Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Tormek sharpening system opinions??

Posts

Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#1

Tormek sharpening system opinions??

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>Anyone own one?

Ray

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#2

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

Stuart Johnson

>Yes, it does a great job on everything. But, I stopped using it for my turning tools after buying a Woodcraft slow speed grinder and the Oneway Wolverine jig. The Tormek is now used for knives, scissors and planner blades.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#3

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

wilbur

>I do. I bought it strictly for turning tools and curved blades, since I sharpen chisels and plane blades on waterstones. I wasn't getting anywhere trying to sharpen turning tools freehand on waterstones.

I decided on a Tormek as opposed to a grinder/Wolvering jig primarily for these reasons:

1. I don't have to worry about inhaling grinder wheel and metal dust. I figure if wood dust is bad for you, grinder wheel and metal dust must be at least as bad.

2. Many people say that a grinder is faster, but I found that to be a bit of a disadvantage, since for me the faster action of a grinder just allows me to screw up the tool that much more quickly.

3. Also because a Tormek is "slower", it tends to remove less metal to obtain a sharp edge than a grinder, which leads to longer tool life, which means saving money.

4. No sparks flying around my shop, which is not that spacious.

From a practical standpoint, I've found that there is no difference between a Tormek and a grinder/Wolverine jig when it comes to sharpening/honing a turning tool that is already set up. If you sharpen freehand on a grinder, then you save the time spent mounting the tool in the jig, but otherwise I've found no real difference in time spent sharpening between the two jig systems.

There is a difference if you are trying to put a new profile on a turning tool, but I was able to take a gouge with a regular profile to a fingernail profile in about 10 minutes, which seemed reasonable to me. This will be a one time operation for most people.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#4

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

ken chase

>I bought mine a long time ago when I was building furniture and needed to sharpen my chisels. I'm too impatient to use it for my turning gouges. The Tormek is just too slow.

I hated flattening the stone but I see they came out with a new add-on to make the chore easier. I use the Wolverine and just purchased a clever device made by Don Geiger which is used with the wolverine and the Elsworth jig. I really noticed an improvement in all my swept back bowl gouges.

Ken

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#5

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

RonZ

>I own one and I'm happy with it. I would get a regular grinder also as it is slow for rough grinding to shape your tools and it is a waist of the stone.

They have two new additions that for me have really changed the way it works. One is the new diamond dressing tool and the other is the turning tools setter. I can get set up and finish grinding in under a minute [per tool]. When I sharpen a skew, long grind spindle or bowl gouge on the Tormek, the edge lasts 3-5 times longer and gives me a better final cut.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#6

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

Darryl Hansen

>I bought one a long time ago. I usually only sharpen my "ellsworth" type gouges and so leave the jig spacing set up all the time. I put a 21/2 spacer on the bench top and use that to set the length of the gouge in the jig. Some say it is slow but I can sharpen a gouge using my set up in 18 seconds so I have no problem with the speed. Sharpens extremely well and since I am a KLUTZ and can't use a grinder free handed it has saved me a considerable amount on tools. The upfront costs are high no question on that. I'v had mine about 4 years with no problem and it was the demo at a wood show so it had plenty of wear before I got it home.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#7

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

JKJ in East TN

>There is past discussion in the archives. Some love it, some think it's a waste of money. I love it because it only takes a few seconds to set up, removes an extremely tiny bit of metal, and leaves a consistently razor sharp edge. Contrary to the opinion of some, it is extremely quick to sharpen a complex shape on a gouge once the shape has been defined. I typically hone a number of times between sharpenings while turning, then stop and sharpen a batch of tools at once.

It is slow to remove a lot of metal so I use a 1/2 speed bench grinder when reshaping. I plan to someday modify the grinder to use the same support and jigs as the Tormek.

Jet has a copycat version - I was told the Tormek patent ran out. You might check to see which is better.

JKJ

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#8

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

Bill Hale

>As I have two shops I have two Tormek systems. I also have a grinder in each shop. I only sharpen on the Tormek and all of the reshaping is done on the grinders. I also second bevel on my tools with the grinder and this reduces the the tool bevel to the Tormek wheels.

I find it fast and always a duplication of profile.

The fact that I have two of them tells my opinnion.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Show Low, AZ.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#9

JL

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

JL

>I have a Tormek and an 8" slow speed grinder. I usually use the 8" grinder for my gouges and then hone with the honing side on the Tormek. I do use the Tormek for scrapers.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#10

Depends.....

TDaniel

>If you tend to cut with the nose of your bowl gouge you will like the results from the Tormek but if you cut with the side of the gouge with the handle low then you will likely get a faster cut with a gouge sharpened on a 80 or 100 grit wheel. I think the tiny serrations that you get from a standard grinder may actually help cut the wood fibres the same as a steak knife works better than a super sharp honed knife would work. Just as there are different blades for different cutting purposes there will be times that the edge from the Tormek will be best suited to a job and there will be times that the edge from the grinder will be better. I have both but 98% of my sharpening is done on a 100 grit wheel on a low rpm 8" grinder.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#11

Re: Tormek comments. Thanks gang.

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>I already have a grinder, 6", with a 36 grit coarse stone on one side and a 1 1/2" - 100 grit white stone on the other. Unfortunately, it spins at 1,725 rpm. I've tried with all my might to sharpen tools only to ruin them. I've even practiced on some "beater" hand chisels before committing to my good ones. I don't have the guts to attempt lathe tools.

