Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Boxelder color question

Posts

Boxelder color question

#1

Boxelder color question

Joe Pack

>I love the appearance of boxelder, and can get it in my area, but the gorgeous red color I see in items posted here and elsewhere is all but non-existant, at least on the surface of what I have seen. Is it likely that the color is deeper than the surface...there, but not readily apparent without cutting deeper? Is the reddish character all that difficult to find?

Re: Boxelder color question

#2

Re: Boxelder color question

Carole Valentine

>Joe, some has red and some doesn't. Seems to me that the female tree is more prone to red (maybe the bugs or fungus or whatever like girls better!) You won't know until you cut through the tree though. The red most often radiates out like a poinsettia from the heart. Oh, and the red will eventually turn brownish upon long exposure to light.

Re: Boxelder color question

#3

Re: Boxelder color question

john lucas

>Carole answered well. If you have already cut logs laying out it will be hard to see the "red" because it fades to brown under direct sun very quickly. Some box elder trees have very little red, usually around the heart, some have none and occasionally you get lucky and find one like Carole did.

My good friend who carves a lot of box elder says that trees that in a rougher environment, such as fence row, or power line area, have more red. That may be a wives tale sort of thing but he sure finds some good wood.

Re: Boxelder color question

#4

Re: Boxelder color Hint

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Joe,

You can get a good indication of interior color by carefully examining the bark. If you find Ambrosia Beetle bore holes (about 1/16") or fras tubes, you'll have color; more holes, more color. See my posted photo below.

Box Elder reacts to the Ambrosia Beetle's fungus by producing the red stain rather than the browns and greyish tones produced by other maple trees. Unfortunately, it's very susceptible to UV light, and as stated, will go brown sooner or later regardless of what you do.

mm

Re: Boxelder color question

#5

Re: Boxelder color question

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Joe,

Like everybody else said, sometimes you find the red and sometimes you don't.

I just cut down two box elders that were damaged in the fire next to the store several weeks ago. The first had no color whatsoever. The first chips that flew from the second tree had some red streaks and my blood started pumping! Unfortunately, the tree just has a few streaks right on the outside edge and a little in the heart. Not enough to make pretty turning wood. 8^{

Gary

Re: Boxelder color question

#6

Re: Boxelder color question

Bill Neddow

>John is right about the rough environment producing red in the Box Elder. The red is a fungus that gets into trees under stress. Generally, the more stress, the more red. It is sometimes hard to determine how much stress a tree has been under. Sometimes, you will find wonderful streaks of red in a tree that seems to be in ideal conditions. But it probably was suffering from lack of water -- or maybe somebody built a house and cut it off from the sunlight.

The red is the color of the fungus. And, eventually light (especially bright sunlight) will fade it to brown. You can slow it down with finishes with lots of UV inhibitors in them -- but, you can't stop it.

Re: Boxelder color question

#7

Re: Boxelder color question

Ed in Sptbg.

>Sometime in the past, I read somewhere that color change or fade in woods like box elder, padauk, redheart, and others, could be slowed or prevented with an initial coat of ArmorAll before finishing. Any truth to this, or just another entry for Snopes.com? Have any of you tried it?

Re: Boxelder color question

#8

Re: Boxelder color question

john lucas

>Ed We did tests of armorall and several other UV inhibitor type things on photographic posters that we make. None of them worked well enough to even consider using. I haven't tried it on wood. I've used a spray spar varnish on some segemented work that had purple heart and Osage Orange. I can't really say whether it works or not. The piece is at a friends house and it has faded some but it's indoors and is about 10 or 12 years old.

Re: Boxelder color question

#9

keeping the box elder color

john lucas

>When I took a class under Binh Pho he uses a lot of box elder. He often bleaches the wood. The white wood bleaches almost white with multiple applications but the bleach doesn't affect the red very much. He then airbrushes the red with metalic dyes. The metalic dyes don't fade and he airbrushes the same color directly over the red in the wood so in affect he hasn't changed a thing, just made it more permanent.

Re: Boxelder color question

#10

Re: Boxelder color question

Lan Brady

>Jack,

Although no red color, don't overlook the other benefits of Box Elder. This wood cuts well. It carves well, and it accepts dye easily.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: Boxelder color question

#11

Re: Boxelder color question

russ Fairfield

>A tree expert will probably tell me I am wrong, but I have always found there to be two types of red coloring in Box Elder, and they look quite different. There is the color up the center of the tree that looks like Ambrosia, except that it is red; and caused by the same bugs and fungal growth as Ambrosia. The other is a localized red that is caused by stresses on the tree, and is often accompanied by stress induced grain patterns like stripes, ripple, or quilting; and it is often found in the crotch growth. I have never found the beetles that cause Ambrosia in North Idaho. The red I find is all from stresses of the growing tree.

The Ambrosia type coloring is a darker red that turns to brown as it ages. The stress induced red is a much brighter red that usually starts to disappear with age.

We can preserve the red from growth stresses, or add red where there is none, with dyes, chalk, or other colorants. I have used the red powdered carpenters chalk for both purposes. My preferrence is to add the red where there is no natural color, and for this I use an alcohol soluble dye mixed into shellac. I apply the thinned shellac with an air brush so the edges can be feathered for a natural appearance.

Either way, don't use too much red. Think of the red blush as being like that on a peach, and try to duplicate a similar blush on the wood. The Box Elder will age into a darker yellow color and the red blush adds a nice accent.

Re: Boxelder color question

#12

Did Carole says girls have bugs and fungus

C.W.Stivison

>Just checking

CW

Re: Boxelder color question

#13

Thanks

Joe Pack

>Wow...an education. I appreciate the information.

Re: Boxelder color question

#14

LOL!!!!!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>