Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Posts

Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#1

Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Dave Winters

>What's the most contrary wood you have tried to dry, and why? I have heard bad things about eucalyptus and fruit woods. I'm tearing my hair out with some Pimento wood. Got me to thinking about it. What makes some woods easier to dry than others? Tangetial shrinking? Cell wall thickness?

I have tried DNA, boiling, anchorseal, plastic bag, paper bag; no success with any of these.Have not tried microwave.

My next attempt will be to turn thin, green, and just let it go off. Sometimes you have to let the wood win!

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#2

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

John Veerkamp

>Pacific Madrone. Just look at it and it splits.

John

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#3

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

stacey s

>Laurel Cherry (Cherry Laurel) not sure which way it goes. Beautiful wood but I have never had any survive. About like the other wood that was mentioned look at it and it cracks. I think if you looked at it long enough you could watch it crack.

Stacey

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#4

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

john lucas

>The worst wood for me has been Bradford Pear. I know many people have turned it with great success but virtually every piece I've gotten has had internal cracks that you can't see until the piece is half finished.

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#5

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

JKJ in East TN

>>What makes some woods easier to dry than others? Tangetial shrinking?

I read that all else being equal (MC, temp and humidity, etc), drying without cracks is somewhat a factor of the tangential-radial shrinkage ratio. However, I've personally had more trouble with persimmon (T/R:1.5) and small diameter dogwood (T/R:1.6) than white oak (T/R:1.8) or y.poplar (T/R:1.8). Fruit trees in general seem to be problematic.

I suspect there is far more going on perhaps things like the strength of the bonds between the cells, porosity, presence of tyloses in the pores, length of cells, size, distribution, and strength of rays, straight vs. interlocking grain, and the presence of reaction wood.

JKJ

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#6

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>You are correct, John.

All the factors you mention play a part in the tendency of a particular wood to split. When the stress induced by drying forces overcomes the strength of the bonds between the cells, the wood splits. The stresses are created when the wood cells in the surface layers dry below the fiber saturation point and start to shrink while the cells below them are somewhat wetter and still the original size. The wood tends to split along the radial surfaces because the rays are groups of horizontal cells compared to the vertical cells of the wood fibers. As we know from cabinet work, gluing crossgrains is not the strongest bond.

Regardless of the particular wood characteristics the most important factor to consider, and the only one which we can influence, is how much shock are we inducing in the wood. The amount of shock is directly related to the Moisture Content of the wood when it's cut and the Equilibrium Moisture Content rating of the space where we put it. If you take a piece of wood that is at 40 or 50% MC and put it into a space where the conditons will create an EMC of 7 or 8%, then you are going to have a tough time keeping the wood from cracking. On the other hand, if you can create conditions where the EMC is up around 20%, then you have a much better chance of a good result. AnchorSeal, paper bags, etc. are all methods to control the EMC conditions at the surface of the wood.

On the other hand, 20% EMC conditions are also excellent for growing fungus and mold, so you have to be careful about airflow. I'm not surprised that it is so difficult to give someone foolproof, step by step instructions on the best way to dry wood, particularly turning blanks.

It's lots of fun to take a bunch of laboriously prepared blanks to a symposium in an airconditioned space and watch them set there and check before you can get them sold because you didn't have any AnchorSeal left to put on them.

56 today and still learning about drying wood.

Gary

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#7

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Ralph

>Don Larson has an excellent record with boiling Madrone, but he does some unusual steps, so I would hesitate to just do it, but one of them is letting the blanks cool in the water.

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#8

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

robo hippy

>I will second on Pacific Madrone. Dale Larson out of Portland does boil his. I don't like to boil mine because it muddles the colors a bit. I like to turn thin and green (about 1/4 inch), LDD soak (which only makes it easier to sand, not cure), and bag it. This doesn't always work. Madrone starts to split when you fire up the chainsaw. Christian Burshard (spell?) does a lot of work with Madrone, and likes to turn very thin, and then microwave it. It does warp in unpredictable ways. I have had cored sets where every bowl seems to move differently. This is why it is one of my favorite woods.

robo hippy

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#9

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

eliot d

>Gary, Great response! Very informed.

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#10

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

eliot d

>By the way, Happy birthday!

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#11

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, eliot. I had a good one.

Gary

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#12

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Jim Terry

>Good response, Gary. Glad to see you are signed up for the North Carolina Woodturning Symposium in October. Look forward to seeing you again.

Jim Terry

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#13

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

Dave Winters

>Thanks all for the responses. I'll post on WoodWeb too, to get Dr. Gene Wengert's take.

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

#14

Re: Poll: Most difficult wood to dry...

RonZ

>Israeli olive wood. You just cut the aproximate size you need, cut abut ten times more than you need, put on the sealer and pray. I only start in the winter because if I tried it here in the summer, it would be cracked by the time I got it home. Lets not leave out the wonderful 'surprises you find inside when you turn.