Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

band saw

Posts

band saw

#1

band saw

hutchison

>thinking of buying anew band saw.like steel city 18". saw most major brands,new company what do you think thanks hutch

Re: band saw

#2

band saw recommendation *LINK*

Ed Moore

>One of the best deals for bandsaws is found at LeNeave in Charlotte, NC. I have put the link for the LeNeave (Northstate) bandsaws below.

I recommend the 21" and 3 HP, I think it is #5300.

Call them and ask for the Ed Moore special - just for fun. Everyone who has purchased this saw that I referred to them has been very pleased. A friend with a Laguna likes this saw better than his.

Ed


LeNeave19", 21" bandsaws

Re: band saw

#3

Re: Ed- those saws have some ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... very nice looking features and look very much like my Mini Max S45, but do you know what does the 19" retails for?

Re: band saw

#4

Re: band saw recommendation

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>These saws look identical to the Grizzly and Harbor Freight saws. I have the Grizzly and like it a lot. The 17inch is $799 in Harbor Freight and not much more in Grizzly.

Re: band saw

#5

Re: band saw

Bill Neddow

>I had a very hard look at a Steel City band saw (18") a few months ago and was very impressed. Their booth was just next to the Laguna booth -- and Laguna did not come out well in the comparison. Have a friend with a Laguna and it is constantly breaking. Their service reps have been less than helpful.

Re: band saw

#6

Re: band saw

robo hippy

>I guess it all depends on how high you want to cut. If you are just cutting circles, then a smaller saw will work. If you are cutting logs into bowl blanks, then you need something bigger, and more horse power. 14 inch saws with riser blocks, and a 1hp motor work, but aren't designed for heavy duty cutting of stuff 12 inches high. I have always been wary of the Grizzly products. I have known too many that need to be tinkered with in order to get them to work right. I have a Laguna 16HD which cuts 16 inches high. The only problem that I have had with it in three years, was some minor damage because it was shipped on a pallet rather than in a crate. It is the second best Christmas present I ever got myself (next to the PM). The biggest difference between the Laguna and the Minimax is the Minimax is a bit heavier. Laguna has had customer relation problems, but have been trying to make up for it.

robo hippy

Re: band saw

#7

Re: band saw recommendation

Ed Moore

>I paid a little less than $1100 for the 21" saw with two blades and the heavy-duty mobile base in April of 2004. With steel prices going up, I would ASSUME that this saw would be in the $1300 - $1400 range now. I don't recall the price for the 19". I wanted a 17", but they sold out like hotcakes at the woodworking show in Charlotte, NC, in January(?) of 2004. They gave me a good deal on the 21" as a result.

I have assembled Grizzly bandsaws for others and I assure you that the quality of the LeNeave Northstate saw is MUCH better than Grizzly or Harbor Freight saws. Like I wrote earlier, a friend with the Laguna prefers the saw I have. He goes first class and turns on a Oneway 2436 with an outboard set-up. He knows machinery and would not consider a Grizzly or HF saw.

LeNeave is a family run business with an impeccable reputation. They don't sell junk.

Ed

Re: band saw

#8

Re: band saw

RonZ

>I have the 21" one like Ed Moore posted. Its a great tool. It's 3hp one phase and EU approved which gives you safety features. I import them direct from Taiwan to Israel so the name is the manufacturer there. While Grizzly might look the same beware. When I import from the east I can get China or Taiwan and Taiwan is about double the price but its worth it. The Jet lathes I get do circles around the Chinese copy. Heck, they might even come from the same factory but they definitly know how and where to cut back. Remember, you can get the cheapest garbage notebook computer and the top of the line and they come from the same factory. Its certainly holds true for machinery.

Re: band saw

#9

Re: band saw

RonZ

>I'm sorry, this is the same name, OAV.

Re: band saw

#10

Re: band saw

Rick Pixley

>Personally I'd stay away from both Laguna and Mini max..I've got a Laguna and the buying experience was horrific at best...A lot of mis imformation and I believe outright lying took place..The owner seems to be a real peach too..A friend of mine bought a mini max for an understood price and when he received his bill it was for a substantially greater amount..He had them pick it up and ended up with a Rincoh (sp) from Woodcraft..Looks to be quite a bargain and appears to operate on a par with my Laguna..

Re: band saw

#11

Re: Don't condemn MiniMax ..

Jamie Donaldson

>.. based on a random story- I am very well pleased with both my S45 and the dealer I purchased it from. I've had it for 2 yrs. and the salesman even called me recently to say hello since he's also a turner. There are very few products made today that everyone can say was trouble free!

Re: band saw

#12

I won't condemn MiniMax ...

Ed Moore

>but LeNeave had a Minimax in their showroom next to their Northstate bandsaw and they couldn't sell the Minimax.

Ed