Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

drying green wood

Posts

drying green wood

#1

drying green wood

ken chase

>I just purchased some green silver maple and box elder. I live in Palm Desert Ca. which is desert, dry and hot. I'm storing in my shop which is air conditioned and won't get more than about 88 degrees. I was advised to place the wood in paper bags then in plastic. I chose to

seal all six sides of the blanks I cut. Do I still need to bag in plastic? Or is sealing protection enough?

Thanks

Ken

Re: drying green wood

#2

Re: drying green wood

Fog Tanner

>Ken,

I live in Texas, in the coastal area, where we have some heat and humidity. I used to not use anything except paper bags. I had three walnut bowls split in the bags, which may or may not be usable. I had a dozen more elm roughed out bowls in a cardboard box with shavings in it, didn't loose a one. After a few days of low humidity last fall (we ony have 3 days of winter here), I encountered some splits in a roughed out bowl in a bag. Since then I have started coating everything with end grain sealer and not had any problems. I still use the bags just to keep some of the loose bowls together.

If you talk to Mike Mahoney, he coats roughed out bowls as soon as they come off the lathe. His environemnt is closer to yours as far as humidity goes. He will get splits if he doesn't take care of them quickly. I am more into the one hour window, buring blanks in shavings as I core them and coating them all at one time after each blank. I think you may have some of the same issues even though you are ariconditioned, as you also have less humidity along with that.

Re: drying green wood

#3

Re: drying green wood

Barry Irby

>I agree with everything Fog said And.....

I have a friend who just got into turning. He has the analytical sort of scientific mind. He took a bowl blank and quartered it (yikes) and put one quarter in a single brown paper bag, one in a doubled bag, and one in a plastic bag. The other was his "control". He weighed them periodically. The ones in the paper bags dried almost identically to the control. The one in the plastic bag hardly dried at all. I don't remember all the details (there were lots of details) and we are in humid south-side VA. His solution was to take a plastic bag and use a hole punch to put a fairly significant number of holes in it and that let the blanks dry slowly.

I would say in your climate the Sealing would be a good idea. I doubt paper bags will do much for you except help organize things. You might try big plastic "Tupperware" type boxes with loose lids and remove the lids for a little while each day until they are dry or try the hole punched plastic bags. If I leave green blanks in sealed plastic bags, they spalt and then rot.

There is more going on than just removing the moisture. the goal is to remove it evenly. Not letting the end grain parts race ahead and dry faster and split. It might be that the bags help with that a little even if they don't retard drying much.

Locally, AC pulls ten to twenty gallons of water a day out of a typical small house. If you are in a very dry climate, you may just get the cooling without the humidification. Yours may cool and filter while ours cool, filter, and dehumidify, hence the name "Air Conditioner". Wonder if reducing the temperature would actually raise the RH in a dry climate?

Re: drying green wood

#4

Re: drying green wood

GaryG in MD

>Hi Ken,

Fog and Barry have given you some very good advice. Let me add my experience FWIW, since I'm having problems that you may be able to learn from.

I live in Maryland, and it is what I would call "temperate" -- neither super hot or wet or dry -- just kind of average.

I believe that in your post, you were asking about hunks of wood (rounds or half rounds), not roughly turned bowl blanks. The problems are similar, but much worse with the hunks. Very simply, I believe most people will tell you to rough them out on the lathe as quickly as you can. That would certainly be my reco, based on my most recent experience; to wit:

Tree cutters came into our neighborhood a couple months ago and cut down a number of large trees. I don't like it, but they did, so I figured I might as well get some pieces rather than let them go to the chipper. First I made the mistake of not being able to chain saw all of them immediately, and I put some into plastic bags. Wrong!

Rule #1: NEVER put wood in plastic bags!!! I immediately started getting black rot, and that's very hard to get rid of once you get it (see Archive posts on bleach, boiling, etc.) I don't think it would be any different for you in your dry climate -- freshly cut, green wood has a lot of moisture in it, and if you keep the moisture in, it will probably start to mold/mildew/rot within a couple days.

