Need help buying Hollowing Tool
Warren Chernoff
>I'm a beginner and am looking at doing some hollow vessels. Which hollowing tools should I be buying. I'm looking to buy it just once, and one that will grow with me.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Need help buying Hollowing Tool
Warren Chernoff
>I'm a beginner and am looking at doing some hollow vessels. Which hollowing tools should I be buying. I'm looking to buy it just once, and one that will grow with me.
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool
Dick Hines
>I have the Kelton and the Jamieson. I use the Jameison more than the Kelton because it takes less effort. The Kelton I use if I am doing a deep hollow piece. If you get the Jumbo boreing bar from Jameison you can get 15"to 18" deep. I don't do pieces this deep ver often so I have not invested in the Jumbo bar.
With the tow systems I have best of both worlds.
Re: You will receive a vast range.....
Jamie Donaldson
>...of answers with this request, but if you really want to learn to hollow, the right way is the old fashioned Ellsworth way. I recommend the Sorby/Stewart armbrace handle and a set of John Jordan hollowing tools for the handle. You will learn the techniques and never outgrow the tools, yet not be swamped with all the gadgetry on the market today. I studied with David Ellsworth in 1990, and his techniques are still the same today.
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool
Barry Turner
>Instead of a once-and-for-all approach to hollowing, I decided to approach it incrementally. A cheap (well, fairly cheap) way to get into hollowing is with the Sorby Hollowmaster. Then, once I got a feel for the process of hollowing, I moved up to the 5/8" size of Kelton Hollowers. I may try the John Jordan tools next. I appreciate your wanting to buy only once and grow into the tools, but my way might be easier. You decide.
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool -contrary view
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>OK, I am going to be contrary here:
1) my first bought hollowing tool was a Sorby HollowMaster. I still use it for some fine inside finishing. But you would be hard pressed to use in with a top hole smaller than a inch and a half, as a beginner.
2) I have the Don Pencil Arm Brace copy of the Stewart system. It works great.
3) I made my first tools with Drill rod, in the Ellisworth style.
That said, I doubt that I will use them again (OK a little), because I started using captured systems. I have used the Elbo system, and I have a system system centered around a Jamison tool. I made my own secondary rests, use mostly Kelton hollowers in it, and have a homemade laser rig.
Buy a captured system that is simple, Like the elbo tool, Don Derry's system.
Here is why I say that:
1) Starting with the Ellisworth type tools or the Armbrace tools is about like deciding to take up rifle shooting, and being encouraged to start with a Matchlock, then the wheellock, flintlock, etc, etc. Learning Hollow turning need be some metaphysical event, where you get in touch with your inner hollow form.
2) Go Right to the modern hollowing tools. The take most of the frustration, danger, and fear out.
These tools are the reason that hollow forms are everywhere.
Mark
Re: You will receive a vast range.....
Eric
>I would have to agree. I also had the opportunity to study with Ellsworth back in June. Although his technique and selection of hollowing tools may be very basic, I still feel you should begin this way. The newer tools are definately easier to work with, especially the stabilized tools. So much so that you can essentially use one hand but the truly understand and appreciate the art of hollowing a deep vessel start with Ellsworth's tools. Woodcraft has them, or you can order directly from David Ellsworth, himself. Good luck.
I second that Mark!
Dick Hines
>
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool -contrary view
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Mark's advice is very well put! I learned the old fashioned way. But the truth be told, when it comes to hollowing, once you get the outside form done, the rest of it is just drudgery. And, with the feel along method, there can be a very steep learning curve, a curve which breaks those other curves you made into round firewood.
Additionally, captured systems are a whole lot less stressful on your own elbow and shoulder, something I appreciate a little more each year. I have a number of students who come to me for hollowing lessons. I have a wide range of tools to offer, from genuine Ellsworth style to Stewart to Kelton to my pride a joy, a laser guided, torque arrested, Monster Wood Tool rig. The hand held tools will go a little faster, but the MWT rig is the most accurate. We start with what they think they are going to afford, or what they want to do, but the MWT rig gets pulled out on a regular basis.
Bill
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool
Charles Watson
>Is there such a thing as buying once, maybe--if you try using the tools of other turners before purchasing your own, and know exactly what forms you will turn. By beginner, I assume you are new to turning. If that is the case, then I would suggest a captive system,
but be prepared to fiddle with it making adjustments.
If you want freedom in exploring different shapes, and to really get the feel of turning hollow forms, try the John Jordan hollowing tools and armbrace.
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool -contrary view
Gordon Seto
>Unless your signature is David Ellsworth, nobody cares how it was done.
Your ego to brag among your turning buddies is another matter.
A poorly finished HF in ugly shape done with the most challenging method is still not a master piece. The general public judge the final results of the whole piece. Only the woodturners give the priority to how it feels when they rub their fingers inside and how the bottom looks when they turn them over. But they are unlikely to collect your turnings if they have to pay anything close to the amount the non turners are willing to pay.
Gordon
Which monster tools?
JKJ in East TN
>Exactly which tools or set? On the web site I see MWL1, ML4 "+4 piece", MHS "hollowing system", MLD "deluxe", MLE "extreme", and MHS2 "system II". Can you share specific recommendations? Just go for the "II"?
