Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

orientation question

Posts

orientation question

#1

orientation question

David Breth

>My sister saw something at a craft show that I thought I would make for her and for my wife, but I'm having trouble deciding the orientation.

Don't have a photo, but it is pretty simple to describe. Picture a mushroom. On the edge of the mushroom, drill holes all the way around it so you can hang ear rings off of it. Make a lidded top for it so you can store jewelry trinkets inside. You are done.

I'm torn between going end grain or side, because I'm not sure which orientation will have the strongest side to hang the ear rings. Admittedly, those don't weigh a lot, but of course, anything is subject to taking a dinger off the edge of a table, etc.

I would appreciate your thoughts -

David B.

Re: orientation question

#2

most likely......

TDaniel

>was an end-grain turning. It could be turned from green wood but a good fit with the lid will be impossible unless you give it a year or so to dry before finish turning.

Re: orientation question

#3

Re: orientation question

JKJ in East TN

>>...Picture a mushroom. ... Make a lidded top for it

>so you can store jewelry trinkets inside.

Most lidded boxes are made with endgrain orientation, the grain running down the long axis. This helps the lid to fit better as the wood moves with the seasons since the radial expansion/shrinkage for most wood is less than the tangential. Side grain turnings tend to go more out of round even if the wood is properly dried. Of course, if the lid is loosely fitting, it won't matter as much and either orientation will work. In that case, the figure of the chunk of wood might suggest the orientation that will look the best.

I wouldn't worry the least bit about the strength. Even balsa wood would be strong enough for earrings. As far as withstanding dings, either orientation would be vulnerable.

JKJ

Re: orientation question

#4

Re: orientation question

john lucas

>I agree 100 percent with TD and JKJ. End grain works best for boxes and the earing weight won't a problem. I saw plans for one of these earing stands somewhere but I can't remember where. It's probably in one of my books. I think it might be in a Richard Raffen book.

Re: orientation question

#5

Re: orientation question

David Breth

>Thanks very much for the responses. I appreciate it. I'll go endgrain with it -

David B.

Re: orientation question

#6

Steven Antonucci

There one in the Craft Supplies catalog

steve antonucci

>It's end grain if that helps. It's a woman in a hat and the frills are where the earrings hang.

Steven

Re: orientation question

#7

Re: There one in the Craft Supplies catalog

David Breth

>I've seen that many times, but never realized what it was!