I was planning to leave on vacation shortly thereafter, so there was no way I could rough it all on the lathe. I did my best, but I ended up with quite a few half rounds left over. I had carefully removed the pith and cut them into octogons with the chain saw, and waxed them all with Anchorseal or it's generic equivalent. I put them on stickers inside my house, in a dark room, to keep the temperature/humidity well controlled while I was gone. I thought I had done a good job and that these blanks would dry slowly enough for me to be able to rough them at a reasonable pace when I returned. WRONG!

Yesterday, I was forced to move all of these hunks out of the house because my wife and visitors were complaining/commenting about the fact that the whole basement smelled musty. Upon closer examination, I found that the largest percentage of them were either cracked (all 5 birch), black with rot (9 silver maple), or cracked and black with rot (7 our of 8 red oak and 4 silver maple). Needless to say, I am quite unhappy. FWIW, I have had better luck with black cherry, altho I also found 5 of them cracking.

What I have learned from this experience is that even if you try really hard to do the right thing, it is very difficult to keep unturned hunks of wood around for more than a few days as chainsawed, sized half rounds. You really have to leave it in log form and let the pith cracks take the ends or turn your bowl blanks. I have had much better luck drying bowl blanks, so I was really surprised with my poor results here now. I stacked them all outside in the shade and plan to do some serious roughing and see what I can salvage, altho it's depressing.

Your mileage may vary.

Good luck, Gary

Re: drying green wood

#5

Re: drying green wood

john lucas

>Ken I have a problem not being able to rough turn all the wood I get. I lose a lot. I agree about the plastic bags. They are great for storing wood for a few days but much more than that and you get mold. The same is true storing the bowls in shavings.

I've tried sawing them up into blanks, sealing them with anchorseal and putting them in the corner of my shop. I still lose a lot of those.

I've had my best luck with leaving the logs as long as possible. If the logs have already been cut short, which I have to do to get logs in my truck by myself, then I split them at the heart. I coat these with anchorseal as soon as possible. On cherry I coat it as soon as I saw it. I've had amazingly big checks in cherry after driving 30 minutes home without the anchorseal.

Some woods are simply easier. I didn't do anything to a walnut log that was 6 feet long and sat in the yard for a year. I just turned it and got some really good pieces out of it. The same with Hickory. Cherry, and apple are cracked horribly after just a month.

I try to monitor my wood pile. If they are getting some pretty big checks I cut them through the check. Then I bandsaw them into the biggest squares I can get. 5x5, 4x4 3x3 2x2 etc.and as long as the log. I put these on a low shelf and dry them. I'll them for smaller projects later on. Occasionally I'll saw a log up into planks and try to save these for platters. I don't do that often because my saw is simply too small to do that.

Re: drying green wood

#6

Dick Hines

Re: drying green wood

Dick Hines

>I don't live far from Barry so my weather comditions are the same. I rough turn all my bowls and soak them over night in denatured alcohol. After a night in the bath I let them drain back in the vat on DNa, at 1$15 a gal I like to save all I can. When I get home from work I will wrap them in paper and cut the inside of the bag out.

The roughed bowls go in the back of my shop on the floor, tho collest place I have.In 30 days they are raedy to return.

Re: drying green wood

#7

Re: drying green wood

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Ken:

Just keep in mind you are not trying to seal up the wood and stop the moisture release.. All you want to do is slow down and even out the drying process. I have found no no magic formula that always works because the are so many variables with wood species, time of year etc. Do some experimenting with expendible wood and find what works for you.

Re: drying green wood

#8

Re: drying green wood

RonZ

>Hi Ken,

I live near Jerusalem, Israel so I think our weather patterns are similar. =o)

I store logs, half logs, and roughed out bowls. The main wood that I store is dalbergia, rosewood from Israel, as it is the most stable. Hard as hell, but stable. For the logs and half logs I use what is called polygag. It is a roof sealer and does the job but even white glue with a 50/50 mix with water will work. Only put it on the end grain. Wood grain is like a straw so you want to cover the end grain [like the end of the straw] to keep the moisture going out too fast.

You're in the US so I would use a woodsealer that is available from Woodcraft that is an emulsified wax. We have nothing like that here so I broke down and shipped a bottle here. It's really the best so I use it only on my roughed out bowls which I cover completly. I date them and usually wait about 6 months before turning them to finish.