JKJ
Proceed systematically *LINK*
Ed Moore
>Warren,
You identified yourself as a beginner and I must assume that as fact here. Then start with small hollow forms and perfect that technique before trying to hollow a log with a huge system. I have a Jamison rig with laser and it did fine when I used it. Recently I saw a demo and the presenter used a Don Derry rig. The simplicity of the Derry set-up convinced me that if I were to get back into hollowing I would immediately purchase the Derry rig with a laser and start over.
I just googled Start with smaller hollow forms. If you can't use Don Derry's system and get good results, then trying to do larger forms is a waste of your time and money.
Re: Need help buying Hollowing Tool
john lucas
>Wow some really good input on this subject. As someone who doesn't do a lot of hollow forms (at least big ones anyway) I switch back and forth between the captured bar systems and hand held. I do a lot of shapes that are more unusual and find the captured bar system is too restrictive for some shapes. I can use it but constantlly have to change hollowing bars or adjust the rear tool rest so I can reach those hard to reach areas.
With a hand held system I can don't change bars as often and can easily reach anywhere in the vessel. Measuring wall thickness takes me much longer because I have to stop and measure, but then you have to stop and blow out the shavings anyway.
I will agree with Bill G. The captured bar takes the "white knuckle" experience out of hollowing and with an attached lazar makes measuring the wall thickness a lot easier. It's not perfect, I cut through one the other day.
I like the John Jordan system because it's so simple and can easily be adapted to many of the captured bar rigs. The cutters are inexpensive and easy to replace and easy to modify if you feel you need to.
I think a lot has to do with the size vessel you do. I would not even attempt to do a vessel the size and thin wall thickness that Frank Sudol was known for without a captured bar system. On the other hand vessels under 6" are very quick to do by hand. It's those from 6 to 12 or 15 that are slow to do by hand and much easier to do with a captured bar.
My take...
keith zimmerman, Normal, IL
>I have been working off and on at hollowing for a couple of years now and decided after doing my first piece that I would work small and learn how the wood feels with the tool against the wood. I think I am progressing adequately in this manner.
The first tool I bought was the Sorby Multi-tip Shear Scraper and it worked quite well. Then I bought two sizes of Sorby swan-neck hollowers and found them very difficult to control due to torque. I tried some Keltons and loved them so I bought a set of minis and 1/2". I use the minis in their handle and the 1/2" in a Don Pencil armbrace. I can get 4-5" deep with that setup.
When I decide to go deeper than 4-5", I may look into a captured setup, but first, I want to understand how the wood reacts and feels with each of the cutters I have.
My thoughts.
keith
Re: My take...
Warren Chernoff
>thanks for all the info guys. There is so much info out there, that I'm still confused. I have turned a few goblets already, using gouges and scrapers and thought it was okay, but figured there was an easier way. Any video I watch (like the pro-forme hollower), makes it look so easy. As I mentioned before, I don't want to buy one set of beginner tools only to find they aren't what I need. I would like to turn anything from goblets (minature and regular) to 10-12" vases,and everything in between. That Don Derry setup looks interesting. Don't know if I want the hands on approach by turning using tools like the Keltons, but not sure either of the captive system as it looks too mechanical and not enough hands on. As I mentioned before, I guess I'm still confused
Re: My take...
eliot d
>There's something wrong. You shouldn't get axial "torque" problems with a swan neck tool so long as you support the tool BEHIND the curve of the swan shape. That's the whole idea behind the swan neck design. The axial torque is defined as force multiplied times the length of the radius arm. So if the tip of the cutting edge is in line with the axis of the tool handle, there is NO axial torque. You certainly can get torque about an axis perpendicular to the tool shaft but not about the axis of the tool shaft. But this kind of torque shouldn't be worse than what you would get with a similar straight tool.
Re: Eliot, I think his torque may
Allen Neighbors
>come from just a bad position inside the form...
I have been having a heck of a time for about 5 months with my home-made swans and also from my Don Pencil swan neck, too. Been fighting like crazy to keep the torque from causing dig-ins. I made sure the curve of the shaft was beyond the toolrest, and the cutting tip was in line with the handle, and I was still having trouble. It wasn't the torque... it was bad technique. (what? me?)
I discovered it was my positioning inside the form that was causing all the trouble. I was allowing the cutting tip to be pointed in an 'upward' position, and even though I was cutting on center, I would get digs (catches, if you prefer). Duh! When it finally dawned on me I felt so stupid.
When I began making sure the cutting tip is lower than the shank, I quit getting the catches.
Re: Eliot, I think his torque may
eliot d
>Allen,
I learned from no less an authority than David Ellsworth that he prefers a tool that is NOT swan necked -- i.e. a cutter sticking out at about a 45 degree angle from a straight shaft -- precisely because, if you get a catch, the tool will swing down and harmlessly get out of the way. Whereas, swan neck and other constrained tools, after a catch, have no place to go but into the wood, thereby, possibly ruining a thin-walled vessel. But, you're right, his idea depends on the cutting edge pointing a little bit down -- not up into the wood.