Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

Posts

Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#1

Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

Please join us tonight for our weekly Turning Chat, our topic will be: Production Work, Does It Harm The Perception Of Our Art In the Mind Of The General Public?

In a recent conversation, a serious multi-media art collector and gallery owner (who shall remain nameless) made some interesting comments about woodturning in general and production woodturnings specifically stating: "Production woodturnings of any type, by any woodturner, do nothing to advance the art of woodturning within the medium, or in the mind of the general public. Their simple forms sacrifice unique artistic elements, in favor of those designed strictly for speedy execution and are generally devoid of artistic creativity, or detail."

This gentleman went on to say that he felt production work (he defined "production work" as multiple forms of any woodturning project produced quickly with few artistic elements) may in fact be harming the overall impression of woodturning and its acceptance as a legitimate art form in the mind of many serious collectors and the public. He felt that all production woodturnings look too much like craft work and not real ground breaking unique artistic work, thereby nurturing the perception of our medium as a "craft" instead of an "art" within the mind of the general public. He also indicated that many of his gallery customers seemed to share these feelings as well.

So what do you think? Do you feel that production woodturnings of any type (bowls, pens, platters, hollow forms, peppermills, bottle stoppers, etc.) are harming the perception of woodturning by somehow forestalling the general public's acceptance of woodturning as a true art form? Join us as we discuss what will undoubtedly be a very interesting and lively discussion of the impact of production work on woodturning and whether it's harming the perception of woodturning as a legitimate art form in the mind of the public.

We will start the chat with a 15 minute review of 2 selected works by our WC friends.

If you are interested in having your work reviewed at the turning chat, remember to email Ron 1 or 2 (max.) photos of some of your recent work (completed or unfinished, in process etc.) for our "Show and Tell" session. Please indicate whether you are submitting the photos as "Completed Work" for a critique, or as an "Assistance Needed" submission that you would like some type of help, or assistance with.

Turning Chat room opens at 9:00pm EDT (For meet and greet)

Show-N-Tell starts at 9:30pm EDT

Main Topic starts at 9:45pm EDT

Post Chat Wrap-Up starts at 10:30pm EDT (For extended discussions if desired)

See you there!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#2

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our

john lucas

>Man would I love to be there for that. Unfortunately I'm demonstrating in Crossville tonight and probably won't be home until the last minutes of the chat.

I'm a production turner mostly but I'm trying very hard to make some pieces that are defninitely "art". I think most of the money in woodturning right now is in production work. If you go to the art and craft shows there will be some gorgeous work that I would put in the art realm but it could easily be considered production work because the artist probably makes 100's of the same sort of pieces with minor changes due to grain,the wood itself, how you feel that day etc. Each piece is a one of a kind even though they are similar.

I think I understand the point of view of the writer in that there are many people that think "pretty" isn't art. Those people don't think an Ellsworth piece is art.

Great topic. I'll talk fast tonight and maybe finish my demo early.

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#3

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our

john lucas

>As I was driving back from lunch I happen to think that all of the mediums have their craft side, glass, clay, wood, metal. Go to any art fair and you will see mostly production work. Of course it's hand made and probably no two are the same but each artist has arrived at a style that sells and they produce that style and variations on that style until they feel the need to change the style according to current trends.

Has this hurt the Art fields of Glass, Clay, wood etc. I don't think so. The question in my mind then is can an artist excell in both areas. Now that's a tough one.

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#4

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our

Russ Fairfield

>John,

My answer to this question is a question -

Does it really matter, and what can we do about it?

The way I see it is that there are three different venues; and each has its own suitable product, its own clientele, and its own value and pricing system. I sell art at galleries, and and I sell craft and kiitchen stuff at craft shows. The 3rd area is the flea market, and that includes school and church bazzarrs because they draw the same vendors, the same clientele, and products sell for similar prices.

I don't try to sell salad bowls in art galleries. I do sell salad bowls at craft shows. I haven't been to a flea market or bazzarr for years because I no longer makes cheap stuff the fits the value range of that venue. I never sell the same things in different venues at different prices. That is the fastest way yo get into trouble, and I learned that lesson many years ago.

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#5

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I think what is most likely is that "craft" turnings are impacting the gallery guy's own business, or at the very least, he thinks they are. I do artsy stuff that sells for a pretty good price, but then again, I don't charge $50.00 for a $15.00 chair spindle because it was me who turned it. Even if I did, I suspect no one would be willing to pay it.

Diversity in business is good for me, or at least for my business. It is nice to sell the occasional art piece, but when that slows down there is always the mundane stuff, and if that slows down there is furniture, teaching, demonstrating, etc etc etc. But if I had to pin the health of my business on one particular venue, I could see where I could get into trouble.

Bill

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our art?

#6

Re: Tonight'sChat: Is production work hurting our

TDaniel

>Very true Bill, it takes it all to pay the bills.