Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

Posts

Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#1

Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

Craig Daymon

>I'm considering a coring system. I'm addicted to nice pieces of lumber and since this is sometimes exotics that I've paid cash for, I'd like to turn less of it into sawdust. Like Gilmer Wood has some sweet looking big chunks of Bubinga right now that are pretty pricey, but if you slice them up and core them you could get a decent return. There are 2 pieces, 11-7/8" x 11-7/8" x 37", that would slice up into 6 blanks almost 6" thick and nearly 12"x12". I'm guessing 4 bowls per blank?

I'm using this as a basis to determine the value of the coring system. Does that seem right? In that particular case we are talking about a $625 chunk of wood. (Doubt I'll buy it, but nice example.)

I'm also thinking the McNaughton system offers the most bang for the buck and largest number of size options. I have a Powermatic 3520. Are there any McNaughton issues with the 3520?

All opinions welcome. Thanks,

Craig

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#2

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

Jason Clark

>I have the standard Mcnaughton system and the Powermatic 3520B and absolutely love it. The Mcnaughton system offers much more flexibility than any of the other systems (Oneway, Woodcut) but it does have a pretty steep learning curve. The Bill Grumbine and Mike Mahoney videos are espescially helpful as the written instructions in the box are essentially worthless.

The 3520B has more than enough power, any catches or chip buildup usually result in belt slippage, you may require a longer tool post as the standard set is geared toward a lathe with a 16" swing, CSUSA should be able to help you out there. One of my next purchases will be one or more of the blades for the jumbo system so I can take out a 18-20" core as I'm looking to exceed the 20" swing by turning outboard.

On a piece 12 X 12 X 6 I'd expect a total of 3 bowls, possibly 4, but I tend to leave my roughouts fairly thick here in the desert of Arizona, particularly the largest of the set.

Jason

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#3

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

Rick Allen

>So the answer is that on that single piece of Bubinga at $625 you could get 36 bf without a coring system or 87 bf (maybe 92 bf) with a coring system. The value gained as profit the coring system developed you get

somewhere around $800.

In that one hunk of bubinga you can more than pay for any coring system out there.

Of course the truth is that to get that many bowls out of the hunk of wood you are limited to the profiles that the knives which your coring system provide. With fewer cores you get more freedom of shape as your core can be thicker. Still it doesn't take very many cores to pay for the system.

The other truth is that you will lose some wood because you coring goes through the bottom or the side. So it might take two hunks of wood like that big piece of bubinga to get your money back. It is almost impossible not to get your money back from a coring system.

Good Luck

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#4

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

Fog Tanner

>I have the Jumbo blade set and bought blades from the standard and mini sets. I core Pecan blanks in the 19"-22" fairly often and so far I have not used the Jumbo blades. You can use the standard blades for the size your are talking about. Mahoney rarely uses his jumbo blades, using the standard size blades for most of his large bowls. If you get the mini blade you can get another couple of bowls eaisly. I normally get four thick walled bowls from a 19" blank, now I can get 5-6 depending on the mood and the wood.

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#5

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

Fog Tanner

>I have some pecan and mesquite(couple thousand pounds) I am going through right now. Some of the blanks are up to 23", from which I can get a 20"-22" roughed out bowl. From those blanks I can get 5-6 roughed out bowls. Most of the blanks are smaller in the 14"-18" size. From the larger blanks I can get 5-6 roughed out bowls, plus another 4 or more from the offcuts. The mesquite, I core closer to the finished size as it doesn't need the drying time so I get more bowls per blank. It doesn't take long to get quite a few bowls drying. I have paid for the system several times over in the number of bowls I get from each load of wood.

I use the McNaughton system. I have used it on the Delta 16" steel bed lathe with no problems. I now use it on a 24" Vicmarc 300. The blades on the McNaughton are curved to match the curve used on standard prduction bowls. If you rough the blank to this shape you will get more bowls per blank. But, it is also very versitile allowing you to core other shapes, including cones for outflowing bowls. You won't get as many outflowing from a blank, but two or three is better than just shavings.

I have the Mike Mahoney DVD and was in a workshop with him. Both helped me a lot in improving my coring. But, there still is a learning curve with the system but well worth the time. Its also worth learning how to core from the outside in as well as the inside out. Each has it place, Mikes nested sets are cored from the outside in and I get more mesquite bowls coring from outside in. The pecan is inside out and more bowls per hour.

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#6

Make sure you get the tall post

KurtK in Indy

>I bought the McNaughton corer system and am happy with it. It is very loud though. I would caution you that you tell them you have the 3520 (which is what I also use) and make sure they send the long 1"post they have. I initially got the system and it came with the shorter post and the center of the cutting tip and my machine didn't quite line up.

It will save you $$.

