Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Trying to get my turning wheels back

Posts

Trying to get my turning wheels back

#1

Trying to get my turning wheels back

Carole Valentine

>I have really done no turning since my Mom passed away in May and decided that it was time to try and get back into it. The hollow form is Kentucky Coffee tree. That wood is very stable - I turned it green to finish and got no detectable warping. It is also very porous - when I was blowing the shavings out while hollowing, water was blowing out of the outside through the pores!


img

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#2

Attempt at a box

Carole Valentine

>A little spalted Maple box. I am not too good at these yet. This my 3rd box. I have the lid fit down, but for some reason, it is difficult for me to get a decent form in a box. Got a little too exuberant with the sandpaper on the finial detail and some of it disappeared, but at least I am turning again! Yippeee!


img

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#3

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

Pete Kekel - Kentucky

>Good start Carole! Hang in there and keep working at it.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#4

Re: Attempt at a box

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole, I think this looks really nice. First of all...I'm thrilled to see you back at the lathe...secondly, it looks like you never took a break! Love the hollow form. It's a beauty.

I too have only turned several boxes and like you said, I struggle with the forms of them. I just did one the other day and was pretty happy with it on the lathe...and then when it came off...I was kind of disappointed in the shape. That's why I need Mike to teach some classes and get into one of them! I'd really love to take a box making class.

Keep em' coming Carole. Your work is never gets old to look at.

Jen

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#5

Re: Attempt at a box

Carole Valentine

>Thanks, Jen. It's good to be back. Maybe we can get Mike to do an "online" class for us - we send him pics of our box as it progresses, while it's still on the lathe, and he critiques and makes suggestions!

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#6

Re: Nothing wrong with your wheels!!

Jamie Donaldson

>BTW, that's about the prettiest piece of KY Coffee tree I've ever seen- it's usually boring grey/brown by the time it dries out.And the box is very nice as well, so keep busy!

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#7

I'm All for that idea, Carole......

Ruth Niles

>Taking pictures of a work in progress and having an online class with suggestions and critique from an instructor is a terrific idea. Like Jen, some forms look good on the lathe and once you part them off, it's more "what was I thinking?" And once they are done and off the lathe, you can't go back and shape the base wider!

I also agree with Jen that your work is super and it most certainly does not look like you've been away from your lathe.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#8

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Hi Carole,

Sure looks like you are back in the swing of it, those are both fine looking pieces!!!

Gil

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#9

Stepping out of lathe lurker mode to say:

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>You go, Girl! It is great to see you getting back to turning. I've missed seeing your distinct and special work. I love this Kentucky Coffee piece. You sure the water spilling out wasn't from the humid weather? :-)

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#10

Re: I'm All for that idea,

john lucas

>Well suffer from the same malady. I guess boxes are just hard. I'll turn one I really like and then the next one will just not work. I think you have to turn the same kind of box over and over. After you turn about 25 or 30 of the same thing you'll probably find a shape you like. Then the figure on the next piece of wood will throw it off.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#11

Are you using training wheels. :)

john lucas

>Those are both great. I really like the Coffee Tree (even though I hate coffee) It's got a great shape.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#12

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Carole,

Sorry to hear about your Mom. I guess I missed it when it happened.

Beautiful work, as usual.

Gary

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#13

That's what keeps us turning, John.......

Ruth Niles

>No two pieces really come out exactly the same. I've often thought that the "artistic" turners are actually "production" turners because they have to do the same thing over and over until they have their "original" or signature piece down pat. Guess that's why I'll never be known for my turnings, I do too great a variety from bowls to coffee scoops, porch balusters to bottle stoppers, kids stools to mushroom toothpick holders.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#14

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

George Van

>Hi Carol, good to see you turning again, as the others have said you can not tell that you took some time off. I have been roughing some hollow forms and I have had them off and on several times and keep searching for the right form for my eye. I find overnight can make a big difference in how the form looks to me. Working on these forms helps me appreciate the turners with a �natural eye� for these things.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#15

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Carole,

Those are very nice pieces. I love the form of the hollowform. Very nicely done.

Like so many of us, I've struggled with the few boxes I've done and I think your's looks wonderful.

Very glad you are turning again, I alway like to see the forms you produce.

Thanks for the pictures,

Mike

Hoping to turn today in Apex, NC

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

Mike Stafford

>That is a pretty little hollow form, Carole. I love the grain orientation in your photo. I don't think you have missed a step with your time off from turning. I hope turning provides as much solace for your soul as it does for mine. I don't know of a time I am much more at peace than when I am contemplating and enjoying a piece of wood.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#17

Ditto that comment

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ruth, I feel the same about your comment regarding a signature style. As much as I'd like to be known better in the turning world for a particular style or design, I just can't seem to stick to anything long enough. I'm not sure if that's a good thing or bad? Anyway, I always go back to the saying, it's not the destination, it's the journey along the way! And if I turn a few off balanced boxes along the way...well I'd say that's not so painful is it?

