Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Another coring question

Posts

Another coring question

#1

Steve Kubien

Another coring question

Steve Kubien

>I've been thinking of a coring system for a while and haven't yet found the answer I am looking for.

I read in some book (may have been a Raffan book) about coring from the headstock side being easier because as you peel off the outer bowls, you can turn a tenon on the new one right away. Makes sense to me and I'd like that ability. What system allows me to do this?

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Re: Another coring question

#2

Re: Another coring question

Jason Clark

>The Bowl Mill has a couple of photos showing milling done from the headstock side, using this process they don't have to rough turn the bowls, the entire outside of the bowl is removed in a single piece.

http://www.bowlmill.com/cgi-bin/bowlmill/bowls3.html

Mike Mahoney mentions that McNaughton makes a set of reverse curved knives for coring on the ourboard side where the rotation would be opposite the normal counter-clockwise rotation we deal with (or if your motor was reversible and you wanted to do it that way). If I remember the video correctly Mahoney doesn't put a Tenon on the piece (except for the largest) until the pieces have been dried, if you have to true the tenon up after the bowl has distorted you may as well not have cut a tenon in the first place.

Jason

Re: Another coring question

#3

Steve Kubien

Good point

Steve Kubien

>Thanks Jason. I hadn't thought of the distorted-through-drying tenon. Still, I think it would be handier to go from the headstock side and make a tenon if only to be able to mark the centre (inside and out). Am I making more work out of this than I need too?

Steve Kubien

Re: Another coring question

#4

Re: Another coring question

Fog Tanner

>McNaughton makes baldes whuch work from the headstock side. This is what Richard prefers, eventhough he looses the smallest bowls from the center. But we are also talking about someone that roughed out 250 bowls in 2 1/2 days, so he is looking more for speed that the smallest bowls he can get. He also does outflowing bowls which can be cored from the headstock side, cutting a cone or cones from a normal shaped bowl.

An alternative to the headstock side for what you are talking about, is to turn a recess in the blank for your jaws to expand into after you have done the outside of the bowl. You can core off the outside bowl, then reverse the blank on the chuck and turn off the outside and add a tennon to the blank. You can repeat this until you get to the smallest bowl and then hollow out the recess.

Mahoney turns a tennon after the drying process. His reasoning is you are just wasting wood with a tennon that is going to warp. I have started doing that and get an extra couple of bowls. Since I start out on a screw chuck, if I am going from the outside in I just put it back on the screw for the next bowl. This would be Mesquite where I am finish turning the bowls and not worries about warping.

Either set of blades will work for you. It just depends on what you are looking for and what you get comfortable with.

Re: Another coring question

#5

Steve Kubien

Thanks

Steve Kubien

>I guess I've got a little more thinking to do and I need to view the various videos which are available. Thanks for all the info

Steve Kubien

Re: Another coring question

#6

Huh?

Bob Fawcett

>Color me stupid.

I can't imagine how you core from the headstock side.

Re: Another coring question

#7

Re: Huh?

Fog Tanner

>The blades are curved the opposite of the ones you use on the tailstock side. Coring is on the right hand side, facing the bowl from the headstock. Other than that, it is the same. It has the advantage if you want to place a tennon on each blank. You can do that without having to take the blank off and remount it as you would from the tailstock side. Works fastest if you have two tool rests so you can leave one set up for coring and the other for doing the outside of the bowl. Just depends on if you are looking for speed or maximum number of bowls (and tennons).

Re: Another coring question

#8

Re: Another coring question

robo hippy

>Don't know how I missed this thread. The blades you are refering to are made only by McNaughton, and are called outboard blades, and come in the large and standard sizes. They have to be ordered, I believe, because they aren't used by most people. The biggest advantage that I can see is that you have the biggest mass of the bowl closer to the headstock, so less vibration as compared to standard coring where the base of the bowl (least mass) is closest to the headstock, and the rim (most mass) is farther from the headstock. With the more curved blades, the headstock can be in the way. If you turn a recess in the top of the bowl blank, and remove the biggest core first, you have the core centered for remounting and easy turning of a recess or tenon, whichever you like to use. No real time savings, each piece must be mounted, the same number of times to turn for turning a mortice or tenon, weather on the top of the bowl, or the bottom for remounting.

robo hippy