Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Curosity about your dust collection system

Posts

Curosity about your dust collection system

#1

Curosity about your dust collection system

Jimmy Edwards

>After as much research and planing I installed a Grizzly 3hp 220v, with 6 stations, close area. Lathe, bandsaw, tablesaw. RAS, miter saw, and router/planer. All 4" line, PVC with flex hose for the drops. Don't know if the planing was worth a hoot but the system works very well and is a lifesaver. I think dust collection is the single most important thing in a shop now that I've seen the difference. Just curious as to the system you fellas have and how it performs.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#2

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Bill Hale

>I have basicly the same system butwhere I live in AZ.I have no collection. My vac is outside of the shop in a kids playhouse and blows out on to the ground. Works great. Be sure to run a ground wire for static discharge , fire protection.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Show Low AZ.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#3

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Jimmy Edwards

>Bill every few feet there is a support wire and I drilled a short screw through the PVC and jumped over to each support wire for grounding. Also adding a JET 2000 for air filtration in the center.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#4

Re: Curosity about MY dust collection system? *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>OK.

I ran my 2hp Reliant collector on a 4" system for about 8 years. Pickups for the TS, BS, chop, Performax, plus a utility port used with a hose for cleaning plus connection to occasionals like the router table, jointer, oscillating sander, and sanding at the lathe.

Wanted a cyclone, but don't have the shop space (or ceiling height) for one.

Just finished converting the system to 6" PVC which included making a new inlet port for the blower. Huge difference! Yes, the tools have 4" ports, but the difference in the amount of air moved is very significant. The TS has 2 ports (under and overarm), the chopsaw cabinet is 6", and I have 2 4" pickups for the lathe.

Convert to 6" ducts when you can!

mm

ps: Forget the grounding wire thing. Because PVC is a very efficient insulator, you cannot ground it with a wire. If you're concerned about static, you change to all metal ductwork. There have be reports of fires in home and small shop dust systems, but thay have ALL been caused by hot metal sparks (like cutting nails) or smoking wood (coming off a blade) lodging in the dust and being fanned by the airflow. Not a single static discharge fire has been documented. Yes there's static. Yes it will spark. But the spark is rather cool and not near hot enough to start ignition in these small collection systems that run intermitantly. More info on Bill Pentz's site if you're interested.


Pentz

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#5

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Jim, Some time ago I researched running a ground wire on a collection system and found that it is a complete waste of time and money.

Norm

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#6

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Rick Allen

>That 3HP system can support an 8" main. Changing to a 6" main and 6" drops to the machines will make a HUGE difference. If you can bring an 8" main and drop to a large dust hood for your lathe, sanding dust at the lathe will be a thing of the past.

JDS makes a 2 HP cyclone that stands 6'. The blower is beside the cyclone instead on top of the cyclone.

Good luck

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#7

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Fog Tanner

>I have a 2hp Onedia cyclone system which moves a lot of air. I don't know what the airflow of you Griz is, but assuming its close to the Oneida - horsepower doesn't always mean airflow - its all in the impeller. If it is, your ducting is too small. Mine starts at 7", then into 6", and the majority is 5", with one short run of 4". You have to measure the pipe size against the airflow. Too small and you can increase the flow, but the air is moving too fast and won't pick up enough dust. Too large and the air is not moving fast enough to carry the dust all the way to the unit and it can stack up in the column. The right size should carry the dust from the pick up all the way to the collector. That is why I have the various sizes, to maintain the correct airflow as the ditance changes. I bought the unit from Onedia, so they figured the size of the runs for me.

I have very little flex, only what is necessary to hook the the various tools. One foot of flex is about 3 feet of duct in air drag, same with elbows. The short radius are probably worse. All the elbows are large radius, which you can't get in PVC from the box stores. I use 45 degree pickups where possible. The Wye's that connect into the line are 45's, another thing you really want to try and do. I used all metal Snap-loc, which was easier to run than PVC, just not as cheap. The options for connectors is also greater. Everything is sealed with metalic silcon caulk so I don't have any leaks.

The best pickup I found for the lathe, was one of those large rectanular "funnels" that are sold for use on radial arm saws. It has a 4" pickup in the back. I built an open "box", where the funnel is setting at about a 35 degree angle. This sits on a table behind the lathe and works great for getting most of the dust. I have two blast gates and two pickups for the lathe. I just haven't gotten around to making a pickup for the front of the lathe. I haven't found one I like, so I am going to make one out of fiberglass and resin. But, that entails making a plug and mold and I'll wait till winter for that.

