Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

Posts

Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#1

Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

Ed Moore

>I received a question from someone on WC asking if the cutter from one could be put on the other. But this doesn't address that. I simply took the cover off the Munro Mini tool and straightened it since it is articulated and tried to see if it would cut similar to the Hunter when used the same way.

First, the Munro cutter is about 0.3" in diameter and the Hunter #3 is about 0.4" in diameter. The Hunter cutter is very shallow and by comparison the Munro Mini is rather deep.

My observation on a piece of poplar and a piece of pear is that the depth of the Munro cutter makes it more aggressive and a bit grabby. For quick removal of material the Munro would seem to win. But the Hunter mas much easier to control and didn't grab. I found that when cutting a cup in the end-grain I had to move the handle of the Munro to the right more or it would shriek and cut a groove. The Hunter was more forgiving when making the same cut. I think this was entirely due to the difference in the depth of the cutters. With the tool facing to the left, say at 9 o'clock, I found that I didn't want to rotate it more than to about 10 o'clock when cutting.

I guess I should return to the test pieces and see how the Munro does with the cover on it, which of course was how it was designed to be used. The cover might make it difficult to cut a small cup as I was doing. Or at least one would need to really move the Munro handle to the right to do that.

Since inquiring minds wanted to know,

Ed

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#2

I put the cover/shield back on the ...

Ed Moore

>Munro Mini and tested it on the endgrain of a piece of maple. It cut much better, except that it would jam a little since the shavings pass between the cutter and the cover. I anticipated that the Munro would be more sensitive to the angle of the tool handle relative to the surface of the wood and I was right. A mathematician/engineer would say that the tool handle must be almost normal to the surface (perpendicular)in order for it to cut efficiently. The Hunter was much more forgiving here.

Because the Munro is articulated, the toolrest must set further back from the wood than when using the Hunter. I feel that this gives less control.

I don't foresee hollowing boxes with the Hunter or the Munro Mini, but I sure do plan to use the Hunter for final shaping and finishing cuts on the interior of boxes and maybe lids.

I hope that this helps someone,

Ed

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: I put the cover/shield back on the ...

Mike Stafford

>Ed, I would love to see pictures of the Hunter or the Munro articulated in use on the inside of boxes and box lids. I have not tried that type of cutting on boxes yet and would enjoy anything that would help smooth out the process. At present I am using just spindle gouges and scrapers for the process. I am using a hook nosed scraper for hollowing the insides of my semi-enclosed box forms. Do you think these tools would be superior to my current method?

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#4

I'm not really set up to ...

Ed Moore

>take pictures of a tool cutting. Maybe you should plan on coming up for a visit and trying them both out. You can test drive the Robust at the same time. We can have a box-turning Fest! Maybe Carole Valentine and Jennifer Shirley would like to come at the same time. Think about it!

Ed

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#5

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

Mike Nelson

>I have a Munro and find you have to close the hood almost all the way to have any reasonable control but then it clogs on most woods which is a real pain since you have to unscrew the hood to clear the shavings. If you open the hood, it cuts deep furrows if you aren't very careful and still clogs. OK for rough hollowing. I am anxious to try the hunter.

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#6

Re: I put the cover/shield back on the ...

john lucas

>Mike due a search for hunter tools and see if the photos I put up on their use are still there. I don't know if I still have them. I'll look. I love the hunter tools for finishing boxes. The only thing I don't like about them is hollowing a box from scratch. They don't want to cut the very center. If you drill out the center this isn't a problem. I love the finish I get off the hunter tools. It lets me start sanding a lot higher than normal when I use these tools.

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#7

Re: I put the cover/shield back on the ...

Leppikallio

>For some reason I think that for boxes gouges and scrapers are best. Well of course it depends how big is the box and how closed it is but usually there is quite big opening in boxes. So it is easy to hollow those with "common" tools. I think Munro tools are not that much box hollowing. I have Munro mini and I have to say that I love it. Just had hollowing session yesterday evening and that is wonderful tool. Especially for that green wood. However that is absolutely slower way to hollow if you compare it to gouge and scraper (backhollowing cut or not). You just can't get those big fat shavings with Munro tool. That is the price you have to pay if you want to make controlled cuts deeper inside vessels.

Also there is carbide cutter for Munro mini hollower which is again little bit different than the HSS one. Profile is slightly different.

Also one note about that clogging cutter head. It is true that there often seems to be "stuff" between cutter and "cap". However I have never had to remove the cap and clean the cutter. New shavings will push old ones away. So it really cuts even there is some shavings, you just have to find that sweet spot where the tool is cutting well.

No commercial interest, just a happy customer...

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#8

Petteri, I wasn't knocking the ... *LINK*

Ed Moore

>Munro Mini and the only reason that I removed the shield was because of a question that I was asked. It was an interesting experiment and without a shield the Munro gave me more grooves when hollowing a cup in end-grain than it would with a shield or the Hunter would give. For smoothness I would choose a Hunter over a Munro.

I also agree that for boxes it is quicker to rough them out with a gouge or a scraper. I also drill out with a Forstner bit first. But for a finish cut inside a box I don't think that we will beat a Hunter tool. I have included a link to Hunter Tools below in case you have not checked one out. I think that because the cutter of the Hunter is shallower than a Munro HSS cutter you don't need a shield on the Hunter and the cut is easier to control. I also think that the tip of the shank where the Hunter cutter is attached is carefully shaped and that it is "just right".

Because of the shield I also found that the Munro was very sensitive to having the angle of the tool handle just right for the cut. There seemed to be much more freedom with the Hunter.

Ed


Hunter Tools

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#9

Re: Petteri, I wasn't knocking the ... *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Don't mean to hijack the thread. Has anyone compared these two with the Eliminator? Both Hunter and Eliminator look identical (no cap) except the design on shaft. From the look, it seems the design on the shaft of Eliminator is better. It is made from a bigger rod and tapers down. I think that design would allowed to reach deeper without chattering and small enough to reach into tight place.

Gordon


img

Eliminator

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#10

The Eliminator cutter looks ...

Ed Moore

>just like the Hunter cutters. Certainly a heavier shaft that would handle vibration better would be nice. The Eliminator is more expensive than the Hunter.

My question is: Can we buy the cutters directly from MSC, Enco, or a similar supply house and cut our cost?

Ed

Re: Hunter #3 tool vs Munro Mini

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: The Eliminator cutter looks ...

Lyle Jamieson

>My understanding is these are newly engineered carbide tool cutters that do not use the same technology as the old carbide in the metal lathe tooling marketplace. The new carbide can hold a much sharper edge. Its called nanograin technology.

Lyle Jamieson