Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

hollowing with a punky tenon

Posts

hollowing with a punky tenon

#1

hollowing with a punky tenon

john lucas

>I mentioned the other day that one of the Box elder vessels I was hollowing for my friend, came off the lathe with a broken tenon. The wood was punky on the bottom end. I cut it down to get rid of the broken tenon but it was still pretty soft.

I soaked it with CA glue and then put 4 short screws in the bottom. It still wanted to chatter because the wood was so soft. I put a homemade steady rest on and was able to hollow this 10" vessel to 3/8" thickness.

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#2

Steven Antonucci

Somedays, you just have to try new things

steve antonucci

>I have a piece of maple that is punky throughout, but it costs me nothing to try. Have you tried soaking it in the stuff they sell as wood hardener? That's on my list of things to try.

Steve

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#3

Ric Taylor

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

Ric Taylor

>Steve,

Minwax makes a wood hardner (it's in a yellow can) that works well in making punky wood stiff enough to get clean cuts with turning tools, but I wouldn't assume that it is strong enough to reinforce a tennon. One of it's advantages is that it dries quickly.

It must be used with great caution because it is extremely flamable. Use only in very well-ventilated spaces.

Ric

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#4

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I don't think Minwax wood hardener should be trusted to harden a tenon. It doesn't soak in deep enough to be dependable.

I have used it to turn punky wood, but had to apply the stuff several times as I found it only soaked in about an 1/8". Make sure it is used in a well ventilated area.

keith

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#5

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

john lucas

>Keith that's what worried me about the thin CA. I thought it soaked in pretty good but I was afraid to trust it and this piece of wood was one of three and I had to make 3 pieces. No turning back. Had to find a solution. I thought about wooden dowels glued in but decided I could give up the total length of the piece and not hurt it's looks.

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#6

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

Jorge Castaneda

>Steve,

I've tried the wood hardener, expensive, 10 bucks or so for a rather small can, the stuff is runny and on end grain just goes to the other side of the bowl, it improves the wood some but it is not a great imrovement. Reading the current tread about diluting epoxie, that may be the way to go and more economical.

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#7

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I've tried CA myself, same results. I've tried other glues also and have found it to be almost impossible to harden a tenon hard enough.

I've wound up sacrificing some wood to get to firm enough wood several times.

Better to be safe than sorry.

keith

Re: hollowing with a punky tenon

#8

Re: Somedays, you just have to try new things

Joe Flemig

>John,

I've used thin CA with success. It is important, however, that you do not use an accelerator on it. I chuck these pieces, and then glue the piece onto the chuck jaws too. The mechanical leverage of the chuck will break the CA bond when finished and you can scrape off the excess.

Joe Fleming - San Diego