Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Posts

I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#1

I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Carole Valentine

>Why is a "perfect" egg shape so darn hard to achieve - even when I have the real thing right in front of me? Yeah, the box looks like an egg, but I can't seem to get it "just right." It's driving me nuts. I suppose not all eggs are the same shape. I can't tell because I only had one in the fridge. :)

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#2

Re: You suppose right...

Allen Neighbors

>All eggs are not the same. Some are a little rounder, some have a little more point-some a little less. Some are larger, some smaller.

If you got it close... you did it!

I made one out of Bois d'Arc, standing at the back of my truck in Colorado, Thursday, after getting an egg from the fridge to use as a model. A lady bought it Friday morning.

Close works, in hand grenades, AND, in eggs! :)

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#3

Re: You suppose right...

Carole Valentine

>Good! That makes me feel better! Was you egg hollow (a box) or solid? What kind of price do you put on them?

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#4

where in CO R U??

The MountainMan

>The MountainMan in Buenavista... Nice and cool here at 8k feet!!!

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Mike Stafford

>Turning a perfect egg form is a most difficult task. Turning a box in the perfect egg form is even more difficult. What makes it hard for me is that you turn boxes from the inside out most of the time, so you have to visualize what the inside of egg you want to turn looks like. And I am not talking about the white and yolk....

Larry Marley has a video where he turns an egg shaped box and when he opens it into a fry pan he fries the egg.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#6

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Dick Coers

>Carole,

You must become one with the egg. Be the chicken, feel the push, feel the relief..........

Only then will the form be correct. LOL, LOL

Couldn't help myself. The last time I tried turning eggs I looked at the natural form in the refrigerator. The ends definitely had the blunt end and the pointed end. I know they are soft when delivered by the hen, making the push and release that forms those two different radii. Maybe I have gone too far with this, maybe I'm way too bored here at work, maybe.............

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#7

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Stuart Johnson

>I saw that video on youtube but for some reason it was removed.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#8

Try my technique

Troy German

>Turn a sphere. Realize it looks more like an egg. Tell people you tried to turn an egg.

Enjoy the struggle,

Troy

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#9

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

RonZ

>We get organic farm fresh real eggs here and you will see mother nature is working with you, they come in all shapes and sizes.

I make an egg box usually with a built in stand and it is used for spices.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#10

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Peter Hyde

>I saw an egg that Leo Van Der Loo turned. It was no more than 1/16" thick and was a "pop" fit when you pulled the 2 halves apart. Incredible!

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#11

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Bill Neddow

>Like you, first time I turned an egg, I developed a lot more respect for a hen than I used to. Thank heavens, I don't have to lay them!

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#12

Where is Leo?

C.W.Stivison

>

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#13

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Lan Brady

>Carole,

Talk to the wood.

It don't know, it's suppose to be an egg!

LOL, Lan

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#14

Mike Stafford

Wood talks and something walks....

Mike Stafford

>Whoa Lan, I thought the wood did the talking. When I talk to the wood it almost never listens.....

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#15

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>As others have already suggested, the "perfect" egg shape and the shape of real eggs aren't the same. It seems no one ever properly educated the chickens and other birds on how to do their job. Real eggs have a wide variation in shape. Some are nearly oval, some are rather pointed, and I've never found a carton with two identical eggs in it.

My opinion: if a non-turner recognizes it as an egg, then the shape is correct.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#16

Re: You suppose right...

Allen Neighbors

>Nope, not a box... solid Bois d'Arc egg... and I got 5 bucks for it. I'd like to try an egg-shaped box... but one the 'size' of an actual egg would be awful hard for a klutz like me. :)

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#17

Re: where in CO R U??

Allen Neighbors

>I was in Fun Valley, just north of Wolf Creek Pass on US160. I was just there for a week... I live in NW Texas. It was 107 degrees when I crossed the Oklahoma Panhandle, coming back home.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#18

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

RonZ

>Why? Hens don't turn eggs, turners do.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#19

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Leppikallio

>Perhaps you should try those famous eggs Donald discovered? ;-))


img

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#20

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

JKJ in East TN

>>...and I've never found a carton with two identical eggs in it.

And that's AFTER they are graded and sorted for uniformity and size! We get about a dozen eggs a day from our little Rhode Island Red flock and the variation is extreme. I've seen some that would never make it to a carton: huge, tiny, long and skinny, nearly spherical, "lumpy"...

Perhaps someone should contact the National Bureau of Standards and ask for a cad drawing of The Standard Egg.

JKJ

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#21

Re: Where is Leo?

Peter Hyde

>C.W.

Leo was at a BBQ with a few other turners and wood butchers a couple of weeks ago. Pictures are here http://www.canadianwoodworking.com/forum/showthread.php?t=17750

He had a lot of his turnings with him including the egg.

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

#22

Re: I just can't compete with Mother Nature!

Barry Irby

>Everyone KNOWS ---- EXACTLY-----what an egg looks like. That's why you cannot get it exactly right. And yet, none are the same in nature. Wonderful isn't it?

We had a demo at our turning club on turning eggs. The demonstrator spent forever discussing the perfect egg shape and how he had derived it. He had templates and gauges and jamb chucks. Took an hour to walk us through the first one. Changed the jamb chucks for each end of the egg. Was pleased that when he was not talking he could do one in less than a half hour including sanding. We have a member that is one of the best people I have ever seen with a skew. After the crowd dispersed, he walked up and asked if he could show the demonstrator how he did it. He chucked a blank and said, I make it a cylinder like this, I round the fat end like this, I cut a groove in like this and then round the small end like this and catch it with my other hand. (All in less time than it took you to read this.) He said, I turn an egg a minute. His egg did not need any sanding. Not sure I have ever seen anyone more stunned.