much lighter sapwood. I'll try to get some pics tomorrow and post them. Maybe somebody will know it.

Thanks much,

Gary

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#6

Re: Identifying Wood by Bruce Hoadly

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks Ron,

That book is on my "I'm going to buy that one of these days," list. I borrowed JKJ's copy a year or two ago. It's a great book. It might have the wood that I'm trying to I.D. I'm pretty sure now that it isn't Chinaberry.

Gary

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#7

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, Jason,

That is one I hadn't seen before. Unfortunately, I'm back to square one, because the wood I have does not resemble the endgrain shots of Chinaberry.

Gary

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#8

JL

Re: Send me a picture or two (end and side)...

JL

>I've got a copy of "The Woodbook" from Taschen by Romeyn Beck Hough.

It has end grain, radial and tangential pictures of most American woods. I checked already and it has Chinaberry.

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#9

Re: I think Hobbit House is mistaken.

Allen Neighbors

>Ever had a time when you recognise that some folks just keep perpetuating a mistake? And can't seem to get the point across?

This is such a case. Chinaberry and/or Hackberry wood is often mistakenly named as the other.

As are a few tree booklets and Websites, in this hobbithouse link, the writer has confused Hackberry and Chinaberry wood. Chinaberry trees grow yellowish berries in clusters of 3 or more. The Hackberry grows it's berries, which are nearly black, in singles.

I've cut probably 25 Chinaberry trees over the last few years. Also a few Hackberry.

The wood shown in the Chinaberry article on the Hobbithouse Website is Hackberry, not Chinaberry.

Chinaberry is a very blonde wood, and almost never has any color to it other than blonde. And I've never seen blonde Hackberry.

Just my most humble opinion.

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#10

Re: Endgrain micrographs? *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>Gary,

Don't forget about the free wood ID service the government offers. (Link below) I haven't tried, but they apparently offer to ID up to five samples per year for US citizens.

I've started to save known samples of wood for future reference but I don't have any chinaberry. My 15-30x binocular microscope has been a real help.

BTW, I wonder if what you really want is macro- rather than micro- photos. Hoadley uses lower power for most hardwoods since many can be identified by pore distribution (recommends a 10x hand lens I think) and goes to the cell level with a higher powered microscope only when necessary.

Also, this link has photomicrographs: http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/trees/index.html. No chinaberry, but you might want to save the link for future reference.

JKJ


USDA Forest Products Laboratory

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#11

Woodbook online *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>..The Woodbook

Hey JL,

It appears the photos from (one copy of) Hough's The Woodbook are available online at the link Jason Clark provided (repeated below). But I don't see the text which is unfortunate.

Chinaberry is in Volume V, listed as Bead Tree (Melia azedarach), plate 105.

I also have a copy of The Woodbook and find it interesting and useful, but one thing to watch out for is some of the common names have changed since the the original was published long ago.

The fluidity of common wood names is the reason most experts suggest to always include the scientific name to minimize confusion. For example, chinaberry is also known as persian lilac, nimwood, white cedar, chinatree, chinese umbrella tree, paraiso, pride of india, bead tree, and probably others.

For those not familiar with The Woodbook, the original was a set of huge volumes, each containing thin slices of real wood samples. Each "copy" of the book then had unique wood sections. The book available in print today contains photos from all volumes of just one of the unique "copies". The photos in the link are from a different set of volumes and are quite different from those in my printed copy. This emphasizes to me how difficult it is to make an accurate ID from photographs - the appearance of wood can vary tremendously even within the same tree. This is why the ID methods described in Hoadley's books are so useful.

JKJ


Hough Woodbook photos

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#12

Re: I think Hobbit House is mistaken.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Allen,

I agree with you on the difference in berries, but I think you went dyslexic on the difference in wood color. The Chinaberry I've seen has all had a reddish heartwood. Our Hackberry is always a white wood, until I spalt it, of course.

Gary


img

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#13

Re: Woodbook online

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Jerome and John,

The (macro, thanks John) pics from the Hough book online that Jason suggested are what convinced me that I don't have Chinaberry. The horizontal distribution of cells on the endgrain is something my wood doesn't have.

The wood that it most closely resembles in "Understanding Wood" is Mulberry, but this wood is a brownish red. One of the reasons I was guessing Chinaberry is that I seem to remember the trees having a very frilly compound leaf. Of course, that was before the fire and it could have been the leaves from the multiplicity of vines that were growing in the tops of these trees.

I hope to get down to the store a little later this morning to lop a piece in two with the chainsaw and take some pics. More later.

This might be a good one to send off some samples, but as rarely as I can get to the post office, I don't know when I might get them sent. Sean Troy is still waiting for some spalted samples to use to inoculate some of his maple. I think it's been two weeks since I promised to send it. It's coming soon, Sean, I promise. I actually got the box addressed the other day. 8^]

Gary

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#14

Re: Woodbook online

JKJ in East TN

>>The (macro, thanks John) pics from the Hough book online...

Actually, the sections photographed in the Hough book are relatively huge compared to the photos in the Hoadley book. I can't find the reference at the moment, but I somehow have the impression the samples were on the order of 5-6" wide.

BTW, the Mulberry I cut recently was a brownish red when fresh. However, the blanks I prepared on the bandsaw lost the red quickly.

JKJ

Re: Endgrain micrographs?

#15

Re: Woodbook online

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi John,

Actually, I feel a little embarassed by the fact that I try to make some income from local hardwoods. This is one that I don't know, and I have 4 decent sized trees from the fire that we had at the store several months back. The brownish-red heartwood is more red than brown, the endgrain resembles the endgrain of mulberry at the macro level, but not a perfect match.

You are certainly correct about the scale of the pics between the two books. I could see, though, from the pics on the Hough website, that my wood doesn't have that distinctive horizontal (to the rays)cell pattern running around all over the place.

I took after a crotch cut this afternoon with an electric hand planer and 60 grit sandpaper. I'll put up some pics in a day or two.

It will be worth the effort to find out what it is.

Gary