Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

discarding sandpaper power disks

Posts

discarding sandpaper power disks

#1

discarding sandpaper power disks

eliot d

>I know the advice about using sandpaper as if it belongs to the other guy. Still, the stuff's not really free, and I just can't bring myself to toss it after only a few uses.( I'm talking about power sanding with 3 in disks -- not hand sanding.) I use the disks from Woodchucker in Canada. I go up to 1000, and have been getting fine results. I do toss one when it feels like it's taking too long to get out the scratches from the last grit. I spend a lot of time sanding and don't tolerate any sanding scratches, but I don't think of the stuff as free and confess to using the disks over and over. So how do you really decide when to discard one of these disks?

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#2

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Ruth Niles

>Do you clean the discs? I run them on the rubber eraser I have for my belt sander. It does help for longer usage but I don't like to work too hard so if a disc is taking too long to give a clean surface, it's gone.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#3

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

eliot d

>Hi Ruth; Yes, I always clean them with a blast of high-pressure air -- or , sometimes, like you, with one of those rubber-like blocks.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#4

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Sanding shouldn't be a chore. The more you use paper the more of a chore it becomes. Discs don't have to be round. I but bulk hook and loop and make my own sq discs. I cut a few hundred at a time and keep them in individual plastic containers by the lathe.

Terry

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#5

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Barry Irby

>Elliot, I am sure I have told many people you should use sand paper like you bought it with somebody else's money. But thin I have he pack rat gene too.

I find that the rim of the disks wears out faster than the center. So when a 3" one seems dull, I use it on the 2" mandrel, without cutting it down. That puts the pressure on the part of the sand paper that has had less use.

I also fold them and use them for and sanding details.

I have not tried cleaning them in Simple Green Like I w=do my Performax sandpaper, but I did clean a H&L disk for my ROS. It worked, but it took all the sterate off the disk.

Did I mention you should use it like you stole it?

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#6

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I clean dry wood from the disks with a blast of air and sometimes the crepe rubber block for the belt sander. Wet wood means I use a brass brush for cleaning the sanding pads. Try to do it before it glazes. When a three inch pad is worn around the edges I go to the 2" holder with it. The center is still good but I do not bother cutting down the edges unless it is near a critical design element that might be smoothed by mistake.

On the other hand, most of my wood is free; my tools are mostly home made and cheap; the lathes were paid for long ago; a few sanding disks for a good sized piece is cheap entertainment.

One of the things that lets the disks last for me is not pulling them on and off the Velcro. Just make a bunch of holders instead and have one for each grit.


Around the Woods

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#7

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Rick Allen

>Hi Eloit

I take three approaches to the longevity of sanding discs.

Option 1 is to use the cheapest sanding discs I can find. I buy the blue film discs from www.vinceswoodnwonders.com. The abrasive is great on these discs, the blue film substrate is flexible and resilient so these discs last a long time and support cleaning. The price is $0.22 US. The discs are oversize so the edge doesn't burn in. In the past I have bought discs from www.sandpaper.ca but the exchange rate has made these a little more pricey than they once were.

Option 2 is to buy discs which are easy to clean. Abranet discs are easy to clean but pricey. These things are $0.56 each. But the mesh nature of these discs make cleaning them easy and effective. The best price I found for these is at www.btisupply.com. Seaching the net may find you a better price.

Option 3 is to buy high quality discs. Abralon discs have a very soft touch but are VERY pricey at $1.50 each. They clean well, not as easy as the Abranet. The best price I found for these is at www.btisupply.com.

My current method is to use Abranet for the grits 80 ~ 180. I switch to the blue discs to 600 and I like the soft touch that Abralon exhibits for 500 and 1000.

Naturally I have grits which overlap these boundaries. The overlaps can sometimes resolve particular sanding issues with different woods, profiles and finishes.

Good Luck with your quest.

