Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Posts

Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#1

Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Allen Neighbors

>Imagine this: We have a travel trailer, and, of all things, my wife wants us to use it!!! Who'd have thought... :) She takes along a small sewing machine and her quilting supplies, and is content to stay wherever for a whiile... I'm always antsy to get back home.

At her suggestion (another 'who'd have thought'..) I'm going to buy a small lathe that I can carry along. I would like to have one that is dependable, whose nose matches the tail, and that I can lift easily enough. Don't know what I'm doing...Don't have a fortune to spend. What would be the best one for me, for the price?? I'm looking for suggestions.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#2

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Allen

My vote is for the Jet VS mini. I have been using one for about 5 years and have never had one problem. It is a great machine.

Terry

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#3

Al, this is what I would do...

TDaniel

>Al, I have a Vicmarc VL100 left over. This is actually a very good lathe, much better than the Taiwan stuff. I use one in my shop. It is without a motor but that is no problem. I no longer sell Vicmarc because the company does not support its dealers in a realistic way but this little lathe is a very good machine. Let me know if you are interested and I will give you a fantastic price on it.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#4

Re: Al, this is what I would do...

Allen Neighbors

>Terry, what are the specs on the 100? Swing x Btwn Ctrs, Speeds, etc?

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#5

Re: Al, this is what I would do...

Bill Crommett

>Alan: I bought a VS Jet mini to use while my big General was waiting for repairs. The Jet is so quiet and stable that I am not at all in a hurry to get the General fixed. Check out the stats !~

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#6

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ? *LINK*

charlie b

>I'm assuming that you have turning tools and

a chuck or two, with extra jaw sets. If not,

the price of the lathe will be your smallest

expense ; ). Consider how you're going to

sharpen your chisels and gouges. Dull tools

can lead to accidents. Not good when far

from home.

I've had the JET VS mini (or is it a midi?) which

runs around $329-$359. comes with a live

tail center and a spur drive center, along with

a cast iron tool rest. Has a 10" swing, though

you can't get the tool rest banjo under a 10"

piece, about 12" between centers and weighs

may 50 pounds.

The variable speed is REAL handy. Lets you

go "slow" (I think the lowest rpms is 500) or

faster (1200 rpms) without changing the belt

over to another set of pulleys. By changing

belt to the other pulleys you can go 1100 -

2600 and 1700 - 3900 (haven't gotten off

the first set of pulleys - yet).

I've turned bowls up to 9" diameter and 4"

deep - from bandsawn roughly to round

blanks - little itty bitty things and everything

in between on the JET in the last three years.

Other than a tool rest that broke, have had

no problem at all with it. I can bog it down if

I try, but lighter cuts make up for raw grunt

torque (the motor isn't that big - 3A, "1/2 hp").

Most of the major scroll chuck makers have

adapters for mounting their chucks to the

JET VS mini/midi - which is nice.

You can get a bed extension for this thing

that'll let you do baseball bats and table

legs or stair ballisters if you want to -though

a bigger lathe would be better.

This is a great little lathe and pretty bullet

proof.

charlie b

ps Want to turn a Wig Stand? You can on

the JET VS mini


Wig Stand on a JET VS mini

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#7

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

john lucas

>Allen I believe the VM100 has about the same specs as the older Jet mini but without a motor. I almost bought one but ended up with the Nova Comet which looked the same but had a motor and they sold it with 1 1/4 x 8 spindle which matched my other lathe. You can't get that one anymore.

I would also go with the older Jet mini if you don't buy the Vic. The new jet is bigger swing but much heavier.

I also have a Carbo-tec mini which is quite small but a lot of fun to turn on. I believe it has an 8" swing and 12 between centers but it also has #1 morse tapers and 3/4 x 16 thread where the jet and vic have #2 morse tapers and 1"x8 thread.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#8

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Bill Neddow

>Allen, go with the Vicmarc -- it is the best. If, for some reason, you cannot -- go with the Jet Mini or Steel City Mini. We have a lot of mini lathes in our club for teaching. The Deltas and Generals are always broken.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

keith tompkins

>Hi Allen, I picked up a Rikon mini at the Yankee Symposium in CT. It was the demo model for the show, and I purchased it for $200.00. It has a 12" swing, 8" tool-rest, and 1/2 hp motor. While not v/s, it has six speeds which are easy to change; the belt cover swings out of the way to make the belt accessible. It has a 1x20 spindle and #2 tapers. It's a bit on the heavy side at 89 pounds, but that's an advantage while turning. It appears to be built like an anvil.

I bought this as a travelling lathe for demos, and as a back-up student lathe.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#10

Re: Best ..., kinda long

Dave Staeheli

>If you turn down material from the very rough, I can't recommend the Jet Midi. We turn a lot of burls, always out of balance, and we beat the stuffing out of the Jet. Tailstock just couldn't handle the stress.

I'm a gypsy woodturner, moving from place to place in the back of my truck. I started with a Klein, which I still think is a good lathe. I admit I'm rough on my lathes, working with mostly "found" wood, which alway seems out of balance. Still no failures. One thing Bonnie sells is a way to mount a grinding wheel on her lathe. It means one more machine you don't have to take with you which is great. Unfortunately the 5 1/2 inch swing is pretty limiting.

