Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Posts

For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#1

For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Don henthorn

>to boring bars. What flux do you use. I have done it before with no trouble. Today I can't get the silver solder to flow. I am trying to put 3/16" tips on 3/8"rod. The rod takes the solder just fine, the Enco tip doesn't. I have tried three kinds of flux, a no name from about forty years ago which has worked fine in the past; a tube of Oatey that came with kit and some paste flux that came in a green can from the HD. I just can't get the silver solder to flow on the tip. I am using a Mapp gas torch. What have I missed (or forgotten)(G)?

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#2

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Bill Crommett

>Don: Have you tried Borax ? That is what I use when brazing, but it has been a long time since I have silver soldered anything.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#3

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

john lucas

>Don I don't know what brand I use. I've had it forever. Did you clean the metal?

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#4

John, I thought I had cleaned it well enough but

Don henthorn

>I will give it another shot with lacquer thinner and report back.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#5

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Rich Coers

>You might try to pretin the carbide before soldering to the steel. I also like to cut a small piece of silver solder off and nest it in the flux. It will let me know when the heat is right and will flow out. I don't have to bring in the wire at the right heat that way. I don't use mapgas, so I can't help with any heat ideas.

Here's a link that also gives some good ideas.

http://www.carbideprocessors.com/Brazing/book/05.htm

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#6

ENCO Bits

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Some bits are coated with lacquer, and some have a clear coat that is soft. Maybe the coating has melted on the HSS bit, and formed a barrier to the flux. Try wire brushing and lacquer thinner(??).

Gil

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#7

Re: Cleanliness is next to Godliness, Don.

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>We sandblasted most surfaces prior to silver soldering. If the surface wasn't prepared this way, we would just use the machined surface, but the main thing is no none nada oil or contaminates on the surface. This means fingerprints, especially. I was making an extension drill one time and the welder saw me pick up the drill with ungloved hands by the machined end. He made me go back and remove the finger oil with emery cloth before he would insert it in the hole in the extension shaft.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#8

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Jerry Whitaker

>Don, I don't want to hijack your thread but there are silver solders out there with different percentages of silver and am wondering what is the best percentage for this purpose. I have seen all the way from 5% to 50%. The higher the percentage of silver, the higher the cost. I have never used the stuff but I would like to. Thanks to anyone who can answer this question.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#9

Low temp tin solder is sufficient

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>You really don't need high-temp silver solder for this, as long as you don't overheat the metal when grinding. I've used regular plumber's solder with a paste flux.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#10

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Medium thick CA works just as well. Ellsworth got me started using it. Simple and easy.

mm

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#11

Ken & Mark & Don......

Barry Irby

>I assumed Don was making some sort of butt joint, not inserting the tip in a hole.

Ken, Can you really just use plumbers solder to butt two pieces together and then use it as a hollowing tool? I would have bet dollars to donuts (not such a big bet theses days) that it would have been knocked off on the first try.

Mark, On the few I have made, I drilled a hole in the rod and glued them in with CA. Its a really good opportunity to glue your fingers to the tool. DAMHIKT

One thing David showed us was that if the hole does not go all the way through the bar, when you heat it to replace the tip, the broken tip just pops right out propelled by the vaporizing glue.

(On the first night at Arrowmont I broke David's hollowing tool, playing with it. It was a ADD moment. Yes, I'm one of THOSE guys. David was very gracious and used it as a teaching opportunity.)

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#12

Soldering Butts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If I were silver soldering a butt joint on a boring tool, I would, at the very least, hot pickel the cutter (even better than sand blasting) and the tip of the bar. A couple of 800* heats & quenchs in mild nitric will do nicely to clean off any "furrin stuff" and also lightly etch the metal surface for an enhanced bond with the solder. As Al explained, once cleaned, no touchy/feely or you get no sticky.

However,

Getting a solid butt joint set up and soldered is way more work than simply drilling a hole in the bar and rounding a peg-end on the cutter. A 1/4" peg will do nicely and, as Barry mentioned, changing cutters is easy.

mm

ps: To grind the peg, simply chuck the cutter in a drill, and carefully run it against a spinning grinder wheel.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#13

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Mike Nelson

>Thanks Mark and Barry, I'm going with CA instead of set screws for future tools.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#14

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Jerry Whitaker

>***One thing David showed us was that if the hole does not go all the way through the bar, when you heat it to replace the tip, the broken tip just pops right out propelled by the vaporizing glue.***

This sounds like a real good solution along with the suggestion to put the bit in an electric drill and hold the butt end to the grinding wheel to round it off. Seems to me that it would be best to leave just a real small flat on the four corners to prevent possible twisting and loosening in the event of a catch. And, CA glue, as expensive as it is .... is always available and more accessible and cheaper than good silver solder. Thanks for both of these tips guys.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#15

Re: Ken & Mark & Don......

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I should have been more specific about the situation I've done this in, sorry. I soldered a HSS toolbit on the end of a 3/8" thick x 1" wide mild steel bar which has a pocket milled for the bit, so it has pretty good support. And as Mark says, a good degreasing is essential for a good solder joint.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#16

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

Barry Irby

>CA glue is way low tech compared to solder and silver solder. Even I can do CA. It's got to be a thousand times easier than all this heating a pickling they are writing about. (They are scaring me)

I make mine so the cutter will slip easily in and out of the hole in the shaft and then put CA in the hole and squirt the cutter with Accelerator and stick it into the hole quickly and with authority, before the CA grabs. Smart to wear your face shield while doing this. CA bonds very nicely to eyeglasses. DAMHIKT

A 3/16 cutter will just about fit in a 1/4" hole. You may have to brush the corners on a grinder or you might be able to drive it home.

When I change cutters, I heat the tool enough to soften the CA and then use the same bit I drilled the hole with and run it into the hole to clean it out.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#17

Thanks to everyone.

Don henthorn

>I'm silver soldering because I don't have the tools (not even a vise) to do the drilling. I'm gluing into a ground step on the end of the rod. I seem to be overheating or something since the flux appears to darken and then obstructs the flow of silver. I never used to have problems, now I can't do anything. I will keep on trying with all the suggestions.

Re: For you guys who silver solder tooling tips

#18

Tools

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Don,

All you need is a drill, a 5/32" bit, a clamp or two, and a table. Clamp your tool rod to the table and drill a hole in the end [of the rod |;-} ] about 3/8" deep; straight in for a boring bar, angled in from the edge for a side-cutter. Use the same drill to put the peg on the cutter bit (just grind-it-til-it-fits the hole), and with some CA you're good to go. I bought my cutter stock from ENCO in 2-1/2" lengths and get 3 cutters out of each "bar". Cut them with a thin abrasive cutoff wheel.

mm