Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Spindle gouge on bowls?

Posts

Spindle gouge on bowls?

#1

Spindle gouge on bowls?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I've been playing around with this for a short while using a spindle gouge ground to 60 degrees like a bowl gouge with a secondary bevel to reduce the length of the orginal bevel.

My first impression is as a finishing tool it's easy to control inside and outside a bowl. The flute shape shears the wood like a U shape bowl gouge rolled on it's side.

Who else has tried this before and what did you discover?

Allen Neighbors, your other post made me think all work and no play is not heathly... made shavings all night.


img

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#2

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls? 

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>


img

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#3

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Doug,

That looks like a bowl gouge in the pic. Is that one of your spindle gouges? The flute looks deep.

Also, got my first prototype gouge handle made for the tool I bought from you. So far it is working well.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#4

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>It's the spindle gouge in this picture, 3rd from the left.


img

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#5

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

john lucas

>Doug I've ground secondary bevels on all of the tools I got from you ( and others) The shorter bevel makes it quicker to sharpen especially if you use different grind angles so you have to change the length of the Oneway jig. If you don't absolutely nail the distance you may not get a perfect grind and have to remove more metal.

I also like the shorter bevel because it lets you get into tighter places. I think this is really important on the spindle gouges because they are so thick. I do the secondary grind freehand, not trying for anything pretty because it doesn't matter. Some people put a spacer in the Oneway cradle so it grinds perfectly. I also add a 3rd small grind on the very bottom of the bevel. This eliminates the sharp corner so you don't bruise the wood. This is really important in the bowl gouge. I usually do this after I sharpen, I turn off the grinder and just touch the corners while the wheel is slowing down. You don't have to turn it off of course it's just a habit I've gotten into.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#6

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

George Van

>Doug, I learned the spindle gouge method from Russ Hurt. In his video he makes the comment after turning for quite a while that he owns a bowl gouge so he should probably use one in the video. I also had a turner from the Michigan UP teach me to use the continental forged spindle gouge which I still use quite frequently. I turn a lot of spalted wood and the continental gouge reduces or eliminates tear out producing fine curls. I like John's idea of a third bevel to eliminate bruising. I do like the heavy look of your spindle gouge, I will have to order one and take it for a test drive. Much cheaper than being hooked on new cars!

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#7

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Bill Neddow

>Richard Raffan uses spindle gouges extensively when he is turning bowls, especially for finishing cuts. He refers to them as "shallow" gouges, as opposed to the bowl gouges which he refers to ad "deep gouges". As for grinding double or triple bevels, Stuart Mortimer is a firm believer in this. His gouges are ground convex as he finds this is far more forgiving than trying to work with a concave-ground bevel, with a relatively sharp corner at the bottom. It makes adjusting the angle of the tool to get the perfect cut easier, as there is always some bevel touching somewhere.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#8

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Clay Foster

>The deep fluted bowl gouge is a fairly recent development in wood turning. Before its invention, all bowls were turned with a spindle gouge because that's all turners had.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#9

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Bill thanks, I knew this wasn't a ground breaking idea but didn't know who used a shallow flute on a bowl. I'll find a picture of his grind to see what he does.

A freehand grind will produce the convex shape I think your talking about, Johannes Michelsen teaches a freehand grind on his 1 inch shallow gouge.

The thought with using a jig to grind this shape is so it's easy to discribe and anyone could reproduce the same shape.

So far the cut is very clean but the secondary bevel needs to be increased becaused it's burnishing the wood. Maybe the 60 degree nose angle is not right and should be decreased to 50-55???

The secondary bevel was made by adding a 5/8 long spacer behind the leg on the Vari-grind. This will be increased.

This weekend I promise I'll work on the skews and scrapers.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#10

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Clay, you are so right we/I forget the about the past. Bowl gouges change turning in a big way. Tearout is still the problem we have with a bowl gouge even if the tool is rolled so the flute is closed (well I can't do it). I found the spindle gouge has a nice flute shape to shear the wood and prevent tearout (even I could do this).

I like this hobby because there's always a challange.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#11

Steve Kubien

Raffan's book

Steve Kubien

>That looks a lot like the type of grind Raffan uses in his books, at least to my eyes.

