Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

Posts

live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#1

live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>I am about to order a live center from Grizzly, along with a drill chuck arbor.

My Jet mini lathe has MT2, is that right? I have a new drill chuck that says JT #33 on it. So I will be getting G1435. ($9)

My question has to do with the live center. There are a lot to choose from. Aside from double the price (in the interest of my lint filled, but otherwise empty wallet), any reason the $24 G5686 is twice as good as the $12 H3408?

Do I need a spur drive? Grizzly has H3406, a 4 spur drive for $6.

Turns out I have 2 chucks! But I have no alder or poplar to make waste blocks. The local lumber yard doesn't carry anything but construction lumber. Next Wednesday I am going to Norfolk, NE, a bigger community than Bassett. Hopefully I can find something there. Or can I make construction lumber 2x stuff work?

I just 'won' an auction for a little 9" Delta band saw on eBay. I needed 'something' to cut wood. It certainly won't replace my Powermatic at home but then the Powermatic didn't fit in the car when I came here. Here is another rationalization. The lathe can swing 9" so the band saw should be a match! Like I said, better than nothing.

Thanks for your help. Things are slowly coming together.


Grizzly live centers

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#2

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Gordon Seto

>Carol,

Jet mini is MT-2.

Unless the two live centers that you are comparing has interchangeable centers, the 60� point may not be suitable for wood turning. You may be better off with a live center that is designed for wood. Usually it has a ring to prevent the point from penetrating too deep to split the wood.

Spur drive? It depends. Some pro turners like Alan Lacer and Mark Sfirri recommend using a safe drive. When you have a catch, it just spins. Mark can turn those crocked baseball bat with it.

Yes, you can use scrap 2x construction material as waste block. Avoid plywood; you never know when the glue joint fails.

Gordon

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#3

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

eaglesc

>Lowes sells 1x aspen here in S.C. and also poplar.'Aouldn't that work for a waste block?

(like I said I only turn pens)

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#4

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

john lucas

>I love my spur drive, I have 4. If you use 2x4's which I have buy quarter sawn ones. The grain on these runs from the wide flats sides to wide flat side. The don't split as easy. You may find that they have the heart in them but the still work well.

I would agree, the 60 degree points aren't that useful. I like what is called a cup center. It has a short point with a ring around it. I'm a big fan of the Nova live center but they run around $80.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#5

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>H3404 is a cupped center for wood. But what is a safe drive? And where do you get one?

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#6

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carole Valentine

>Did you not get a live center with your Jet mini? They are supposed to come with one. Mine came with a live cup center like what John mentions. Biggest problem I have found with cheap centers (both live and drive) is the you can get one that does not have the taper machined precisely enough. This either allows it to slip (annoying) or in the worst case it ends up scoring the inside of the spindle or or the tail stock. I have always preferred a 2 spur drive over a 4, but I have used it for so long now that I don't remember the reason. :) I have a couple of Steb centers but don't particularly like them. I feel like I have to crank my TS down too tight to keep them from slipping at the slightest pressure. I used them mostly when I was learning to use a skew.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#7

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

Carole Valentine

>Not exactly for "linty" pockets. :))


Steb Centers

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#8

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>No kidding! :)

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#9

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carol, the Jet mini lathe comes equipped with a live center, a spur drive and a faceplate. And yes it's #2 MT. You probably won't find alder where you are but poplar makes good glue blocks. In fact, most any soft wood can be used. Just be sure it's dry and not warped.

Glad to see you're getting back to turning.

Wally

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#10

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>The safe drive is spring loaded from Oneway.

You can also use a non-revolving dead center.

I saw a demonstration from Mark Sfirri on off-center baseball bat at Louisville Symposium. He said he has not used spur centers for over a decade. If he can drive those crocked baseball bats with safe center without slipping; it should have no problem for regular turnings.

Gordon


Safe Drive

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#11

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ditto what Wally said Carol. You should already have the spur drive and live center provided by JET. I think you bought your mini from eBay and perhaps it didn't come with those?

What type of chucks do you have? You may not need to mess with glue blocks? Don't let Wally hear me say that though...Shhh....

