Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Using different glues on segemented turnings?

Posts

Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#1

Using different glues on segemented turnings?

Ron in Drums PA

>Your thoughts on using different glues on a single segemented project.

I'm in the planning stages of a new segmented piece. The main part of the project will be wood and copper. After some experimenting, I found Systems 3 Quik Cure epoxy worked the best with the way I do glue ups.

I'd like to use yellow glue to assemble the feature ring and to attach the ring to the body.

Grain orientation aside, do you see any problems mixing glues this way?

TIA

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#2

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

eaglesc

>the "feature ring" you speak of, is that the copper piece?

I KNOW you are not contemplating bonding the copper with yellow glue, right?

I have had miserable results bonding anything with epoxy but realize others love it.

For me its' usually thick CA all the way!

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#3

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

Stuart Johnson

>Ron, I don't think it should make any difference but it wouldn't hurt to glue up a sample or two just to be certain.

If you have time try and take some photos as you go along. I have tried using copper from time to time and not had any luck. My next attempt is to try using it as vertical spacers instead of veneer. I'll glue the ring together using epoxy and yellow glue for ring attachment. The spacers will have very little holding strength but the ring alignment will still be strong. (I hope)

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#4

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

Ron in Drums PA

>The feature ring is all wood (at this time). All metal to wood joints will be epoxy.

After you and I spoke on the phone a month or so ago, I tried to turn a xmas bulb with CA, copper and maple. CA couldn't withstand the hollowing process. Epoxy work best. I like to turn the bulbs thin to reduce as much weight as possible so the ornament doesn't cause the branch to droop.

CA works well on segmented pens because you have a brass tube to support everything. With a hollow bulb I don't have that luxury.

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#5

My concern is wood movement.

Ron in Drums PA

>The form is copper and quarter sawn wood held together with epoxy. The result will be very little wood movement. In fact the epxoy and copper will prevent movement, that's why I chose quarter sawn wood.

The feature band (at this time) is all wood and will be held together with yellow glue. This combination allows wood movement. Epoxy is just to tedious to use for the design I have in mind. CA is just to brittle.

Having a secetion that allows wood movement sandwiched between to sections that inhibits wood movement is what I'm concerned about.

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#6

Re: My concern is wood movement.

Peter Hyde

>I spent about 3 years doing a rebuild on a very large trimaran. The owner used West system epoxy and purchased the big manual for their system. We used epoxy to bond stainless to marine ply in some very stressed areas. Following the recommended proceedure we had no failures. Basically you "wet out" the metal by rubbing the mixed epoxy into the suface using 100 grit wet and dry paper. Make sure the whole bonding area is thoroughly scuffed with the epoxy and allow to become tacky. Apply second coat normally with a spatula or spreader and then use moderate clamping pressure to hold the metal and wood together until set. The wood should also be wetted out and allowed to dry before bonding. Always take the precaution of removing the wax bloom from the dried epoxy wetting coat with a white vinegar wash using nylon scouring pads, followed by a thorough rinsing with clean water and allow to dry. I know this all sounds complicated but it worked for us and we never had a failure even with the chain plates on the hull that take all the strain from the mast rigging. Doing interior trim work we used regular yellow glue for all the cabinetry. It was all coated with epoxy then sanded and varnished. Again no problems. We only used the West System for the whole project. What other epoxies behave like I have no idea.

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#7

Re: My concern is wood movement.

eaglesc

>I don't know what you mean by CA being "too brittle"

I have read that remark before and found it to be basically a crock.

In all the intricate glue ups I have done using CA with wood, plastic, metal, cloth, I have never found CA to be "too brittle"

I have however had numerous joints fail using epoxy , did the same glue up using Ca and not had the joint fail.

I have never had a pen "shatter" when dropped because the ca joint was "too brittle"

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#8

Thanks Peter,

Ron in Drums PA

>Just the info I needed

Re: Using different glues on segemented turnings?

#9

Re: Thanks Peter,

Peter Hyde

>Sorry it was so long winded :-) As a warning to all epoxy users it is possible to get sensitized to the stuff. After 3 years of boat work using dust masks and barrier creams on all exposed skin, I am now unable to get near the stuff because the fumes attack my eyelids and nasal passages, so beware! Use complete cover-up and a proper sealed face shield as well as rubber gloves.