Steve Kubien -who is still in love with his Thompson gouges.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#12

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Gordon Seto

>I always have my spindle gouge grind at 35� to 40�, the bevel will bottom out unless the bowl is shallow.

May be I should buy more spindle gouges from you and experiment with the blunter angle.

Does that has the same effect of using the traditional grind bowl gouge with the flute pointing up? The traditional grind is almost vertical; therefore it is cutting at very high shear angle. Even though we are only using the left wing (on the inside) of the gouge, but the right wing also provide some rigidity to the tool.

Doug, no matter what, we still need another bowl gouge for traditional grind.

BTW, I like your web site design, not too colorful but classy.

Gordon

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#13

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

Bill Neddow

>Doug, there is very little new in the world of woodturning. But there are a lot of adaptations of already existing ideas that result in significant advances. One new thing, I think, was the introduction of the bowl gouge in the 1960s, conceived by Bob Stocksdale and manufactured by Gerry Glaser. For adaptations, think of the fingernail grind on the bowl gouges. I though it had been dreamed up by a number of people at roughly the same time. (In Ireland, it is call the Liam O'Neil grind, or Irish Grind. In America, it is called the Ellsworth grind.) And, possibly, it was. But I had a chance to look at a woodturning book published in the 1880s, and there, in an illustration, was a fingernail grind (or O'Neil, or Ellsworth) on a spindle gouge! Thus, it may have been an adaptation.

Whether an invention or an adaptation, it is still a wonderful addition to our tool chest.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#14

Henry Taylor makes a Shallow Gouge

Craig Daymon

>Doug,

I have an M4 Henry Taylor 9/16" Shallow Gouge that I like a lot. It works well inside or outside and is sometimes useful for spindle work as well. The flute is a little deeper than your spindle gouge, but much less than a traditional bowl gouge. I like the idea. The HT shallow gouge is available in M2 and M4 steel.

http://www.cuttingedgetools.com/Onlinecat.htm/WebCatalog/M4Taylor.html

There is also a roughing gouge, referred to by Packard as a German Spindle Gouge and probably the same as the Rude Olsolnik Shallow Roughing Gouge, that I like a lot too and have used as a shear scraper inside bowls quite effectively. (NOTE: Although this is a roughing gouge, the design makes it much safer for this than a traditional roughing gouge. I also hold it by the tool steel about an inch or 2 from the bevel when using it to shear scrape.)

http://www.cuttingedgetools.com/Onlinecat.htm/WebCatalog/Roughing%20Gouge.html

-Craig

P.S. You stated in an e-mail that you were e-mail that you were going to be making Skew Chisels as well. Do you plan to round the edges? (Please?) My P&N skew has the short bevel side rounded, but not the long and sometimes I like to lead with the long. I can fix it on the grinder, but it would be nice if I didn't have to do so.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#15

Packard German Spindle Gouge *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>The largest size Packard GSG is 1.25", which is probably why I feel safe shear scraping with it. The Rud Osolnik gouge is 1.75", a bit big, but probably still safe used the way I described. This is typically a shear scrape from the center drawing up the side to the rim, not moving from rim to center.

-Craig


Packard German Spindle Gouge

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#16

Sorry-meant to put Packard GSG post under previous

Craig Daymon

>Makes more sense there.

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#17

Yes,the short side is rounded.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#18

But not the long side?

Craig Daymon

>Is there a reason not to round the long side? In Darlow's first book, he is using a P&N skew chisel where you can see that he has ground the long side round as well. It's not hard to do myself, but I was just wondering if there is a manufacturing reason or a usage reason to keep one end flat.

-Craig

P.S. Looking forward to getting my gouges from you. (I didn't place the order, it is a B-day present that I know is coming.)

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#19

But not ong side-explained in Alan Lacer DVD

Gordon Seto

>

Re: Spindle gouge on bowls?

#20

Re: But not ong side-explained in Alan Lacer DVD

Craig Daymon

>Gordon,

I think I have Alan's article on the skew, but I don't have the video. I'll check the article to see if he mentions it in there.

-Craig

P.S. Got my Thompson gouges today. Looking forward to putting them to wood.