When I commit to buying tools and so forth a few things are important.

1) Funtionability (is that a word) Will it perform as they (the manufacturer) say it will.

2) Ease of use. I don't have time to spend fidling with gadgets.

3) Cost/usage - If it costs "x" amount of $$$ will I get "x" out of it. I bought a Wagner power painter thinking it was going to save me time......I spent too much time fussing with it, cleaning the parts, etc. Gave it to some sucker. He was happy.

Anyway, I appreciate the advice as always from the WC gang. I'll have to check out the Wolverine items and other options. Research doesn't cost a dime. :-)

Ray

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#12

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. you say that unfortunately your grinder runs at 1750 rpm- that is the ideal speed for a 100 grit white wheel and turning tools?

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#13

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

john lucas

>I agree with Jamie. I've used a 6" 3450 grinder for years for all sorts of sharpening and have now switched to an 8" 1725. I like the 1725 speed. It not as intimidating, doesn't heat up the tool as fast and still sharpens just fine.

I don't really agree that the tormek takes off less metal. With a properly tuned grinder and a good jig that is set correctly you can sharpen with very little metal removeal.

My mantra is, take what you have and learn to use it. then upgrade when you can. I turned for 12 to 15 years with a Craftsman 6 grinder at 3450 rpm and a cheap gray wheel. Of course I sharpen quicker and better now with a good grinder but you can certainly sharpen on a cheap grinder.

When I demonstrate with my foot powered lathe I have an old hand cranked grinder. I sharpen quite fine with it. It runs at about 200 to 500 rpm depending on the kid power I have to run it.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#14

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

Peter Hyde

>Funny you guys should bring this up. I was just reading the Oneway Wolverine Manual and here is what Oneway says:

Our recommended grinder

8" at 3450 RPM. This gives an optimum speed of 7225 surface feet per minute with a new wheel and an acceptable speed of 5740 sfpm with a wheel considered worn out at 6-1/2"

Why a 3450 Grinder?

Manufacturer recommended speed in surface feet per minute (sfpm) for grinding wheels is between 6000 and 8000 sfpm:-

6" at 3450rpm = 5419 sfpm

(at 1725 rpm=2709 sfpm - too slow)

8" at 3450 rpm = 7225 sfpm

(at 1725 rpm = 3612 sfpm - too slow

So sometimes I guess it pays to read the instructions

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#15

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

TDaniel

>I think you will find that the vast majority of turners prefer the lower 1750 rpm. A 3550 rpm grinder must be perfectly balanced as well as being a high quality grinder. A Baldor 8" grinder with balanced wheels running at 3550 is not the same as an import with its poor quality wheels and mounting plates. Unless you want to spend about $500 or more on a grinder you will be better off with a 1750 rpm.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#16

Re: Peter- you should also be....

Jamie Donaldson

>,,, aware of the fact that Oneway sells a lot of turning tools which we would be grinding shorter at a faster rate with a high speed grinder! I have for years preferred a 1750 rpm with a 120 white or blue wheel for "renewing the edge" on my gouges, but for a manufacturer who is rough shaping the criteria changes to removing metal at a much faster rate. Anything faster than 1800 rpm is not necessary and increases the safety hazards involved in the process, especially for a novice with what can be a very dangerous machine.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#17

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

RonZ

>I'm sorry but I think the information is wrong. Perhaps they recommend that to sell you more tools because your metal is being eaten away at 7225 surface feet per minute. You need much less than that for daily sharpening. Your wheel will fill up with metal sooner, too. I have a super slow 8" grinder and I'm very happy with it. One side benifit is it made a shorter learning curve for learning how to sharpen by hand.

BTW, Oneway recommends that you dip your HSS tools in water while sharpening. While true for carbon steel, that will ruin HSS. Turning supply manufacturers don't always know about turning.


img

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#18

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...because

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>as I said, " I can't sharpen anything to save my life." I'm just not good at it. :-) I 'm dead serious. I either mess up the angle, turn the steel blue or God knows what else. For a woodworker that's like not knowing what grain is. Bad analogy, but you get my point.

I stink at sharpening. I've tried and tried.

I appreciate your comments Jamie. Thanks.

Jack of all trades, master of none.

Ray

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#19

Re: Jamie's comments - 1 more thing

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>I was under the impression that the slower the grinder spins, the better. Everything I read follows this general rule. Maybe I need to read more. :-)

I do dip my tools in water frequently while attempting sharpening but I still screw things up.

Maybe I need to take a class in tool sharpening, if I could find one.

Believe me, I have no intentions of plunking down the money for a Tormek if what I have will do the job.

Thanks a lot Jamie, now I'm all confused. :-) Just kidding, I appreciate the advice.

Ray

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#20

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...

eliot d

>Ray,

Would you believe that I first heard of a hand cranked grinding wheel in a book by Krenov. His point was that a hand- powered wheel would not be intimidating to a beginner when sharpening a chisel. I actually went out and bought one and used it for a while. But I guess I "graduated" to a powered one. I like the idea of a hand -powered one , though.

Re: Tormek sharpening system opinions??

#21

Re: Ray- I don't understand why...because

eliot d

>Ray,

Wait a minute, wait a minute! Have you ever sharpened using a Wolverine system? It's practically foolproof. I promise you that you can do a great job easily with it. I have no affiliation with them. But there's practically nothing to it. Please try it and get back to us.