Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

Posts

Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#1

Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>I posted some questions about using or buying a Tormek and got some great commnets from the gang. Also, found a Tormek www.thingychatgroup at Yahoo which was quite helpful but sort of biased.

Anyway, that being said, I've been looking around, reading, trying to practice my skills some more and went to my evil grinder the other night to sharpen something and guess what I found out.....?

I stated in my earlier post that I had a grinder with a speed of 1750 rpms, which several people including yourself said was sufficient. Okay. I'll listen to someone with experience. It's all good.

I looked at the "specs" on my grinder the other night after cussing it out and realized it turns at 3450 rpms. That and I don't own great lathe tools either.

So, I think the combination of cheap steel tools, high grinder speeds, and my lack of experience with sharpening techniques is what is causing my frustration with "Turning."

Someone in my last post stated that a person should take the tools they have and learn to use them first. I agree with this 100%. I do think buying a slower speed grinder might help and it's a whole lot cheaper than a Tormek. Also, getting a jig like the Wolverine system might be a better way to go.

I just wanted to thank you Jamie for making me think a little bit more about making a big $$$ purchase when maybe I didn't need to.

Thanks !!

Ray :-)

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#2

Re: And as a bonus, the .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... 8" low speed grinder is on sale at Woodcraft stores for $79!! Jump on it ASAP!!!! You will have to dress and maybe balance the wheels right out of the box, but that is a grinder that will serve the needs of the average turner. Buy the Woodcraft diamond dresser that is also on sale, and have some fun grinding those dull tools.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#3

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

Cyril Griesbach

>Ray, Jamie is soooo right on the woodcraft grinder sale. I've seen lots of pros sharpen on the same one as well. I'll also recomend the wolvering jig with the vari-grind.

Cyril

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#4

Wait a minute...

TDaniel

>The Woodcraft grinder will likely need balancing. That is about a $60 (with shipping) additional investment. So $79 plus $60 is $139.. Redmond recently had the Delta 8" 1750 rpm on sale for $134. If you can still get it the Delta is a much better deal.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#5

Re:TD- who says you need a ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...$60 balancing kit to balance a wheel? There are tons of these machines hummmmming along nicely without requiring such gadgets. If you get a bad wheel then Woodcraft has been very quick to exchange for a replacement- you don't need to ask me how I know this!! I have been recommending this grinder to my students and classes with full confidence that it will do the job until they decide they want a Baldor!

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#6

Re:TD- who says you need a ....

bowlman

>What's is a decent price for a Baldor, and where is a good source?

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#7

Re:TD- who says you need a ....

john lucas

>I have one of the woodcraft grinders. It took about 30 minutes of fiddling to get the wheel balanced without any extra gadgets. I've recommended it to many in our club and several have bought this grinder without needing any fiddling.

I looked at the Baldor's and dearly want one but the one I looked at was 3 times as expensive as mine. I purchased a 1" stone to go on one side of my grinder and the wolverine jig and the grinder for less than I would have spent on just the grinder If I'd bought the Baldor.

I'm not putting the Baldor down. If you can afford top quality stuff go for it. It is a very good machine.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#8

Re:And the Delta doesn't have....

Jamie Donaldson

>... 2 AlO (white) wheels, so add about $80~$100 for those upgrades that come standard on the Woodcraft. That's a deal maker or breaker!

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#9

How do you balance a wheel tht is not running true

TDaniel

>Before you can balance a wheel you must be sure it is running 90 degrees to the shaft of the grinder. The cheap grinders do not have mounting plates that will hold the wheel 90 degrees to the shaft. The balancing kit sold by One-way includes new hubs to correct a manufacturing problem of poor mounting plates. I have gone through this on cheap grinders and I can tell you it is hit or miss on many of these made in China grinders. The Delta grinder is also made in China but it is a cut above the rest. A Baldor grinder is very expensive so the most grinder for the money spent I think is the Delta and I am told that it is or was scheduled to be discontinued in favor of their new variable speed piece of junk.

TD (That's my story and I am sticking to it!)

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#10

Re:And the Delta doesn't have....

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I am not so sure what all the hub-bub is about balancing the wheel? Now, I understand that we all want things to run smoothly, but I personally think that the wheel balancer is one of those gadgets w/o a real need beyond being cool.

