Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

Posts

Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#1

Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

Atwerz

>Going to buy one first,.. then 3-4 months later buy the other. Question is which would you prefer first if you had a choice? Focusing on the Jet 2000 air filteration unit and the Jet 2 hp dust collector system but checking all brands. Tools Jet 1442 lathe, Powermatic 3hp ts, Jet 18 in. bandsaw, Craftsman 12 in. RAS, Craftsman 12 in. mitre saw, DW 12 1/2 planer, and a lot of sanding. All are used a lot weekly. A lot of stuff in the air and on the floor. Dust masks worn all the time but this equipment is needed. Your opinions and comments appreciated.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#2

DC First...

Peter Teubel

>A good DC will grab the majority of the shavings and dust from the source. The air filter just cleans the air from what the DC missed.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#3

Air Filtration

jwoodwright

>The dust does the greatest damage to your Lungs. A Shop Vac will suck up chips and sawdust and with the correct bag, fine sanding dust. A Shop Vac is limited, especially when connected to a Jointer or Planer...

The Fine sanding dust is the problem, it is inhaled.

To prove this, wipe down all machines in your shop. Then, do some serious sanding. Next morning, when the dust has settled, you'll see dust coating all machines.

I use a Dust Collector whenever a machine is running. The Air Filtration has a timer, stays on after I leave the shop.

I also us a Shop Vac (18 Gal) and Drywall Bag Insert to capture the Fine sanding dust. The addition of the bag makes the vac stronger, as the filter doesn't clog up.

Really want a Cyclone system, that would be best...

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#4

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first *LINK*

eaglesc

>Bill Pentz has done more research on this subject than anyone else I have seen.

Take a look at his web site.

AS far as D.C.'s go the unit from harbor freight gets great reviews for the best bang for your buck among many woodworkers.


http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/Index.cfm

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#5

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first

Barry Irby

>This is a good question. I agree that the part of the dust we really want to collect is the very fine stuff that tends to hang in the air long enough for us to inhale it. The rest of it falls out as debris and Is messy, but not really dangerous to your lungs.

So, most DC's tend to get most of the larger particles. More off some machines than others and we can chase the effectiveness of them at getting the alrge stuff round and round. But the real question is how much of the really fine stuff do they get?

This is the part of the equasion I missed. I put in the DC first and still have only a homemade Air cleaner. Read on Bill Pentz's site aobut the "sphere of influance" or whatever he calls it. The idea is that you want a sigificant aomunt of air flowing toward the machine sucking in as many of the "fines" as you can. This is really capturing them at the source, not allowing them to become randomly airborne and entering your lungs.

The controversy about an Ambient air cleaner (AAC)is that in order to capture the particles it has to keep the air moving and provide enough energy to keep the fine particles flying so they will make it to the filter. It might be better for your lungs if they fell out of the air immediately and were no longer available to be inhaled. So lettign them fall out might increase your house keeping, but might be healther. Unless you snort them up when you clean up.

A controversy about DC's is that they have to filter out the really fine stuff or you just throw it back into the air. A bad sustem might actually be more harmfull to you than no system. One answer to that is to exhaust the system out doors, but then you lose the heat and AC.

Running an Air cleaner seems "obvious". You can actually see the dust it took out of the air. And Lord knows my DC fills up often enough, but the problem is that the really harmful stuff is too small to see (I think) while it is floating in the air.

I put in the DC first, followed by the AAC, and it "seems" much better. I wonder if I just knocked out the grossest stuff allowing me to be happy in shop long enough to inhale plenty of the really fine stuff?