Re: drying green wood

#9

Re: drying green wood

jeff f., columbia, MO

>Ken,

I use nothing but large plastic garbage bags to store half-log blanks cut with the chainsaw, and then again to store the bandsawed rounds. I have turned probably 500-1000 bowls this way anywhere from 10-19" in diameter and almost every major species of domestic wood (many maples, oaks, walnut, ash, locust, fruitwoods, cottonwood, sycamore, russian olive, elms,...). Yes, there will be some mold, but usually this only adds color or even nice spalting to the wood.

In a post a few weeks ago (it might not have been on wood central) someone commented that they would never store wood in plastic because it might discolor the wood, and they would never sell a bowl that had been tainted by rot or spalting. To me that was like saying we should only drink milk instead of eating that rotten milk called cheese.

I have had blanks sit in the plastic bags for many months and they do grow mold, but I don't mind at all. I guess what it comes down to is that I would rather have spalting and color in my wood that checks...not a tough decision for me.

Good luck,

Jeff

Re: drying green wood

#10

Re: drying green wood

Bill Hale

>Ken

I do the major amount of my turning in Casa Grande, AZ. where it is very dry. When I get my logs I generaly get them in pieces a little longer than their diameter. I split them and move them in to plastic bags. As soon as I can I do my rough outs.

This is where I differ from most others. I put the roughouts into large plastic tubs, from Walmart, with lids on. Then every day or so I open the tub and let it dry out for an hour or so and back on with the lid. After a couple of weeks of this I start inspecting each piece for cracking and use CA to stop it. Generally this process takes about 4 months to finish drying. At the and of the cycle you can leave the tubs open longer.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Show Low, AZ

Re: drying green wood

#11

Re: drying green wood

Allen Neighbors

>Ken, I live in NW Texas... hot, dry, summers. My shop has open eaves and a swamp cooler. I have a couple of old refrigerators that I have modified into what I call 'kilns' (for lack of a better word).

I drilled 10-12 1/2" holes in the bottom and top of each. I put a 60 watt light in the bottom, and a fan in the top. The fan just circulates the air in the kiln... it doesn't exhaust it.

When I get green wood, I blank it out, and coat the end grain with anchor seal inside and out, and put it in the kiln. Just to keep it 'til I can rough turn it. After rough-turning, I soak in LDD for 30 days or so (the longer soak time works better where I live). After it drips dry for a couple of hours, I put it in the kiln. I turn on the light for about 8 hours a day, for a week. Then I turn on the light and fan for about 8 hours a day for another week. Then I turn on just the fan for about 8 hours a day for a week, and they are usually dry by then, to turn. (These hours on and off vary quite a bit, because I'm a volunteer firefighter, and also run on auto accidents. I get very little cracking. I've experimented with several different times in the soap soak, and this combination of events works best for me.

Hope it gives you some ideas.

Re: drying green wood

#12

Re: drying green wood

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Ken,

Success in keeping turning blanks depends entirely upon how much you stress the wood. A given set of temperature and humidity readings in the space where you store your wood will equal a particular Equilibrium Moisture Content once the wood stays in those conditions for a sufficient time period. You can find a chart that shows that relationship at www.furniturecarver.com/emc.html if Lee Grindinger still has the chart on his website. If not, I'll send you a copy.

For the conditions you describe, perhaps 88 degrees and maybe 50% relative humidity (in reality, probably much less,) the EMC is close to 9%. Now, if your wood is fresh cut, you are probably looking at a Moisture Content of near 70%. You can see how much stress you are putting on the wood when you put it in the conditions you describe. If, on the other hand, you could boost the humidity to 92%, then the EMC becomes 20 or so, and the subsequent stress is cut substantially.

Coating the blanks all over is a good strategy, I think. I remember talking to the LumberLady some years back about selling her some green wood and she wanted it coated in yellow glue. She had lots of problems with wood cracking in AZ.

At this point, I would just pay close attention to your blanks, maybe look at them several times during the day. If you see some checks starting to develop, you can always stick them in a plastic bag to slow things down.

All of our strategies on dealing with green wood are designed to slow down the loss of moisture and consequently cut down on the stress that the wood is trying to deal with. I've found silver maple and box elder both to be quite stable if you don't overstress them.

Good luck.

Gary