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#7

Inside/Outside?

Craig Daymon

>Fog,

I think I know what you are talking about when you say inside-out versus outside-in, but would you please describe the difference?

Thanks,

Craig

I'll remember to order a longer post. Lee Valley offers a Standard/Mini package, which sounds like might be the best package, but I don't know if they offer the longer post.

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#8

Re: Inside/Outside?

Jason Clark

>Fog is referring to which piece is cored first, do you start by removing the smallest core first, working to the largest or do you start with the largest core first and work to the smallest. Smallest to largest would be inside out, largest to smallest would be outside in. Both have their places but IMO the largest bowl is the one that's going to be worth the most and should be your priority so I start from the outside and work in. I'll sacrifice one or more of the smaller cores if it means ensures success with the largest of the set.

Jason

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#9

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

Brodie Brickey

>The standard set will work just fine for most of your coring. If you go really deep into a big bowl you'll have to get the Jumbo cutters. When I shopped it out http://cuttingedgetools.com had the best deal around.

You do need the longer post for the PM. The regular does not put your cutter at center which you need to have for your coring experience to be successful.

I would skip the Bubinga temporarily until you've cored about 10 bowls from logs or as practice.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#10

Re: Inside/Outside?

Fog Tanner

>Jason,

Craig is right on. It is all where you start and what you are looking for. For the Pecan I am working, I mark out the thickness of the blanks allowing for the kerf of the tool (3/8"). I start on the inside or smallest bowl and work towards the outside (i.e. inside out)keeping the largest bowl in mind. If I have to I will core one of the smaller bowls thinner and then finish turn it and let it warp. I like those kinds of bowls.

For Mesquite, I start with the outer bowl coring about half or less than I would with Pecan. I go to the next one and do the same. Mesquite has no appeciable movement and I turn these bowls to completion. This would be outside in, the outermost bowl to the innermost. You would also do this if you wanted to have a go at the nested sets like Mike Mahoney. You will also need the mini set of knives (or at least one or two) if you want to get really small like Mike does. He cores those sets very close to finish thickness. But he has also done several thousand to get to that point.

One of the points I learned from Mike was its not that hard to locate where the tip of the tool is. The tip is inline with the flat potion of the blade, all you have to do is know what that distance is and visualize where that is in your wood. With practice it becomes fairly easy. The most important thing I learned from Mike, was turn the speed down to under a 100rpm as you get near the bottom. I normally core at 600rpm, but turn it down to 50-60rpm when I am close. I have a story about that, but it is too long for here. I'll just say that if it wasnt't for that, I wouldn't be here - I owe Mike a dinner for that.

Fog

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#11

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

RonZ

>As a full time woodturner, I'm a member of the K.I.S.S. club. If it takes to long to learn or is not plug and play, I don't want it. I had Mcnaughten and it was unpredictable. Sold that and got a Woodcut. That one is OK but a local friend uses the Oneway and he says it works the best. Keep in mind that the wood here in Israel is very hard and similar to your Bubinga.

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#12

Planned to skip the big bubinga, but...

Craig Daymon

>...there is another piece about 15.5" x 15.5" x 5.75" that looks very tempting.

I really like Bubinga. I know this stuff is available in big boards 6 to 8 feet wide, (usually several thousand dollars and 15+ feet long) but you rarely see large platter size stock available, like big enough for a 18" to 20" platter. Too bad.

Anyway, I'll have to figure out what knife set(s) I want. I'm thinking standard and mini. If I have the need for the big set I can always get that when I need it.

-Craig

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $$?

#13

Re: Coring systems - Best price/value? Worth the $

robo hippy

>I like the McNaughton as it is the most versatile (you can core regular bowls, platters, and vases), and the fastest. The Woodcut is just to small for me. The Oneway is nice, and I prefer it for the bigger cores, as it is more stable when I am coring a 18 inch diameter bowl, but use the McNaughton for 95% of the cores I take. The McNaughton does have a learning curve. If you do production bowl turning you need a coring system. With the size of that piece of bubinga you are drooling over you can get your money back. Don't start out with the bubinga as the first wood that you core. It is hard. You want something softer for first attempts, and green, like cherry, apple, or maple. For finding where the point is, McNaughton now has a laser pointer that they make for the coring system, which I have, and love. I didn't like the way it was designed to mount on the handle (using the same set screws that hold the blade in place), and had the mounting bracket welded to the handle. You know exactly where the point is, and if you are off course, you can correct before you go through the bottom and make another lampshade. For most of the cores I do, I use the medium and small curves on the standard and mini set of blades 90% of the time. The large curve is used less often as I turn mostly bowls. You don't need all of the blades. Do get experience with the standard set of blades before you try the large set. I have a PM3520A model.

robo hippy