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#6

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first

Larry Bisbee

>I think you will find the dust collector does collect a lot of dust and you can see that when you check the air filter after using it, but it doesn't collect all of the airbound dust. I have both the Jet air filtration system and dust collector, but I also have a Trend Airshield, and use all three. Just checking the Trend Airshield air filter after it's use will show just how much dust you would breath into your lungs without the use of an airshield/respirator system. An airshield/respirator system would be my first choice, than the dust collector, and last would be the air filtration system.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#7

Trend or Triton Respirator

Ron in Drums PA

>I think a personal respirator would be your best bet. Followed by a DC.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#8

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first

TDaniel

>Before buying anything check the micron level of each unit. Some of the bag collectors don't trap anything under 5 micron. Until I converted mine to a cannistor filter I could see a cloud of dust when I turned the "dust collector" on. If you can find, one Trend makes a mask called an "Ace" that filters to .3 micron and does not require a battery pack; cost is about $80, and it does not fog your glasses. It works great as long as you keep it on but I like to remove mine fairly often so I have a JDS filtration unit hanging overhead which cleans the floating dust. I think the JDS is worth the extra few bucks because it has a washable pre-filter. As far as the dust collectors go, they do capture a lot of dust and debris at the source but unless it is in another room there will be a lot of fine dust that comes through the bag and back into your work area. The big value of the dust collector is that it makes mchines like the planer work so much better by keeping the feed rollers clean. So to answer your question:

If I did a lot of woodworking where I used a planer, a tablesaw, and a bandsaw I would start with a wearable mask and a DC unit and add the filtration unit later (but not much later). If I mostly used the lathe I would go for the filter first.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#9

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first

wilbur

>You really need both.

But, if you have to get one at a time, what I would do is get the air cleaner, and use a shop vac with a HEPA filter to deal with the dust on the floor until you get your dust collector.

This is coming from someone who installed his dust collector first.

Also, if you can vent air to the outside, that would be the best way of all to deal with dust, even if it's something as simple as opening a window and putting a box fan in it to blow air outside.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#10

Thanks for the responses

Jimmy Edwards

>The dust issue seems to be the most important issue for woodworker/woodturners, and the most ignored, so I want to get it right as possible. Your responses are invaluable. Going to read everything on Bill Pentz site first.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#11

Re: Thanks for the responses

eaglesc

>1.

If you read everything on Bills site you'll never have time to get the D.C.

2.

I have installed dust collections in cotton mills.

There are no AAC's.Those are just a gimick to get you to spend your money on another foolish gadget.

If the filter in an AAC is dirty, you have already breathed in the dust laden air.

3.

None of the employees in the cotton mills wear anything like a Triton personal air shield.The DC system gets it at the source.I think OSHA (Occasional Search and Harrassment Association) had something to say about that.

If the concept of an AAC was so good there would be no need for a D.C. at all.

Waste your money however you choose.

BTW what type of filter do you use in your home heating or cooling unit?

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#12

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first

Fog Tanner

>I bought a Jet bag unit for some hand sanding, which is all it is really good for. For my powered things like the lathe, I have a 2 hp Onedia cyclone unit. It is good for the submicron level. This is the particle size that will pass through your nose and into your lungs. Baiscly if you can see the particles floating in the air, your body will stop them.

I have a dust hood for my lathe which actually works. It was modeled after one of Raffan's versions. I can see the dust comming off the gouge stratight back into the collection port. This is most of the dust comming off the machine. I am not concerned about the larger shavings being picked up as I can't breathe them. When I am turning dry wood, the dust collector is running. You can get more dust off the gouge than some of the sanding.

For a secondary filtration (or primary depending on point of view), you might want to look at an Airstream. I have a Powervisor which is much like the Trend, with the same filtration level. There is no comparison in the two types. I was turning some Aromatic Cedar a few weeks ago and all I could tell was it was red. It wasn't until I took the helmet off that I could smell the wood. I am allergic to it, so I would have known a lot sooner without the Airstream. The Airstream also puts the collection point a lot closer to the source and ensures the air passing into your lungs is dust free.

Neither of the units was cheap, but I had dust induced sinus headaches which caused me three days lost work each time. In six months I could have paid for both units a couple of times, my regret is not having bought them a couple of years earlier. Especially when I bought the Powervisor because I didn't want to spend the money on the Airstream - just upped the cost.

Re: Air filtration/Dust collection-buy which first?

#13

Air Quality - My Take - long

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I may be repeating myself, but forgive me.