Jen :)

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#12

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>I got the lathe off of eBay. 2 faceplates but no centers. Dead or alive! :)

I have a Talon and a Nova chuck. Funny the stuff you pick up over the years. :)

I'll look for some poplar in Norfolk next week. 5/4 or 6/4? Failing that, I'll look for construction stuff. The local yard doesn't allow you to pick lumber. They look at me like I am a dumb broad. And, yeah, I hate that, but I am the only local pastor in town, and that does temper my response. :) I'll just have to start producing something!!! Let my work speak for itself to let people know I know what I am doing.

When I ask for QS lumber, they say they don't carry that!

I love small towns, but they do seem to be stuck in the last century in some regard. :) So I get to drive 3-1/2 hours to get to a town of 3,000!

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#13

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Craig Daymon

>Oneway makes the Safety Center, but Penn State Industries sells a knock-off for much less. They also carry steb center knock-offs for good prices. Here's a link to their 1" Safety Center. They also have a 5/8".

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/lcsafe2.html

Here's a link to their drive Steb Center knock-offs (and their other drive centers).

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/headstock-drive-centers.html

And here's the live ones.

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/live-tailstock-centers.html

I don't think they're the quality of the Oneway or Sorby products, but I've been happy with them.

-Craig

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#14

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carol, the Woodcraft catalog shows a live cup center for $14.95. Should be okay. Unless you plan to do spindle turning you can get along without a spur center. If you do want one they run around $25. maybe a little less at Grizzly.

Wally

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#15

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Thanks, Craig. I kinda like that combo set.....

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#16

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>long term thinking, Wally, would be to try finials....

That's spindle, isn't it, sort of... :)

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#17

Make your own safe drive.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Get a cheap dead center, take a rattail file and put notches in four places around sharp edge. Works as well as any store bought expensive one.

Ray

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#18

Richard Allen

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Richard Allen

>Is the G5686 worth twice as much as the H3408. The bearings in the G5686 are at least twice as good for larger loads as the bearing on the H3408.

The Jet mini isn't likely to test the difference in bearing quality between the two live centers.

A cup live center is usually a better choice for woodturning. You can put a steel washer over the end of a 60 degree cone live center to limit the splitting potential of the 60 degree live cone center.

One of the nice things about the stock jet live center is that the center point can be removed. I find this option to help when making long thin spindles.

The taper length of the live center is a concern. The Jet mini tailstock features a self ejecting system. If the length of the MT on the live center is to short the self ejecting feature doesn't work. If the MT goes in to far the center doesn't seat properly. Mind you most live centers have the desired MT length. I have had this problem in the past.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#19

Now Carol do you really know

Dustmaker Mike

>what you are talking about? I think I can speak for all us guys and say are you really really sure?

I love to walk into a store and watch guys walk right by the young lady working there and ask the guy what to do and where do I find this or that. Then the guy turns to the young lady and asks her. Your work will speak for itself as it always has then they will eat their looks and you will have the last laugh.

Enjoy the small town life I can't wait for the small town life.

Mike heading out again for Europe and South Afarica and if I am lucky I will miss the Middle East.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#20

Re: Any turner that has a chuck....

Jamie Donaldson

>... "don't need no stinkin' glue blocks" by roughing out between centers and forming a tenon on the tailstock end to reverse in the chuck jaws.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#21

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Yep, that's spindle turning....I find that a chuck with small jaws works better for finials and I don't use a tailstock. For turning small things between centers a small spur center works best. 1/2 or 3/8 inch.

Wally

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#22

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s

Gordon Seto

>Carol,

Try construction sites. They have plenty of cut-offs.

Use the thicker stuff if possible. Those waste blocks can be used multiple times. You can true up the surface of the old waste block and use it again and again. until it becomes so thin, you run the risk of hitting the tip of the screws.

Gordon

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#23

Re: Now Carol do you really know

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Keep your head down, Mike, and stay safe.

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#24

Re: Any turner that has a chuck....

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>LOL!

It's the 'turning between centers' that has me looking for centers, Jamie!

Re: live centers & a few other ?'s *LINK*

#25

Re: Make your own safe drive.

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>This one would be inserted into the headstock, right, Ray? Sounds interesting, not because it could be inexpensive, but because it could be small. I gotta get Cindy's finial DVD and Lacer's skew DVD.