All that is good for about 90% of the dust, for the other 10% I use an Airstream. I wear that the whole time I am turning, even coring - thats where the "helmet" part comes in. And generally, when I am through turning I leave the shop. There will still be some dust in the air, the submicron particles. Which also happen to be the ones that do the damage. So, you really don't want to hang around too long without a respirator on.

Good luck on keeping your lungs functioning, you have a great start at it and are thinking ahead.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#8

Re: PVC sewer pipe is excellent........

Jamie Donaldson

>... for DC piping- thinner and lighter than other schedule pipe, and has nice radiused elbows and T's. It amazes me how many people believe the old myth about DC explosions from static discharges- they swear they know someone that has suffered this disaster! Running a wire inside PVC only serves to cause the occasional blockage.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#9

Schedule

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"20" or sometimes called "S&D" for Sewer & Drain. Lighter than DWV, and way lighter than Sch. 40. I buy the stuff at a local mason's supply outfit that happens to carry the recycled product that has a white PVC shell and a black ABS liner layer; cuts easily. Make bends with a pair of 45's; as good as a long radius bend even with the joints.

The Depot doesn't carry 6", but Lowes has 6" pipe and some lightweight fittings in a special section.

mm

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#10

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Atwerz

>Fog the tag on my dust collector says 2360 cfm and 16.9 static pressure. Darn after reasearch, installation and working great I'm having second thoughts about should have gone to bigger pipe.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#11

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

Fog Tanner

>I spent a lot of time doing research and reading books on the subject. I think you can get to a point of overload. That's also one reason I was happy that Onedia did all the calculations for me. Basiclly if it works for you and pulling enough of the dust to make you happy, then thats as good as it gets. If its not pulling the dust like you want and your lungs aren't happy, that's another story. But, you can always tweak your system that runs to your lathe, that way you will satisfy the "coulda run just a little bigger" thoughts in the back of your mind and maybe keep your lungs a little happier too.

I know I still have the lingering thought that I wish I gotten the 3hp model of mine, it was another $1500, but it would run bigger pipe, which would pull more dust, which would make me wish I would have gotten the 5hp model....Instead I took half that $1500 and bought the Airstream and saved the other half and I am completly happy with what I have now.

After using both, I wish I had gotten the Airstream first. I am still closer to the source of the dust than the dust collector pickup. I just got back from a week in Provo, turning with Richard Raffan. I drove from Texas just so I could take my Airstream. All week making dust and not one problem. Without it I would have been done in after the first day - sinus problems from too much dust. Richard has spent the last 25-30 years of his turning life in one of these things. I asked him how he manages the dust from these turning classes he does without his Airstream. After 3 weeks of teaching, he doesn't turn for two months when he gets home. Doing everything I can to keep from getting totally that way (2/3 there now - and its not any fun).

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#12

Re: Schedule

Barry Irby

>Mark, I thought it was "schedule 35" for the S & D stuff and 40 or heavier for the other. Whatever it is, Lowes had a much better selection that the Depot. They also had little adapter rings that allowed you to uses the heavier Schd. 40 fittings. They were just sleeves that compensated for the difference in thickness, but the plumbing stuff was so much more expensive than the S&D stuff I never used any. There was an even larger variety of fittings if you needed one, though. Whatever the numbers were, the pipe and fittings were about half the weight and cost and perfectly adequate. I did look inside the pipe to be sure the inside was smooth. Some of it was insanely rough on the inside.

I worked on my system later and out of curiosity ran aluminum tape inside the pipe and grounded it. Can not tell any difference in either static or the film of dust that accumulates on the outside. I like the film of dust, that's my ambient air cleaner. I am not breathing that dust.

Re: Curosity about your dust collection system

#13

Re: Curosity about MY dust collection system?

Bill Crommett

>I, likewise converted my inlet to a 6 inch plate and ran 4 inch solid schedule 40 off the 6 inch PVC to near the machines where the gates are. From there on the corrugated ABS is used. The biggest problem I had was keeping the bag on the collector, so I vented it to the outside and now I have to shovel the sawdust away every 3 or 4 months. Works great !