Richard

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#8

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Peter Teubel

>Assuming a bowl of around 10" to 12", one disc of each grit for the inside, then one disc of each grit for the outside. Then one disc of each grit for the lower part and bottom (whilst vacuum chucking). So that's about 24 discs per bowl. This is all power/pneumatic sanding.

I never reuse 3" discs. I find it to be false economy especially when I was in a production environment because new (i.e. sharp) sandpaper cuts SOOOO much faster and better than used.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#9

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Rob Simon

>I like the "someone else's money" saying, and I have a mantra I use also:

" Sandpaper is cheap; Elbow Grease is expensive!"

I use the Mark Kauder school of buying bulk sheets and cutting squares on the bandsaw, thanks, Mark.

I pitch 'em before they're dull, I don't want any burnishing or excessive heat.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#10

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

georgetroy

>I have had a limited amount of success cutting sandpaper from sheets and bonding them to the old discs. Rubber cement will work or spray adhesive. Especially good for an immediate grit of sandpaper or canvas backed paper you don't have in the precut selection. Make sure edges hang over somewhat. GT

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#11

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Barry makes some great points about cutting disks down. I use the centers of 3" disks for 2" disks, and the center of 5" ROS disks for 3" disks.

You can further extend the life of a disk by reversing the direction of rotation. This extends the live of the velcro, by pulling it in the opposite directions, but extends the usefulness of the grit as well. As the grit is worn, it is rounded over, or smoothed in one direction. Running it in the opposite direction uses the remaining sharp edges. Reversing the direction of the lathe, allows you to cut off wood fibers that have been pressed down in one direction - raising them up to be cut off.

You can tell if your sandpaper is still cutting by watching the stream of dust going into your dust collection hose (you are using dust collection, aren't you?) If dust is coming off, you are still cutting, but if the stream gets thin, either your paper is worn or clogged.

Mark

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#12

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Dave Winters

>I have another mantra:

"Sandpaper's cheap, it's Elbow Grease that's expensive"

I use the Mark Kauder technique of buying H&L sheets and cutting 'em square on the bandsaw. Thanks,Mark.

Good points Mark, too about reversing drill rotation and lathe rotation.

I pitch 'em probably before I should, but I don't like burnishing or heat build-up.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#13

Sorry- double post on Rob's name...

Dave Winters

>

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#14

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>My power sanding routine (if I had to start at 60git) would be: 60,100,150,220,320,400,600. Note that each grit progression is (about) 50% higher numerically than the previous one. Alternately, you could use 80,120,180, etc (all on the CAMI or ANSI scale).

Going 60-80-100-120-150, is a waste of your time and money.

Also, I find the if, for example, it takes 4 minutes with 100 grit to remove the sanding scratches of the 60 grit, it will then take about 3 minutes to sand out the 100 grit scratches with 150 grit, and 2 minutes with 220 grit, etc. The time decreases with each higher grit.

Once the scratches with the lower grit are removed, further sanding just makes the bowl smaller, not smoother.

Mark

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#15

Re: Like any other phrugal guy ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... I had collected too large a selection of velcro discs over the years, and now am finding that the adhesive is drying up. I bought in bulk and on special sale, but am throwing away or hand sanding with the old discs now that I have a selection of the blue plastic backed materials.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#16

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

robo hippy

>I also use the discs from Vince. Out of all the discs I have tried, these last about twice as long as anything else I have tried, and the price is right. I can sand out a 4 bowl cored set, with one set of discs, and they still are fairly sharp. Turn your sander speed down. I put a piece of 1/4 inch cork under the trigger to limit the top speed. 600rpm is fast enough, if not too fast. This actually helps the sanding go faster, and you don't heat up the wood or the discs nearly enough. Use the eraser sticks often. I will sand the outside then erase, then the inside and erase. On higher grits, like 320 and up, I will erase a couple of times when sanding the inside and outside. Use a firm pad on the lower grits. A 120 disc on a firm pad cuts like 80 grit on a soft pad, and doesn't leave the deep scratches. I use the firm pad up to 150 or 180, then switch to the soft pads. When you are thinking that it may be time to get a new disc, feel the disc after erasing, then feel a unused disc. If you feel a big difference, then change the disc. If it is only a slight difference, then use it some more. With the blue discs, I swear that they can feel dull, but still cut very well. Also on Vince's discs, the grit is the most consistant of any sanding material I have used. Vince's discs are on a plastic film, not paper. It is very strong and flexable.

