Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Jet vs General Head to Head

Posts

Jet vs General Head to Head

#1

Jet vs General Head to Head

dave caudill

>I know these questions come up a lot and are bothersome to some but I have to ask it here because its the best place for objective opinions. I'm looking at upgrading my lathe. I have an old Delta 1965 home or hobby model lathe and need more. I'm looking at the Jet 1642 and the General 25-650. They look pretty compareable. The jet a 2hp motor the General a 1.5. And the outboard turning options are different the General swivels the Jet moves down to the end where the tailstock sits.

Anyone here have any experioence they'd like to share both good and bad for these two or one or other of these lathes? And please those of you with the Powermatic 3520 please don't say "for another $800 you could get......". I know, I know but I'm at my spending limit and these are my choices. Please don't abuse me any more than I have already abused myself.

Anyways if anyone would like to venture an opinion or if they think they both stink by all means please join in. And any other options you think I should try are also wlecome.

Thanks all.

Dave

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#2

JL

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

JL

>I have a Jet 1642. I've turned on a older General of that model when I took a class. The General had a larger tool rest. The spindle height seemed to be a bit higher - but that could be my memory acting up.

I turn spindles mostly and I really couldn't see much difference in how they handled in that regards. My Jet doesn't have a swivel head. But you can always slide it to the end and turn outboard.

One big difference is the 3 phase motor on the General. If you don't have 3 phase coming into your shop, you'll have to get a converter (more bucks).

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#3

Re: JL- the voltage input for this new....

Jamie Donaldson

>....General is 110v, and it looks like it could have been made in the same factory as the Jets. I haven't actually turned on one yet, but it is probably harder to find a dealer than for Jet products should you need service. These 2 machines are very similar, so buy the 1 you find available with the least complications.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#4

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

Sean Troy

>You won't regret getting the 1642. It's a great lathe for the money and will give you years of enjoyment. It's worth searching for the best price as most vendors give their best price at different times. Look for free shipping but rember you will have to pay for liftgate service if you need it.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#5

JL

Re: OK - as I said..

JL

>I turned on one of their old ones.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

Ric Taylor

>Dave,

I have the Jet 1642 and I love it. I bought mine after reading Dominic's thorough review that you can find posted in the Articles & Reviews section of this website.

Also, the Jet 1642 comes in a 110v model and a 220v model. Mine is 110v.

Ric

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#7

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I have had the Jet 1642 1 1/2 HP VS. for 2 1/2 years. I looked at the 2HP model but decided to go with the 1.5 HP model because it can be run on any 110 volt 20 amp circut. The 1.5 and the 2HP 220v. models are not convertable, they use different controlers and motors. I have turned a 22" by 10" bowl off the end and had more power than I needed. Jet has the 1642 1.5 HP VS on sale at amazon.com for about $1,300.00 as well as other online dealers some with free freight.

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#8

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

JKJ in East TN

>I don't know about the General, but a number of people here use the 1642, including myself. It is a wonderful machine for my use, a good value for the money. It is plenty solid for my use even without extra weight, has plenty of power, and the variable speed is wonderful. I use the 110v version.

I also don't have personal experience with lathes having swiveling heads, but I read once that such a head can somtimes have problems keeping good alignment with the tailstock.

JKJ

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#9

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

Mike Hamilton

>If you're lucky enough to have both a Woodcraft and Rockler nearby you can sometimes do even better. The local Rockler had a 15% off power tools sale recently timed to take the wind out of Woodcraft's anniversary 10% off everything sale. I got my 110v 1642 for under $1200 (for pickup at their store).

Regards,

Mike Hamilton

Plainfield, IN

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#10

Hi Dave

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Dave,

As Ric said, I wrote a review of the 1 1/2 HP (110V) Jet JWL-1642EVS back when I first purchased mine in 2002/2003. Since that time that lathe has handled EVERYTHING I've thrown at it. I've turned bottle stoppers and pens all the way up to large salad bowls and hollow forms.

Pros:


  • One of the features I like the most are the sturdy cast iron bed and legs. All that cast iron does a lot to reduce vibration.

  • The headstock is well built and locks down very easily. Having the ability to slide the whole thing to the end of the bed is super convenient when you need to work on that occasional hollow form

  • I REALLY love the electronic speed readout. It's always nice to know how fast you're spinning!

  • The 1 1/2 HP motor gives this baby more than enough power to turn some pretty hefty pieces of wood. However, if you over load it with a BIG piece of wood, it can be stalled. I got around that by learning to use sharp tools, and take little bites. :>)



Cons:


  • I wish that the tail stock was a bit better made. It tends to gum up and get hard to move. This necessitates frequent maintenance and application of dry lubricant. Call me picky but the I feel that the tailstock's handwheel is small and a bit chincy. I wish Jet had designed the entire thing more like the PM 3520's tailstock

  • I would have like to have seen a better Spindle Indexing mechanism. The one included leaves a lot to be desired. However, a shop built one is an easy add on

  • IMHO the included "guard" and "tool basket" are laughable at best. They do nothing but get in the way. These two items were quickly removed shortly after I moved the lathe into my shop. I wish that Jet had used the metal from these two useless pieces of equipment to add a nice work light or beef up the tail stock.



If you do eventually pick this lathe as the one you want, I would recommend adding trestle legs and a ballast box. I wrote an article on this for WC and feel this was the best accessory I could have added to my lathe.

I hope this helps.

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#11

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

Ruth Niles

>I have the General 26020, upgraded from the 160 (reeves drive) and I do love it. Like you, I stuck to my budget and for every lathe there is a trade off; sort of like everything in life. The General is just a sturdy hunk of iron that keeps on running. Their service is good, I call Chris at General in Canada and he's patient and helps until any problem is resolved. Yes, there are more dealers for Jet than General, however I've found the dealers don't often know as much as I do about the General because they sell it rather than use it.

In order to get the best answer to your query, it would have to come from one turner who uses/used both lathe models. All we can do is tell you how wonderful our lathes are! : )

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#12

Don't overlook the hybrids

TDaniel

>There are some good lathes available that may get complaints in one area but praise in others. Sometimes the one area that is not up to parr can be replaced with a better part made by someone else. I was not happy with my Vicmarc VL300 until I put a One-way banjo and toolrest on it; now it is a very good lathe and the two-tone paint job looks wonderful. If I had a Jet 1642 I would use it until the banjo broke and then I would replace the banjo and rest with one from One-way.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#13

Re: Don't overlook the hybrids

Charles Watson

>TD, this is off the original subject, but I've read previous comments from you about the Vicmarc tailstock. Many other turners have praised the tailstock of the Vicmarc lathe, and I too found that the tailstock on the VL300 that I owned worked great.

But I do know I haven't used the perfect lathe yet.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#14

It's not the tailstock...

TDaniel

>it's the banjo/toolrest lock. I had to crank down so hard on the handle that it broke (the handle that locks the toolrest in the banjo); I finally replaced the handle with a bolt from the hardware store and used a long boxed end wrench to tighten it. This worked but it left depressions in the toolrest shaft so I had to file it often. I turn mostly burls and at the price I pay for them I cannot afford to have a toolrest spin into one and blow it up (not to mention the risk to the operator). The One-way locks securely with much less effort. A guy in my club has also replaced the banjo on his PM4224 with a One-way. I saved the original banjos (2) to use with my 24" toolrest because with two shafts it cannot spin.

Re: Jet vs General Head to Head

#15

Re: It's not the tailstock...

Charles Watson

>Oops, sorry TD. Guess my morning coffee had not kicked in when I was reading your meassage.