Meandering down the Turning Path of Life!

Jen :)

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: Attempt at a box

Mike Stafford

>Great looking third box, Carole. My third box was a cylinder. If I might make a suggestion, start with nice simple forms and practice making variations of them. Take a straight sided box and with variations make it shorter and taller and see how the appearance changes where the join lines need to be. Then make rounded/globular forms without undercuts and see how they are affected by join lines. Practice different shapes on the top of the lid. Cutting and shaping the lid was by far the greatest challenge for me because it is held on by jam chucking it on the box body and can be torn loose if things go wrong. (And sometimes they do....) Egg shaped boxes are a real challenge. I don't do too many boxes with finials because I find it hard to get the proportions right and personally I don't want a delicate little finial on a box where it is easily broken. If the lid is a bit snug finials tend to suffer when hands use them for leverage. Depending on how thick you lid is at the point where the finial is it can be very weak because it is end grain. Keep practicing and with you design sense and skills you will be making beautiful boxes I am sure. This box is quite lovely and nothing to be ashamed of. Spalted wood is not my favorite material for box turning. It seems I always have to dress up spalted wood with sandpaper. I prefer the dense hardwoods so that little sanding is needed.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: Attempt at a box

Mike Stafford

>Jennifer, Carole, Ruth, I would be pleased to consult with you in any way that I can to help you learn to turn boxes. I love turning boxes and want as many people to turn them as possible. I would be glad to help you learn in any way that I can. If we can work out a way to do an on-line consultation I would love to participate. Perhaps Steve Russell can give us some pointers on how we might do that once a month in chat.

I have a box turning tutorial in Word and PDF that I give to my students when I teach. It is available on WoW and also Woodturner's Resource. I would love to have John Lucas and others with a good sense of design comments on our efforts. I think it would be great fun.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#20

Re: Welcome back to turning

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I have never turned coffee tree, but if it looks like this, I would surely like to. Your wheels are definitely on tight, even with the time away from the lathe. I like the box also, especially the burned lines. They act as a nice contrast to the spalt lines in the wood.

I also hope your time spent turning helps give you peace.

keith

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: I'm All for that idea,

Mike Stafford

>I think you are right about that John. I don't like to turn the same shape over and over again but I do turn a shape many times when I am trying to develop it. Finally in my mind's eye I will have it the way I want it to be. Then I will try it on another piece of wood and just as you said I will have to make an adjustment because of what the wood wants to be. I don't find it easy to make the wood into something that it is not already. Sure you can turn any piece of wood to any form but that does not mean it is displayed to its best advantage.

I find this particularly true with boxes. As a square stick you have some idea what the side grain is and some idea what the end grain is also. When you round up the blank your opinion of the side grain changes and you see features that you decide should be on the lid or on the body of the box. You will also see grain that will be near where the finished lid will be and ask yourself what will that grain do when it is end grain. (You don't know for sure what the end grain will look like until after you remove the waste from the spigot/tenon.) And you also have to choose a spot to part the lid and the body which will help you minimize the grain mismatch that results from the removal of wood. Even on forms like I am currently working on the grain mismatch is obvious if done poorly. But a beautiful grain match that wraps around a bulbous/spherical body and then travels over a bead and continues up a flared lid to the top is a beautiful thing to me.

That is my challenge as a box turner and something that I suppose will never be perfectly done but nevertheless it is the challenge, or the travel as Jennifer so aptly phrased it that makes it all worthwhile.

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#22

Re: Attempt at a box

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>GO Carole GO!!!!!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#23

Re: Attempt at a box

Mark Paulley

>Jennifer and all others.

I too am very interested in box making but I either get the lid too tight or too loose. I would like to find a good teacher of box making.

Can you and any others recommend a teacher and why you like this particular teacher?

I am in Kentucky and can travel so location of teacher is not too much of a problem.

Thank for your help and suggestions

Mark

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#24

Re: Ditto that comment

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Jen,

"Jen said" "it's not the destination, it's the journey"

Where have I head that before. :)

www.bowlturner.com

Hope you are well,

Dave

Re: Trying to get my turning wheels back

#25

First principles of box-making ...

Ed Moore

>are important for the fitting of the lid. The idea of rough-turning the box and allowing it to move/dry is an excellent approach.

The first principle of box-making is: Sequence matters. The order in which you do things is extremely important.

Following that, make the female part of the box first. It is much easier to adjust the male portion of the lid/bottom for final fit.

1. If the lid fits over a tenon on the bottom, then complete the lid first and adjust the tenon on the bottom.

2. If the lid is to be inserted into a recess on the bottom, then complete the bottom first and then make the lid. Mike's box is an example of this case.

A picture of the latter case is included for your viewing pleasure. The box is made from zebrawood.

Ed


img