So I got a Vicmarc VL100 pro package. Not a perfect lathe, but pretty robust. After a few modifications, a bit better. Happy with the stable table top stand which adds some weight although just about all I can carry around by myself. The original hole in the stand which Vicmarc made to change the pully belt on the motor was rediculusly small, so just cut the entire end plate out. Made myself an arbor for mounting a grinding wheel, ala Bonnie Klein, so don't have to carry a grinder. Screwed on a couple of drilled out wooden blocks on the backside to drop in a couple of thrift store desk lights. With a couple of tool boxes, the lathe, some sort of table or tailgate, I can set up just about anywhere. It is about the most expensive "portable" midi lathe you can find, but in my opinion, the best.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#11

Re: Best... vise

Dave Staeheli

>One thing I find invaluable for a gypsy woodturner is a good vise you can clamp on somewhere. I tried a couple but found the Zyliss vise to be the most versitle. I just checked ebay and didn't find any, but usually can at about $30. I opens up pretty wide, and you can even press pens with it.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#12

1"x 20 spindle

john lucas

>Keith are you sure about that, I thought it was 1" x8

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#13

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Lan Brady

>Allen,

Looks like you will get as many different answers as there are people. I bought a mini, so I could take it traveling as well. I went with the new 12 inch swing Jet Mini.

Reasons:

bigger swing, 12"

more power, 3/4hp

built in lamp

Indexer

same spinde as my stationary lathe

It is not VS, but easy enough to change speeds.

Good Luck in your decission. Make your list of wants and needs. You will find one that works perfectly.

Lan

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#14

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Gordon Seto

>http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=128188

Gordon

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#15

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

DickAnderson

>Allen:

I have both the jet Mini nd the Technatool Mercury. Mercury is slightly smaller and 10# lighter. It has a 1/2 hp motor, variable speed down to zero, 1" x 8tpi spindle and is well built. I like it better than my Jet Mini.

I understand that Technatool has started making these again and the price should be comparable to the other minis. If you can find one you won't be disappointed.

Dick

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#16

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Stuart Johnson

>Allen, I assume (I know this is bad to do) you plan on doing your turning outside. If so why couldn't you have a steel box fabricated to hold the lathe onto the rear bumper. Of course this would depend on the travel trailer but it could be high and wide enough for the lathe with storage under the lathe.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#17

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Allen Neighbors

>What is bad to do, Stuart? Turning outside or building onto the bumper? I'm don't understand. However, I can't build onto the bumper, because that is where the spare tire and bicycle rack goes, and too much weight on the back isn't good for pulling. However, this is all just in the planning stages thus far, but I've thought about turning on the tailgate of my truck. Otherwise, I guess it'll have to be on a stand close to the trailer. Good idea, and something to think about anyway. Thanks

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: 1"x 20 spindle

keith tompkins

>Oops! Sorry John, you are correct....don't know where the "20" came from.....

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#19

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Stuart Johnson

>Assume... as the old saying goes in business when you assume you make an ass out of u and me. I didn't think about the weight being an issue. I was thinking there might be a way to mount it so you wouldn't need to much more than uncover it and plug it in not lug it around.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#20

Re: Disregard, I told you I'm Slow. :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#21

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

C.W.Stivison

>I vote for the jet mini VS.

CW

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#22

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Allen!

Sounds like fun!

Before I answer, understand that I own a Jet VS Mini, I use it, and I love it! I recommend it to others, even though I have mostly switched over to my Oneway.

When I read your question I immediatly thought of the VL100. It would pretty much be the perfect lathe for this purpose. You can add the motor to it that will give you the performance you need. I just don't think you could hope for more! The little Mercury, if you can find one, would be nice if it had a bigger motor, but I think overall the VL100 blows it away. And what about the Jet Mini? Well, it would be great! But you did ask for the best for this specific purpose, and the Vicky edges out the Jet. ;-)

Have fun!

Scott.

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#23

Re: Arbor ala Bonnie Klein....

Allen Neighbors

>I checked her WebSite and couldn't find anything that was an arbor for mounting a grinding wheel. Can you elaborate on this... maybe show a pic?

Thanks,

Allen

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#24

Re: Dick, I've looked everywhere...

Allen Neighbors

>for the Nova Mercury. Apparently, Teknatool is the only entity that knows they're making the Mercury again.

Woodcraft doesn't have it on there Website, so I emailed them. I got an email back that said, "They've discontinued the Mercury."

Craft Supplies USA doesn't have it online, and so far I haven't gotten an answer to my email query. :(

I'd like to see one of them up close and personal.... :)

Thanks for posting,

Allen

Re: Best Mini/Midi for the $$ ?

#25

Re: Arbor ala Bonnie Klein....

Ed Karch

>Allen check out item#LCM6 at Penn State. This might work for sharpening out on the trail with a mini. One could do something similar with a piece of mdf on a turned M2 mandril with some sticky backed sandpaper. I am heading to a class in Texas with my mini on the tailgate next Oct. and will try this thing out.