Bent grinder shafts aside, if you buy an at least fair grinder, and buy at least fair wheels, you should be able to move adjust it, rotating the side plates, or even using a little shim material, so that it spins with only a little side play (maybe a 32th of an inch). You can then certainly face the grinding surface so that it runs true. That is the only part that must turn true to grind your tools. No, one recommends using the side of the wheel for any grinding.

I would rather be putting my money in first class grinding wheels. I recommend the Purple/blue Norton Wheels. The load less, grind smoother, and still last longer than most cheaper wheel. They are worth paying twice as much, they last more than twice as long.

Just my opinion.

Mark

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#11

Why balance?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I have an old grinder with an imbalance in the motor armature or bearings. It likes to walk across the bench when it spins down. No amount of fiddling with the wheels has any effect on the vibration. Any you know... It sharpens tools just as good as any grinder other I've used.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#12

Re: How do you balance a wheel tht is not running

Barry Turner

>I have had the "boat anchor" Delta Slo-Speed grinder for about four years. It's a decent grinder and runs fairly smoothly. I replaced the 60-grit Chinese gray wheel with a 60-grit pink from Woodcraft almost immediately.......much better. I finally replaced the white 120-grit with a Woodcraft 120-grit white. It too, is much better than the stock Chinese wheel. Dang, that grinder is heavy.....about 90#. I've never even bolted it to the bench.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#13

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

Rick Davenport

>For what it's worth........

I'll put in a vote for a Tormek.

It will not only beautifully sharpen your turning tools, it will do a fantastic job on all sorts of other stuff too.

Your wife will forgive the price once you do her kitchen knives.

And with all the fiddlin and diddlin with high speed grinders, you're almost in the Tormek price range.

And since it runs at 90 rpm, you're not going to grind your tools to stumps learning how to use it.

R

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#14

Re:And the Delta doesn't have....

john lucas

>Mark I could not agree more. I've always been able to get the wheels really close or even dead on my simply losening the nut rotating the wheel to a new location or putting shims under one side of the washers for side wobble. I rotate the wheel by hand and run a pencil against it. This shows me the high side. I loosen the nut and push on the high side. This usually takes out some of the vibration. Then check the left and right wobble. Loosen the nut and put a shim (paper, brass shim stock, plastic, whatever works) between the washer and wheel to move the side in the direction you want.

After the last chat with TD on the washers being out I checked mine and they are dead on. I think the problem may be in the wheel quality or even the label on the wheel. When you compress the washers against the wheel it is conceivable that something doesn't compress evenly which would throw the wheel out a little. An 8" wheel would do this more than a 6".

This usually takes out most if not all vibration.

Before I learned to do this I would simply true it up using a diamond hone and sharpen. It vibrated a little but usually worked quite well. I have an old Craftsman the literally walks across the shelf. I still use if for rough grinding and shaping.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#15

Re:TD- who says you need a ....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Same here... a Baldor is out of question but a Dayton is 400 bucks less and still a good grinder.

8 inch grinders

Baldor - $593

Dayton - $193

I bought the Dayton!

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#16

Steven Antonucci

And never burn them or breathe in the airbornes...

steve antonucci

>

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#17

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

Bob Fawcett

>I am gonna disagree with some (or most) and say a 3450rpm grinder is fine for HSS tools. I use a Jet I got almost 30 years ago. It runs reasonably smooth. The secret to a fist grinder is a light touch. You should almost not feel the pressure of grinding.

I built my own Wolverine style jig from the information I found on the web. I have since bought the vari-grind, but still use the homemade slide arm. I made mine from a piece aluminum of T-slot channel used to make jigs. I just turned it upside down and cut a slot for it to ride in in the grinder base I made from 8/4 oak. A 1/4 bolt with a wingnut locks it in place. The pivot pocket for the jigs is a socket head bolt in the end of the T track with about 1/2 of the head cut off to leave a V pocket.

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#18

Not me...

TDaniel

>I never suggested the Baldor although I do think it is a great grinder....just too expensive. I suggested the Delta 1750 rpm for the most grinder for the bucks. Do not buy the VS Delta. I have not tested the Dayton so I cannot comment on it.

TD

Re: Message (update) for Jamie Donaldson

#19

You are partially right

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>You say the secret to a high speed grinder is a light touch. I think that applies to all grinders. I think a slow speed grinder is a little easier on a novice, but once you learn to grind properly then it doesn't matter. Grinding and sanding kind of work the same. Too much pressure builds up too much heat and doesn't work any faster.