About 3 months ago, it came time for me to close the doors and windows in the shop, and run the Air Conditioning. The day I did, I remembered that last year, the coils of the AC got clogged up when dust collected on moist condenser coils. So, to forstall this, I taped a really good flat air filter to the intake of the AC.

4-6 hours later, that filter was fairly dark with dust - and I had not been working in the shop for the 12 hours before I put the filter on, nor for the 4-6 hours after (working in the yard. This was dust that was so continuing to float in the air, basically days after working in the shop. Ask anyone that has been in my shop, I keep a very clean shop (type A, sorta OCD, and don't want dust/chips in my segmented turning joints). Plus, last year I developed an allergy to Ebony, and it sensitized me to many other woods.

This got me thinking about about air cleaners. Then I started thinking that if I was going to spend $400 for each good air cleaner, maybe my money would be better spent elsewhere.

I started an extended email conversation with Bill Pentz. Bill convinced me that

1) Most Dust Colectors are really chip collectors and dust pumps. They pull out the chunks (including the bigger dust particles, and then pump the really dangerous stuff back into the air (if they got it in the first place). I used my DC a lot, and it is another, not connected) room, and my shop was still filled with dust.

2) Air Cleaners are great for making the shop seem clean (no dust on the shelves and benches), but they cannot cycle air quickly enough to keep the really dangerous stuff out of you lungs. Bill told me of guy that installed a new cyclone in is shop, but had not sealed everything nor fine tuned the drops, yet. Bill was there and they fired up his TS and cut some wood. Even with DC running, it took less than a minute for the air tester they were using to show higher than OSHA allowed dust levels in the shop (this was a double car garage shop, and Bill had to bail because of his resperatory problems. They opened the doors (including the car entrance doors, and put big fans in the exits. They calculated that they were exchanging the air in the shop more than 10 TIMES A MINUTE (I think he said more than that, but I forgot the figure), and it took 20 minutes for the air to return to sub-OSHA standards. Air cleaners are usually set to cycle the air in your shop maybe once a minute or two.

3) Respirators are a good idea. I would even recommend that you wear one. But as my shop example shows, with a respirator you are cutting down on your exposure while you are wearing it, but if you are not capturing the dust at the source with a good DC system, you are just postponing the intake of the superfine dust until you take the respirator off. Unless of course, you put it on before enter the shop, and where it until you leave.

In the end, I decided that what I was willing to do was 1) Upgrade the quality (suction and filtration) of my DC to get what dust I can at the source, and then live with what I cannot capture - while continuing to improve the system.

I decided to replace my 1.5hp Grizzley Cartridge filter DC, with a 1800CFM ClearVue cyclone. I trust Bill's research, so I trusted his recommendations as well. Ed at ClearVue was very helpful with everything. In fact I went to Ed's house/shop when I was up that way about 8 weeks ago. he uses his own system of course - have you ever seen a shop that could have a computer in the shop - a shop that does CNC routing on MDF, that does not have dust on the computer screen? I have now.

Anyway, right now I have the cyclone - and it sucks like a son of a gun. I dropped a 3" jet faceplate next to the DC hose - and it sucked it in 10 feet. It could not quite lift it up 6 feet into the ducting, but..... I am slowly exchanging out my 4" ducting for 6" everywhere right to the machine. I have an old Craftsman TS that I sealed up decently, and now with the DC it is spotless after cutting anything. Some dust still escapes from the back of the blade contact with the wood, but I will be fixing that with an overarm guard/dust port system.

One thing I noticed, I have to empty the DC collection bin faster than I used to - more dust is ending up there. Also, with the better filtration, the room where the Cyclone is, is virtually dust free.

My allergies bug me a good deal less, and I am not working with exotics any less.

Just my experience folks. Take it for what it is worth.

Last Comments:

1) Please read and research completely before sending questions to Bill.

2) Many of us have used/read Bill Pentz's Dust Collection website for years - in my case many years. Most of us don't know that Bill is disabled. He does make a little from royalties that ClearVue pays on every cyclone sale, but no one else that is using his research, and it does not cover his expenses. Read the summary in his DC page, and you can see how to contribute.

Mark