Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I was thionking about the effect of freezing small turning logs as well as turning blanks. Water expands when it freezes. It would seem that this expansion would cause small cracks as the wood freezes.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I was thionking about the effect of freezing small turning logs as well as turning blanks. Water expands when it freezes. It would seem that this expansion would cause small cracks as the wood freezes.
Re: Question
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I'm always skeptical when people claim improvements from freezing native northern woods. At least around here, the trees freeze solid every winter. When it gets down to -20F, you start to hear popping in the woods from the stresses set up by contraction of the wood.
I've never seen any damage to domestic hardwoods from freezing. During the winter, I often have to let my blanks sit in the shop for a couple of days to thaw before I turn them.
Re: Question
Russ Fairfield
>I tried freezing wood several years ago, and after reading several articles and posts on what a great drying method it was. I was never able to achieve the claimed results.
All of the species that I was using were able to accomodate the 8% expansion from the moisture freezing without any internal damage to the wood. Every attempt I made at freezing wood resulted in more cracks than from air-dried wood. all of the cracking was on the outside from too fast a drying rate, and not internal cracking from expanding water as it froze in the wood. Cutting the wood apart showed that ALL cracking was on the outside surface.
Surface cracking would be the expected result because the "frost free" freezer is the lowest humidity most of us can find, unless we live in the desert. All of the same methods for bagging or coating the wood to reduce the rate of surface evaporation were required to prevent the surface cracking.
I also found that the drying rate of the wood was the same as an equal volume and surface area of ice placed in the freezer, and in the same condition of being bagged or not to restrict surface evaporation. When the ice had evaporated, the wood was dry.
Bottom Line for me: There are better and more efficient ways to dry a piece of wood. A light bulb and a fan in the freezer box is a lot more efficient, faster, and with less cracking than freezing the wood.
Others may get different mileage on this one.
Re: Question
Ron in Drums PA
>I had a log that was freshly cut in the winter, then it sat, covered in snow for longer than a month.
One day I decided to cut a piece to turn a bowl. From the time I took the blank inside to the time I made my first cut it was less than 20 minutes.
That wood turned beautiful, but it HURT!
Those shavings was like getting pelted with a machine gun fill of BBs. OUCH!!
Re: Question
John Lucas
>I've often wondered if freezing really punky wood and turning it while frozen would make it cut cleaner.
Re: Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Thanks for the very interesting responses. I really wasn't thinking drying as much as preserving from blue stain.
Worth a try
Ron in Drums PA
>
Re: Question
Ron in Drums PA
>The sections that I turned in the early spring had some blue stain.
Re: Russ, I use an old refrigerator...
Allen Neighbors
>with a fan and a 60w lightbulb, and you're right, less cracking than any other way I've tried to dry wood.
It should work for that
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>Fungus should be dormant when the wood is frozen. It needs liquid water to grow. It has been my experience that wood decay does not progress during the winter around here. And of course the bugs are dormant or dead as well.
Re: Question
Mac
>Hi Barbara, I suspect that it would at least delay the fungus until you could get at it to turn, and then the drying process should further inhibit the growth.I assume you are talking about holly.I mentioned this to Carol V. and I believe that she tried it.You might ask her.....
Re: Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Actually it is Dogwood. I will probably put it in the curing room off of the big freezer. Right now it is cut up into pieces (ends waxed) small enough for me to pick up and in the small room we enter before we open the freezer door. I didn't have time this morning to do any more than that.
My question was more academic than practical. I started thinking about the water in the wood expanding if frozen. I knew that some turners had frozen wood and one thought led to another.
I have used denatured alcohol to keep holly from staining in the summer. It worked well. I soaked longer than usual. The alcohol seemed to keep the fungus away.
Re: Question
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>Hmmm...I'm not sure Barbara, but I know some people freeze blanks to stop them from spalting and rotting. I would think that the wood would "flex" enough not to crack it?
Re: Question
Carole Valentine
>Mac and Barb, I do have some holly in the freezer. It has not stained in there, but I don't know what will happen when I take it out. I think I will wait until winter to turn it. Last time I checked it had not cracked. I have never seen Dogwood get blue stain like holly does, but my experience with it is fairly limited. I have a dogwood tree that has been down in the woods for about 4 months. I think I will cut some and see if it stains in this VA heat and humidity.
Carole
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Watch out for the hidden holes in the woods.:-)
Re: Carole
Carole Valentine
>No joke! I put a pole in the two that Tom stepped in and they were over 5 feet deep. When I go out there now, I take my hiking staff and poke where I am going to step.
Too darned hot to cut anything up today. Praying for storms tonight.