Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Burl, or knot? (pic)

Posts

Burl, or knot? (pic)

#1

Burl, or knot? (pic)

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

A little while ago I posted pictures of a very ugly cherry tree stump that my father-in-law told me about. It was in the yard of his next door neighbor, and the tree had come down for the most part. All that was left was this very ugly stump. So, I called my good friend Dominic Greco, and between us, we got the thing carved up and into our trucks. Below is the first fruits of my share of the wood. I was thinking this might have been a burl. I am not sure, but at this point I really don't care! This is the most highly figured cherry I have ever seen.


Overall size is 7 1/2" high and 8" in diameter, with a wall thickness of 1/4". It was soaking wet when I turned it, and kinked a little as well as rippling a lot as it dried, but I am happy with it. It is finished with Bush Oil and buffed on a Beall system.

Thanks for taking a look.

Bill

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#2

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Sean Troy

>That's the most spectacular I've ever seen. the turning does it justice.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#3

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Troy German

>The form and the wood look terrific together.

Great job,

Troy

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#4

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Bill Neddow

>Wow. That is incredible. I have never seen figure in Cherry like that before. Nice turning, too.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#5

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Carole Valentine

>I wouldn't care either, Bill. Beautiful piece of cherry.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#6

Andy DiPietro

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Andy DiPietro

>Hi Bill,

Stunning piece of cherry and a very nice form. How did you dry this piece? DNA? Can you bring this piece with you for your September demo at DelVal?

Thanks

Andy D.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#7

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

George Van

>Stunning figure, great form to display it with Bill. What grit did you sand to while it was green? I am thinking (maybe mistakenly) that you would loose the wrinkle if you sanded after it dried and distorted a little.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#8

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

john pickett

>BEAUTFUL! I love the spiral effect of the figure.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#9

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

john pickett

>I can't get over the swirl. It really makes it come alive.


img

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#10

Re: Looks like a first class burl....

Jamie Donaldson

>... to me, Bill. The texture added by the wrinkling figure as it dries costs extra- beautiful piece!

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#11

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Gerry Meekins

>Beautiful figure and a real nice form Bill. Definitely one of a kind. (If it's not a Burl maybe it's Burl-esque..)

Gerry

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#12

Ugly is Beautiful! Awesome, Bill.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#13

Knot is my guess....

Ed Moore

>because cherry burls that I have seen have patches of little brown eyes, and none are noticeable in the picture.

In any case, the figure is beautiful and you have revealed it very well.

Have a great trip to Cape Cod. When is the Robust expected?

Ed

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#14

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Stunning Turning Bill,

Glad that one was not put through a saw mill or dumped in a creek...

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#15

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses everyone!

Andy, I will be glad to bring it with me, unless someone comes along with a handful of moolah in exchange for it. But there is more where this piece came from. In fact, if you know where Dominic lives...

George, I sanded it with 120 grit, and then let it dry before continuing. I did lose a little bit of the ripple, so I think with the next piece I am going to tough it out and go through as many sanding disks as I need to just to get it done before it ripples.

Gerry, burl-esque, eh? I love it! I am going to have to steal that one and use it.

Ed, I am looking at the end of October for the Robust.

Jim, I am glad none of those things happened. ;-)

Bill

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#16

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Stunning!

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#17

Awesome!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Bill,

Now that is spectacular looking! Now I really can't wait to turn some of that burl!

I guess the hand planes I'm refurbing will have to take a back seat.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#18

Re: Awesome!

Barry Elder

>Awesome! That piece deserves its' own museum! Just incredible!

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#19

Amazing figure

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Bill,

That is an amazing piece of wood. And the form is also fantastic.

I once made a Shaker style table out of some really curly Cherry, but it was not even in the same ball park as this.

Great piece!!

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#20

WOW, what figure!!!

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#21

neither

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>The swirling grain of stump wood probably has its own nomenclature; I'd just call it swirling grain. Gorgeous piece Bill. Glad to see you have recovered from, well, you know.

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#22

Bill, this is exactly what I tell collectors...

TDaniel

>The beauty is in the wood. It takes many years to learn enough about wood to just leave it alone and show what it has in it. Once you have a trained eye you can spot fantastic grain patterns and display them in a way that makes a piece a treasure which you have done here. Well done my friend!

TD

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#23

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Jack Riley

>Beautiful Bill! Cherry is my favorite and this piece has more going on than anything I've seen before. What finish have you found that will extend the time before it turns the reddish-brown cherry seeks to become?

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#24

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks again for the responses everyone!

Jack, I actually try to accelerate the speed of natural darkening for cherry, so I give the stuff a sun tan when I can for an hour or so. I suppose if you used an outdoor finish with UV inhibitors it might work for a while, but I have never tried that.

Bill

Re: Burl, or knot? (pic)

#25

ausgezeichnet, mein herr!!!

KurtK in Indy

>I had a piece of cherry I recovered from a hardwood mill that was a crotch and soaking wet. Little did I know it would have a flame figure (and ripple quite a bit...but I like it).

That is really cool, Bubba!!

Kurt