>I watched some turning videos on YouTube this weekend and noticed something. Most of the turners adjusted the tool rest without turning the lathe off. This is NOT something I do. But I�m wondering how unsafe others think this practice is, so on a scale of one to ten (helpful guide below), how dangerous is this?
10 (similar to juggling chainsaws that are running)
9
8
7
6
5 (high likelihood of damaging the work piece, low likelihood of damaging the turner)
4
3
2
1 (similar to petting kittens, you�ll probably get scratched, but so what)
>Troy I give it a 6 or 7 but in reality many of us do it. When I'm nervous about getting hurt of damaging the piece I stop the lathe. When I turn my mirrors I constantly adjust the tool rest and rarely turn the lathe off.
>Adjusting the tool rest with the lathe running is like any other aspect of woodworking. If you know what the potential dangers and are thoughtful about what you are doing, the probabilities of bad things happening are low. If you are stupid, careless, or in a hurry, the probabilities of injury are near 100%.
It all depends on the skill (and confidence) of the turner. For many spindle projects, I don't even turn off the lathe...just mount the blank "live" (Steb centers rule!).
>Once you are an experienced turner I would give it a 3-6 depending on the piece you are working. On spindle turning once it is rounded it would be near the low end, on uneven pieces such as large bowls and hollow forms the danger to the piece and the turner would go up. For a beginner - always stop the lathe. This is one of those things that falls under "Work in your comfort zone".
>Hi Troy, much like supporting a spindle turning with your hand, moving the tool rest while running is never recommended. However, I break both rules.
When I'm in production mode, there just isn't time to constantly stop and start the machine in order to adjust the rest...during a demo, I always shut the machine off as a precaution.
A word of caution to all turners. Experience on the lathe, or any other woodworking equipment, does NOT help in preventing accidents! The worst accidents I've personally witnessed all involved veteran professional woodworkers. There is a tendency to become lax in our safety procedures as we get comfortable with machinery....and attempt operations that the novice would not even dream of. In every case....things went bad so quickly, the operator never saw the accident coming! If you are going to move the rest with the lathe running, do so fully aware of the possible consequences.
I think one major potential problem with toolrests is the threaded tool posts with interchangeable rests....I once had a curved rest come loose from the post while working on the bottom of a 4-legged hollow form. The rest swung inward, shearing the legs off, while grabbing my gouge, which ended up imbedded in my left hand. I never saw that one coming either. The rest is now welded to the post.
>Until the piece is round the lathe should be stopped before moving the rest; once the blank is round and there are no corners to hang then why stop the lathe? If the toolrest rubs the round blank so what? There has to be an uneven spot to hang the toolrest.
>I adjust mine with the lathe on, but it all depends on the piece, and what my intentions are. I think a beginner should turn the lathe off, until they get used to the controls of the toolrest, and instinctly know how much pressure, or what movement, is required to adjust it to the position you want it.
>While I would love to say that I always stop the lathe when adjusting the tool rest, I can't. I usually don't stop it while making adjustments unless the piece is not round and the wood is spinning close to it. Then I find it much easier to judge the space between.
This is what I do, it is not a recommendation for others.
>I am not as experienced as most of those posting, but I usually turn off the lathe. I can't say I always do, I have caught myself not turning off.
I will say this. My lathe has a braking resistor. The time it takes to stop is a few seconds. I figure if I save a trip to the hospital or a blown up piece, I have saved more time than I could save by not turning off the lathe.
>had the lathe off, adjusted but forgot to lock the banjo. Spinning chunk of oak snapped a solid 1" neck like it was a candy cane.
In my experience, I suggest that any turner develops a "method of work"- i.e., a way that they ALWAYS do something (within their abilities). If you always stop the lathe, then always stop the lathe. If you always replace the wrench in one spot, always replace it in the same spot (so you don't find it flying seconds later...)
For the record, I mostly turn it off when working, since it's the "safer option". I don't turn for speed...
>I teach my students to always turn of the lathe before moving the rest. It's a good safety lesson for beginners. However, I rarley turn off the lathe. I am used to how my holder slides on the way's.
If you keep the ways well waxed,(not oiled!) you can control the movement a lot better.
>I'm with TD on this, if the piece is round it's much safer to leave the lathe on. But if a novice or non-turner is looking on, I would stop the lathe. Also for the early stages of a turning, especially a bowl roughout.
Now, without an audience, in the privacy of my own shop, and a sharp enough toolrest, I can do what I want. So there ;)
>I remember reading a post somewhere about never adjust the tool rest while the lathe is running because it makes a lousy scraper. That being said, I always adjust the tool rest and banjo while the lathe is running. However, I turn the lathe (PM 3520 A) off and on by adjusting the speed control, not with the on/off button. I start with the lathe at about 20 rpm, move the banjo, adjust the tool rest, then lock it down, and then turn the speed up to where I want it. If the wood does hit the tool rest at slow speed, no damage. Of course I do keep my fingers where they belong.
>If the piece is not round and has some corners still on it, it's not a good idea. If its smooth and round then it's not nearly as likely to catch and slam the tool rest down. Even so, I don't advise doing this and I don't do it very often...but have been know to be lazy and move it while the piece is spinning. But never when the piece is still out of round. I saw the hand of somebody who did this once while holding the post of the tool rest when it caught and slammed down and pinched that part of the hand between the thumb and fore finger and it wasn't pretty. Yuk!