Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

Posts

Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#1

Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

Here is an interesting article on some recent scientific testing of Box Elder and what causes the red stain coloring. Enjoy!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP, EWWFS

The Woodlands, Texas


Red Stain in Box Elder

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#2

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

I'm about as far from botany and biological science as one can get while still alive, but maple staining was described to me as the result of the fungal agent carried by the Asian Ambrosia Beetle. The process being that the mature insects bore into the trunk, often clear to the pith, where they hollow out egg-laying galleries. They carry a fungus colony with them which is deposited on the walls of the tunnels and then grows on the water and sugars present in the live wood. When the eggs hatch, the larve eat their way back along the tunnels living on the fungus until they reach the entrance hole, and then leave the tree as adults. The staining, I was told, was partly the pigment produced by the fungus and partly by the tree. This is why each stain area will have the characteristic Ambrosia bore holes uncluded. I was also told that this staining is a fairly new condition which appeared only after the Asian bugs were "imported" in the 20's.

I'd appreciate any needed corrections to my information. The link you gave seems to sum up with a "BSOM, need more research", but doesn't even mention the Ambrosia's role.

TIA

mm

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#3

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder

russ Fairfield

>I am always on shakey ground when I argue with a tree and bug expert, but I think we are talking about two different things when we talk about the red coloring in Box Elder.

I have always found there to be two types of red coloring in Box Elder, and they look and behave quite differently. One type is the color up the center of the tree that looks like Ambrosia, except that it is red; and caused by the same bugs and fungal growth as Ambrosia. The other is a localized red that is caused by stresses on the tree, and is often accompanied by stress induced grain patterns like stripes, ripple, or quilting; and it is often found in the crotch growth.

The Ambrosia type coloring is a darker red that turns to brown as it ages. The stress induced red is a much brighter red that usually starts to disappear with age. The Ambrosia type red is found east of the Continental Divide, while the stress induced coloring is common along the streams west of the Great Divide.

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#4

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder

Carole Valentine

>I agree, Russ. I have found no ambrosia-type artifacts in this box elder I am turning. However, if the red stain is a host response to stress or injury then I would think any type of injury, including that produced by beetles, would trigger the stain response. From what I could glean from that article before my eyes glazed over, it looks like they still don't know for sure.

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#5

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I'm with you on the eye-glazing thing Carole. The thing that struck me was that these guys wounded and killed 100 mature box elders just to decide that they still didn't know for sure what causes the color.

I thought people became botanists because they cared about plants. What price science?

Gary

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder *LINK*

#6

Re: Etiology of Red Stain in Boxelder

Steve Russell

>Hello,

That's what I've always heard as well, but I have never seen and scientific evidence that is persuasive one way or the other. I've only recently become interested in some of these subjects... Something to do in the wee hours when everyone else is sleeping! :-) I'll let you know if I can find out anything definitive, or any scientific testing that sheds a little more light on this subject. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP. EWWFS

The Woodlands, Texas