Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Yellow Birch Jar

Posts

Yellow Birch Jar

#1

Yellow Birch Jar

Phil Powell------WebKitFormBoundaryfz0uMQK+XT0F+GN

>This jar is made up of a yellow birch burl and a maple rim & lid combination. This is

number 7 in the series of covered jars. Because of the shape and size of the burl the

jar turned out tall and thin. I do enjoy making these!


img

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

#2

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Phil,

I love it until I get to the lid. It looks like it is a completely different style from the main vessel. The rim makes it look like a classic vase, but the lid just looks stuck on and doesn't flow. Your workmanship looks top notch. Of course this is just an opinion and one from someone who hasn't turned much for 8 or 9 months.

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

#3

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

Ron McKinley

>In my view the lid over powers the jar. Lid needs to be a little smaller and stained dark to match the jar. .....Ron

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

#4

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

Bill Crommett

>Like the others, I think you should throw out the lid and make a nice dark or black collar. Leave the vase open.

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

#5

Re: Yellow Birch Jar

George Van

>Phil, knowing your background I would like to know the history of this design. I am sure it is a style that has been done in past centuries?