I also use the LDD soak on green bowls turned to final thickness. The soap does make sanding easier.

In Portland, I was talking to Mike Mahoney about the sand paper that he was using, which is the 3M ceramic (purple) stuff. He says that it lasts longer than anything that he has used, and that he goes through about $200 worth of sanding materials a month. It is available from the sanding glove people. I contacted the local 3M rep, and he will be giving me a call back in the next week or so to come over to my shop and talk. As near as I can tell, it is expensive, and only in shop rolls or PSA, not hook and loop. I will post about that when I know more.

I will consider myself a master turner when I can turn a bowl to uniform thickness without using calipers, and when I can turn one that doesn't need sanding. I am getting closer, but still have a long way to go.

robo hippy

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#17

Ric Taylor

Re: Like any other phrugal guy ....

Ric Taylor

>Jamie,

I have many old disks also, and the adhesive does fail almost immediately. I solved that problem. Before I use the disk, I put about five drops of thin super glue on the fabric side. It soaks through to the sandpaper, and then the fabric doesn't come off.

Ric

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#18

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Bill Neddow

>You can get the 3M purple ceramic paper from The Sanding Glove

http://www.thesandingglove.com/TheSandingGloveCatalog.pdf

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#19

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Not to be a stick in the mud...

First a couple of points:

1) Where and how people spend their money is their own business. God knows I have spent money to have the newest and the neetest stuff.

2) I do like Bruce Hoover and his wife, and love looking through their stuff at the shows (the Sanding Glove folks). I even buy things. So nothing against them, just using their catalog as an example.

BUT - Do you realize that you are paying $.50 a piece for the purple ceramic sanding disks. At that price they need to last 10 times as long as making your own. The disks that they show as "Indasa Rhynogrip" disks that they sell for $7.50 for 50 , are from Industrial Abrasives (indasa)and they are made from the same rhyno grip sheets that you can buy for $16 for a 39"x36", from which you can make about 300-350 2" disks? I can make about 3000 disks in an hour.

There is value, and there is false economy.

Mark


Industrial Abrasive RhynoGrip Paper

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#20

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

Donna Banfield

>I'm one of those turners that uses sandpaper like someone else is paying for it. Or, like someone else who has posted occasionally on this list, who "uses it like toilet paper - only once."

Yesterday I was restocking all my sandpaper bins. I cut all the paper on the bandsaw, using old bandsaw blades. When the blades stop cutting wood, they can still cut the sandpaper. I buy Indasa Rhynogrip 1 meter x 1 yard; or I mean I made my first purchase 2 years and 10 months ago. I noticed that I'm just about out of a couple of grits, and will need to place an order around the end of the year. I bought at least two sheets of the majority of grits, and 4 sheets of 80, 120 and 220. I paid less than $300 last time, and that included shipping. I paid less than $16.95 per sheet, because you can get a price break if you're making a bulk order - but you have to ask.

I'm not a production turner, like Mike Mahoney, but do turn full-time. When I first started using the sandpaper, I tried to reuse most of it, but within the last year, decided unless I can use the 3" disc on the 2" arbor, (i.e., the center of the disc is unused) the entire pile goes in the trash can at the end of the day.

So my next order of sandpaper won't last as long, but it still beats the cost of the pre-cut round discs.

Re: discarding sandpaper power disks

#21

Beggin' your pardon but...

Tony Shaftel

>...how do you do anything 3000 times an hour? Beside counting seconds a little slowly, that is.