Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Gouge question

Posts

Gouge question

#1

Gouge question

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>What is the difference between a bowl gouge and a spindle gouge?

Re: Gouge question

#2

Re: Gouge question *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Mostly, the depth of the flute. Modern American style spindle gouges have a shallow flute, with a thick bottome section. Bowl gouges have a deep flute.

If you go to this web page, and click on the pictures, you can see the differences. On the Home Page, there are five gouges, and the left two are bowl gouges.

Mark


Doug Thompson Lathe Tools

Re: Gouge question

#3

Re: Gouge question

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>Thanks for the info. Another question then, I am looking for a new spindle gouge. I do mostly between centers turning, but I found a bowl gouge for about the same price as a spindle gouge, but the length of the cutter end of the tool is much longer for about the same price. Will it work the same for spindle turning?

Re: Gouge question

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: Gouge question

Ric Taylor

>Tim,

When you say you turn mostly between centers, I'm assuming you mean spindle turning. Some people do some parts of bowl turning between centers also.

If you're referring to spindle turning, and you have to choose between the two gouges, then the spindle gouge is the way to go. The bowl gouge is more useful for when you are using a faceplate or a bowl-shaped hunk of wood mounted in a chuck.

Ric

Re: Gouge question

#5

Re: Gouge question

Gordon Seto

>The longer the flute, the more steel was milled away; the less the tool can extend beyond the tool rest (hollowing deep) without vibration, chattering.

I really like Doug's detail gouges, very solid tool and hold the edge well. The shallow detail gouge has the strongest shaft. The spindle gouge has wider flute and gives easier control on long sweeping curve. His spindle/detail gouge is a good compromise.

Win some and lose some. The best all around tool has not been invented yet.

Gordon