Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Posts

OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

steve antonucci

>As I have been given the "go ahead" to build a shop, I've been out looking at options and cost for a variety of different options.

I know I can get a "large shed" from Lowes (16x24- two story) for 10K built onsite, with my only other cost being the foundation/piers, but it's a rather ugly building, and I'm not sure I want to look at it every day of my life in perpetuity.

Option B is stick built to my specifications. Haven't spent a lot of time thinking about this, but I assume creative control of the look and feel.

Option C is a "barn". I've been looking at 18x24 post and beam barns with lofts that could be decked. Pricing is more than Option A, but not so much more than to exclude it. What is a good "rule of thumb" for pricing a barn? Is it by square footage? Can they be built on a slab? Piers with a wood floor? Looks like about 20K for the structures I've seen (additonal costs for foundation and electrical...)

Guidance, please.

Steven

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#2

Re: A Few Watchouts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Steve,

I looked into building a 24x36 shop and costed it out, with a sweat equity discount, at $25,000 for a slab-on-grade, without a water system (i.e. garden hose and french drain out the back).

But, since you're here in New Jersey . . . .

Watchout # 1: The process for getting a building permit for a second structure, between architect's and lawyer's fees for the application and required approvals and variances, was estimated at between $5 & 10k.

Watchout # 2: When I stopped by the assessor's office (as suggested by the building dept.). The Tax Man got this gleam in his eye and informed me that my property taxes would go up by about $5k PER YEAR, and to please keep his office informed of my progress and completion date so that he could set up the appointment for the revaluation of the entire ranch!

I remain a subterranium woodworker.

mm

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#3

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Troy German

>How about option D: Timber frame construction. It's similar to post and beam but instead of metal fasteners, it uses all wood joinery (e.g. pegged mortis and tennons, shouldered dovetails, and such). It takes longer to biuld, but as a woodworker you could do most of it yourself, save some money on labor, and have an extra measure of pride about it.

Just a thought,

Troy

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#4

Steven Antonucci

I had heard something similar...

steve antonucci

>from the zoning inspector with regard to the "big ugly shed" from Lowes. He mention that I would be an idiot to ever refer to it as anything but a shed (for storage, of course) and that I was absolutely never to mention placing my home office upstairs for the reasons you mention.

He didn't think I'd need a variance, but I haven't dug into the whole process too far yet to tell about costs beyond the building.

Thanks

Steve

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#5

Steven Antonucci

To me, Timber frame=post and beam

steve antonucci

>i.e. structural building vs. stick building... subtle differences, I'm sure, but I'd bet they cost the same...

Thanks

Steve

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#6

Andy DiPietro

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Andy DiPietro

>Hey Buddy

Glad to hear Management approved your new construction project. Save room for wood storage.

Andy D.

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#7

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I figure around $12/sq.ft. around here for a basic pole building. Options can go from there.

Ray

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#8

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Fog Tanner

>Shows the differnce in pricing in the various areas. I had a 32'x50' "pole structure" (even though the "poles" are rectangular) built for less than 20k. That includes a concrete slab. I finished out the inside for around another 1k.

If I park my tractor in it, it is now a "barn" and not a garage and being an ag building, a different tax brake. If I had built a shop on pier and beams and the floor joists had the appearance of "skids", it would have been considered a temporary building and not taxable. Also, some of the taxing authorities here will not place your building on the tax roles until it is finished. I grew up around a garage that had one shingle missing, on the front under the eves. I found later that it was never "finished" due to the one shingle and never on the tax roles. And that was for over fifteen years.

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#9

It Ain't Pretty

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>And don't go by what some putz part-time "inspector" tells you. He'll be long gone when the Tax Assessor drives up and you get hammered for back taxes, fines, etc., yadda, yadda.

If you think the "But Inspector Hairball told me it was Okay" defense is gonna help,

don't.

|;-}

mm

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#10

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Won't work in my township. They'd serve you with a Notice of Deficiency and you'd have 30 days to "correct the defect" or have a removal (of the entire structure) notice nailed to the door and yellow tape wrapped around it as "condemed".

|;-}}

mm

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#11

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Fog Tanner

>Certainly sounds like they are going to get their pound of flesh either way. I just wish I had bought 10 acres instead of 5. I found out that the minimum for an ag exemption is 10 acres here. I could have planted tress on it 20 years ago, had a tree farm for the ag ememption, had turning stock for the habit, the savings in taxes would have paid for the place and I would have someplace for the shavings. And I'm sure there is something that I could have found that the feds would have paid me not to plant. Not to mention, the price of land has gone up four times what is was when we bought the five...

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#12

A Pound?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Somebody's got skinny arms and legs!!!

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#13

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

Bob Fawcett

>Steve,

Metal buildings can be inexpensive depending on your situation. Check them out.

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#14

One Shingle Missing............

Barry Turner

>The "One Shingle Missing" approach is not likely to work with most inspectors. In fact, most inspectors, once they discover that someone is trying to skirt the law using some "creative" angle, lose their sense of humor really quickly.

Having been a health inspector/supervisor for the past 36 years, I know how my folks respond to such creativity. And it ain't pretty.

I prefer, and recommend, an honest, up front approach. Ask straight-forward questions and you'll usually get honest, factual answers.

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#15

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

matt overton

>A number of pole barns have gone up near me here in Bucks County, Pa. for a whole lot less than I could have built them. In fact, a friend that had one built by an Amish man so impressed her that she now represents him and has had him build some for the local Grange. Check out the Amish for pricing, they're cheap and the quality is superb.

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#16

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

JKJ in East TN

>I've seen some inexpensive pole buildings go up with metal siding and concrete floors. One down the hill was completed in a few days. The concrete floor was poured AFTER the building was complete.

JKJ

Re: OT: Pricing a barn building for a shop

#17

Short construction period.

Jack Riley

>Ten years ago I needed to build a new barn/equipment storage/flat work shop. I researched every option available for a 60' X 80' building that was good quality and would still look good in ten years (wife's input)! My farm is in Alabama but I settled on a company out of Minnesota by the name of Morton Buildings. Excellent people to do business with and they make quality buildings. Look them up on the net and you'll see just about any size to fit your needs. My barn is hot in the summer and cold in the winter and for that reason my Oneway is located in the AC! I have no interest in Morton; I'm just a satisfied customer.